What if your next blog post was already written, optimized, and published before you even opened your laptop? With the right automation, you can turn ideas into live content in minutes—consistently, effortlessly, and at scale.
Content creation is changing fast. Today’s top bloggers aren’t typing late into the night—they’re running automated systems that write, optimise, and publish for them. The question is, why aren’t you?
Automate Your Blogging – From Idea to Published Post in Minutes
Imagine waking up to find a brand-new, SEO-friendly blog post already live on your site — without lifting a finger. With today’s automation tools, that dream is now a reality. Whether you’re on WordPress, Ghost, Webflow, or any CMS, you can go from raw idea to polished post faster than ever.
Step Inside the Future of Blogging
It starts with a trigger — something that says, “It’s time to create a post.” From there, AI takes over, generating a compelling title, writing engaging SEO-ready content, creating meta descriptions and keyword tags, and even producing image prompts. Then, your CMS connection pushes it live instantly. No late nights. No burnout. Just consistent, high-quality publishing on autopilot.
The Make.com Method – Your Creative Factory
Make.com is ideal for creators who want full control and custom workflows. You begin by creating a new scenario and deciding where your ideas will come from. The trigger could be a manual start, a Google Sheet entry, or an automated pull from RSS feeds or trending topics. Once the topic is ready, it’s sent to OpenAI to produce a fully formatted 1,000-word post complete with title, meta description, and tags. The content is then mapped to your CMS and published instantly. AI can also create optimised slugs, alt text, and featured image ideas. After a single test, the process runs automatically while you focus on growing your audience.
Zapier is the simplest and fastest way to go from idea to published post. A new row in Google Sheets becomes a new blog topic. OpenAI turns that topic into a ready-to-publish post, and WordPress uploads it instantly.
n8n is for those who want maximum flexibility without writing code. You can set up webhook triggers, loops, and conditions, create advanced publishing schedules, and design complex multi-step flows that align perfectly with your content strategy.
Why This Changes the Game
This approach allows you to publish daily without burning out. It can transform fifty ideas into fifty published posts automatically. It keeps you ahead with real-time trending topics and refreshes old posts for instant SEO gains.
Limitations and Smart Checks
While AI-generated content is polished, it should still be human-reviewed for tone, accuracy, and brand fit. Draft mode is a smart option for an editorial safety net. Some integrations may require paid plans, API access, or CMS plugins.
Bottom line: Once set up, your blog runs itself. You remain consistent, maintain visibility, and free up time for the work that actually grows your audience.
Conclusion
While automated content creation tools offer substantial benefits in terms of speed, cost, and scalability, they present real challenges to the authenticity of the information they produce. For audiences and brands that value trust and genuine connection, striking the right balance between AI automation and human creativity remains essential.
Explore more at the Rise & Inspire archive | Tech Insights
Unshakeable Faith: Finding True Security in God Alone
A Biblical Reflection on Psalm 62:6By Johnbritto Kurusumuthu
A Prayer to Begin Our Journey
Almighty God, our unchanging Rock and eternal Fortress, we come before You today acknowledging our deep need for the security that only You can provide. In a world where everything seems to shift and crumble around us, we thank You for being our unshakeable foundation. Open our hearts to understand the profound truth of Your Word today. Help us to release our grip on the false securities we have built for ourselves and learn to rest completely in Your strength. Transform our anxious hearts into confident ones that declare with the psalmist: “I shall not be shaken.” May this time of reflection draw us closer to You and strengthen our faith for the journey ahead. In Jesus’ mighty name, Amen.
Deep Meditation: The Security of the Ages
Picture this moment with me: You stand at the base of a massive mountain, its peak hidden in the clouds above. The winds howl around you, storms rage, but this mountain remains unmoved, unshaken, eternal. This is the image David paints for us in Psalm 62:6. But here’s what makes this even more beautiful—this isn’t just any rock or mountain. This is the living God who knows your name, counts your tears, and holds your future in His hands.
In our fast-paced world of 2025, we’ve become experts at building security systems. We have insurance policies, backup plans, emergency funds, and contingency strategies. Yet despite all our careful planning, how often do we still find ourselves lying awake at night, worried about tomorrow? David discovered something profound: true security isn’t found in what we can control, but in surrendering control to the One who controls everything.
The Hebrew word for “rock” here is sela—not just any stone, but a massive cliff or crag that serves as a natural fortress. When David wrote these words, he likely had memories of hiding in the caves of En Gedi, where the rocky cliffs provided perfect protection from his enemies. But David recognized that even those physical rocks were merely shadows of the ultimate Rock—God Himself.
What storms are raging in your life today? What circumstances are trying to shake your foundation? David’s declaration becomes our declaration: “I shall not be shaken”—not because we’re strong enough to stand, but because we’re anchored to the One who cannot be moved.
The Verse and Its Context
“He alone is my rock and my salvation, my fortress; I shall not be shaken.” – Psalm 62:6 (ESV)
This powerful declaration sits at the heart of Psalm 62, a psalm attributed to David during a time of intense opposition. The entire psalm is structured around the theme of waiting on God and finding rest in Him alone. Verses 1-2 establish the foundation: “For God alone my soul waits in silence; from him comes my salvation.” David then addresses his enemies in verses 3-4, before returning to this magnificent confession of faith in verses 5-6.
The context reveals a man under siege—not just from external enemies, but from the internal battle we all face between trusting God and trusting ourselves. Notice the progression: David moves from “my soul waits” to “I shall not be shaken.” This isn’t passive resignation; it’s active faith that produces unshakeable confidence.
Impact on Faith and Daily Life
This verse transforms how we approach every challenging situation. When your job security feels threatened, Psalm 62:6 reminds you that your true security isn’t in your position but in your God. When relationships disappoint you, this verse points you to the One whose love never fails. When health concerns arise, you remember that your ultimate healing comes from the Great Physician.
But here’s the practical beauty: living from this verse changes your decision-making process entirely. Instead of asking “What’s the safest option?” you begin asking “What honors God?” Instead of “What if this fails?” you ask “How can I trust God through this?” The result isn’t recklessness—it’s the kind of courage that can only come from being anchored to something immovable.
Key Themes and Main Message
The Central Theme: Exclusive Dependence on God
The word “alone” appears three times in this psalm (verses 1, 2, and 5), and it’s the key that unlocks everything. David isn’t saying God is one option among many—he’s declaring that God is the only option that truly matters. This exclusivity isn’t limiting; it’s liberating. When you know where your security lies, you’re freed from the exhausting work of trying to secure yourself.
The Progressive Revelation:
🎉Rock: Speaks to God’s unchanging nature and reliability
🎉Salvation: Points to His active deliverance and rescue
🎉Fortress: Emphasizes His protective presence and defense
The main message reverberates through the ages: In a world of shifting foundations, God alone provides the security our souls desperately crave.
Connection to Our Current Season
As we navigate through the Ordinary Time of the liturgical calendar, this verse speaks powerfully to our daily walk with God. Ordinary Time isn’t “ordinary” because it’s mundane—it’s ordinary because it’s ordered, structured, and purposeful. This is the season where we grow in our day-to-day relationship with Christ, where we learn to find the extraordinary in the seemingly ordinary moments.
Psalm 62:6 becomes our companion for this journey. In the ordinary pressures of work, family, and daily responsibilities, we learn to declare: “He alone is my rock.” In the ordinary struggles with doubt, fear, and uncertainty, we practice saying: “I shall not be shaken.” This season teaches us that our faith isn’t just for Sunday services or crisis moments—it’s the foundation for every ordinary Tuesday, every challenging Thursday, every weary Saturday.
Living Out the Verse: Practical Applications
1. Daily Fortress DeclarationsBegin each morning by speaking this verse aloud. Before you check your phone, before you worry about your schedule, remind your soul where your security lies.
2. The Security AuditWeekly, ask yourself: “What am I trusting in besides God?” Write down your answers honestly. It might be your savings account, your reputation, your health, or your relationships. Then consciously surrender each item to God.
3. Storm Response ProtocolWhen difficulties arise, resist the urge to immediately strategize or worry. Instead, first go to your Rock. Pray, declare His faithfulness, and then proceed with peace.
4. Testimony BuildingKeep a journal of how God has been your rock in specific situations. These become powerful reminders during future storms and encourage others who are struggling.
5. Community FortressShare this verse with someone who’s going through a difficult time. Be God’s voice reminding them of their unshakeable foundation.
Supporting Scriptures
Isaiah 26:4 – “Trust in the Lord forever, for the Lord God is an everlasting rock.”
Matthew 7:24-25 – “Everyone then who hears these words of mine and does them will be like a wise man who built his house on the rock. And the rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and beat on that house, but it did not fall, because it had been founded on the rock.”
1 Corinthians 10:4 – “And all drank the same spiritual drink. For they drank from the spiritual Rock that followed them, and the Rock was Christ.”
Deuteronomy 32:4 – “The Rock, his work is perfect, for all his ways are justice. A God of faithfulness and without iniquity, just and upright is he.”
A Divine Wake-Up Call
His Excellency, the Rt. Rev. Dr. Selvister Ponnumuthan, often reminds us that every verse of Scripture is God’s personal invitation to deeper intimacy with Him. Psalm 62:6 isn’t just information about God—it’s transformation through God. When we truly grasp that He alone is our rock, salvation, and fortress, we stop living as spiritual orphans trying to provide for ourselves and start living as beloved children whose Father owns everything.
The Bishop frequently emphasizes: “Security isn’t about controlling circumstances; it’s about being controlled by the right One.” This verse calls us to examine the foundations we’ve built our lives upon. Are they sand or rock? Are they temporary or eternal? Are they human or divine?
This is your divine wake-up call today: Stop building castles on shifting sand and start building your life on the Rock of Ages.
Dive Deeper: Reflection and Worship
As we continue this journey of reflection, I invite you to watch this powerful worship song that captures the heart of our message today: He alone is my rock and my salvation. Let the music and lyrics wash over your soul as you declare with confidence: “I shall not be shaken.”
Answering Your Questions
Q1: How can I practically “not be shaken” when everything in my life feels chaotic?
Being unshaken doesn’t mean you won’t feel the storms—it means you won’t be moved by them. David himself experienced fear, disappointment, and uncertainty. The key is anchoring your identity and security in God’s character rather than your circumstances. When chaos surrounds you, speak truth to your soul: “My God is still on His throne, still in control, still working for my good.”
Q2: What if I’ve trusted God before and felt disappointed by the outcome?
This is one of faith’s most honest questions. Remember that God being our rock doesn’t mean He’ll always work according to our timeline or preferences. His salvation sometimes looks different than our solutions. David experienced delayed answers, unexpected paths, and outcomes that initially seemed disappointing. Yet he learned that God’s “no” or “wait” is often His greatest mercy. Trust the character of God even when you can’t understand His methods.
Q3: How is this different from just positive thinking or self-help motivation?
The difference is foundational. Positive thinking says, “I am strong enough.” Psalm 62:6 says, “God is strong enough.” Self-help puts the burden on you; this verse puts the burden on God. When you declare “I shall not be shaken,” you’re not claiming personal strength—you’re claiming God’s strength as your own through relationship with Him.
Q4: Can someone be too dependent on God? Shouldn’t we also be responsible and plan?
Biblical dependence on God never eliminates personal responsibility—it elevates it. When you know God is your ultimate security, you’re freed to plan wisely without being paralyzed by anxiety. You work diligently without being driven by fear. You prepare thoughtfully without being consumed by “what if” scenarios. Dependence on God produces the healthiest kind of independence in daily life.
Q5: How do I help my children understand this verse in age-appropriate ways?
Use concrete examples they can grasp. A rock doesn’t move when you push it—God doesn’t change when life gets hard. A fortress keeps enemies out—God protects us from things that want to hurt us. When they face disappointment or fear, remind them: “God is stronger than this problem.” Help them memorize the verse through songs, actions, or drawings. Most importantly, let them see you living from this truth in your own storms.
Word Study: Deeper Meanings
Rock (Hebrew: Sela)This isn’t the word for a small stone you might skip across water. Sela refers to a massive cliff or rocky crag—something that has stood for millennia and will continue standing long after we’re gone. Archaeological evidence shows these rocky fortresses were natural defense systems in ancient Israel. David isn’t comparing God to a pebble; he’s declaring Him to be the eternal mountain that cannot be moved.
Salvation (Hebrew: Yeshuah)This word encompasses rescue, deliverance, safety, and welfare. It’s not just about eternal salvation—though it includes that—but about God’s comprehensive work of making us whole. Every time you see this word, think of God actively working to rescue you from everything that threatens your wellbeing.
Fortress (Hebrew: Misgab)A high place of refuge, literally meaning “to be set on high.” Ancient fortresses were built on elevated ground to provide strategic advantage and safety. When David calls God his misgab, he’s saying God lifts us above our circumstances and gives us His perspective on our situation.
Shaken (Hebrew: Mot)To totter, slip, fall, or be moved from position. The verb form suggests ongoing action—not just a single event but continuous stability. David isn’t claiming he’ll never face difficulties; he’s declaring that difficulties won’t displace him from his position in God.
Wisdom from the Ages
Augustine of Hippo observed: “You have made us for yourself, O Lord, and our hearts are restless until they rest in you.” This restlessness Augustine describes is the very thing Psalm 62:6 addresses—the soul’s search for ultimate security.
Charles Spurgeon wrote: “This is a sweet verse to a believer who is passing through trial. Satan may roar, the world may rage, circumstances may be threatening, but the believer is as fixed as the eternal hills.”
John Calvin noted: “David does not here speak of what he hopes for, but declares what he has already experienced—that in God there is a sure refuge prepared for him.”
Contemporary theologian John Piper reminds us: “The rock-solid security we have in God is not based on our grip on Him, but on His grip on us.”
What You Can Expect from This Reflection
Through this exploration of Psalm 62:6, you will discover how to move from anxiety to assurance, from worry to worship, from self-reliance to God-dependence. You’ll learn practical ways to apply this ancient truth to modern challenges, understand the rich biblical context that makes this verse even more meaningful, and find specific strategies for building your life on the unshakeable foundation of God’s character.
Most importantly, you’ll walk away with a renewed confidence that no matter what storms may come, no matter how unstable the world around you becomes, you have access to a security that transcends circumstances—a Rock that has never failed and never will.
May this reflection serve as a reminder that in a world of shifting sands, you have access to the Rock of Ages. May you find rest for your soul and strength for your journey as you anchor your life in the One who alone is worthy of your complete trust.
Rise & Inspire – Because your foundation determines your future.
Explore more at the Rise & Inspire archive | Wake-Up Calls
“Let go of habits, biases, or beliefs that no longer serve you. Think of it as uninstalling bloatware.”
“Sleep. Meditate. Take a walk. Even software needs restarts to function smoothly.”
Why You’re the Software of Your Own Life (And How to Keep Yourself Updated)
Hook: You know that annoying pop-up on your phone? “Update required to improve performance.” Annoying, sure—but what if you treated yourself with the same urgency?
The Update Mandate: What Happens When You Stagnate
Imagine your brain as an operating system. If you ignore new knowledge, skills, or perspectives, you risk glitches:
👐Reduced Efficiency: Outdated skills slow you down. Think of using a 2010 app in 2025—clunky, frustrating, and incompatible with the world around you.
👐Malfunction Risk: In fast-moving fields like tech, healthcare, or even creative industries, stagnation can mean irrelevance. Ever met someone clinging to “the way things used to be”? That’s a human version of unsupported software.
But unlike software, you’re not a rigid code.
Let’s talk about why that’s your superpower.
Why You’re Not Just a Machine
You Can Improvise Updates Software needs a developer’s patch. You? You can learn from a podcast, a conversation, or even failure. That teacher who figured out Zoom during the pandemic without formal training? That’s you—adapting, hacking, and growing on the fly.
Your “Updates” Boost More Than Functionality Learning isn’t just about staying employable. It’s about mental sharpness, curiosity, and even happiness. Every time you pick up a new skill or idea, you’re not just avoiding obsolescence—you’re building a richer, more resilient you.
You Have Permission to Skip Some Patches Unlike software, you don’t have to accept every update. Specialize deeply in what matters to you. Love woodworking but hate AI? That’s okay. Prioritize depth where it fuels your purpose.
But Here’s the Catch: You’re Human, Not Code
🚶Burnout is a Glitch Software Doesn’t Feel Constant “updating” without rest leads to crashes—exhaustion, cynicism, or worse. Schedule downtime. Let your mind defragment.
🚶Ethics and Emotions Aren’t in the Code Your growth isn’t just about efficiency. It’s about how you use knowledge. A software update can’t teach empathy, integrity, or courage—those updates come from living, reflecting, and choosing wisely.
How to “Update” Yourself (Without Losing Your Humanity)
Final Thought: Yes, you’re like software—in need of updates to thrive in a changing world. But you’re also the developer, the user, andthe purpose. Update yourself, but don’t forget to savor the messy, creative, gloriously human journey of growth.
Now, hit that “refresh” button—your best version is waiting.
Schedule Learning Like It’s a System Patch Block 30 minutes daily for a course, article, or skill. Treat it like a non-negotiable OS update.
Embrace Informal Updates Chat with a colleague. Watch a documentary. Travel. These are your “background downloads”—small, organic ways to grow.
Delete Outdated “Programs” Let go of habits, biases, or beliefs that no longer serve you. Think of it as uninstalling bloatware.
Reboot Regularly Sleep. Meditate. Take a walk. Even software needs restarts to function smoothly.
Sign-off: Keep iterating, Rise&Inspire
P.S. What’s one “update” you’re prioritizing this week? Share it in the comments—accountability works better than any algorithm!
Not necessarily. In one well-known trial, staff working from home were 13 per cent more productive, and a later trial of hybrid working found no loss in performance or promotion. Yet about half of those home workers later chose the office again, for company and for their careers. The office is where we learn how to work; remote work is where we discover whether we have learned it.
In government offices, a file can travel from desk to desk for days, gathering notes and counter-notes before anyone decides anything. In my years of public service, I often saw such a matter settled in a few minutes, when one officer walked across and talked it through with another. No digital tool has quite replaced that short walk to a colleague’s room.
Yet a desk in a busy office has never, by itself, made anyone diligent.
So when today’s prompt asks whether I would rather work from an office or remotely, I do not see a contest between two places. I see two stages of a working life. The office is where we learn how to work. Remote work is where we discover whether we have learned it.
1. What the office teaches that no manual can
The office was always more than a place where files were examined and decisions made. It was where people exchanged ideas, argued over problems and learned from one another.
Much of what a newcomer learns is written in no manual. It is absorbed by watching how a senior colleague receives an anxious visitor, words a delicate note, or decides that a matter can wait a day. The office also gives the day a shape. The journey there and back draws a line between duty and home, and a face across the table reveals hesitation, warmth or worry that a screen rarely captures.
2. What remote work gives
Remote work is one of the genuine gifts of our time. A day that begins without a long struggle through traffic returns that time to work, family or rest. Work now crosses distances that once shut people out: a parent caring for a young child, a person with a disability, a capable graduate in a small town far from any city office.
3. What working from home demands
But working from home removes the scaffolding, and what remains is the worker. No colleague notices a late start or a long lunch. The laptop on the dining table is still open at ten at night. Discipline must now come entirely from within, and the companionship of shared work is harder to find.
The best-known evidence tells this double story. In an experiment at the Chinese travel company Ctrip, led by the Stanford economist Nicholas Bloom, call-centre staff who worked from home four days a week performed 13 per cent better over nine months than their colleagues in the office.1 Yet when the company later let everyone choose, about half of the home workers went back to the office, citing loneliness and worries about promotion. They were typically the ones who had done less well at home. Home suited some and not others, and it quickly showed which was which.
4. An old answer to a new question
None of this is new. Nearly fifteen centuries ago, Saint Benedict honoured in his Rule the hermits who lived alone in the desert, but only those who had first spent a long probation in a monastery, learning from many brothers before going out alone.2 For Benedict, solitude was not a starting point. It was something earned.
India’s ancient schools made the same point from the other side. In the gurukula tradition, the pupil lived in the teacher’s household and learned as much by watching as by listening. Even the word Upanishad came to be explained as “sitting down near”, the pupil seated close to the teacher.3 Wisdom passed from one life to another through nearness.
5. So, does productivity depend on where we work?
Less than the debate suggests. A 2024 study at the same company, now called Trip.com Group, found that staff working from home two days a week performed as well and were promoted as often as colleagues in the office full time, and resigned a third less often.4
For the nurse, the mason, the farmer and the bus conductor, the question never arises; their work is where the people are. For many others, a thoughtful mix of office and home is the wisest arrangement. But the arrangement matters less than what we bring to it.
Looking back on my professional journey, I realise that the quality of work has never depended solely on where it was done. It has depended on commitment, integrity, discipline, competence and a willingness to accept responsibility. A well-equipped office does not make anyone productive, and a quiet room at home does not make anyone independent. The location may change, but the values that define good work remain the same.
6. What I would choose
If I had to express a preference, I would lean towards the office, not for its desks and files, but for the people I learned from there. Yet I would gladly extend the freedom of remote work to those who have already learned what the office teaches, provided their well-being and relationships do not become the price. Technology should help us work better. It should never make us forget that good work is learned in the company of others, and proven when no one is watching.
A question for you
What about you? Where did you learn your best working habits, and if the choice were yours today, would you choose the office, your home, or a mix of both?
Notes for readers
1. Nicholas Bloom, James Liang, John Roberts and Zhichun Jenny Ying, “Does Working from Home Work? Evidence from a Chinese Experiment,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 130, no. 1 (2015): 165–218, https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qju032. The volunteers came from Ctrip’s Shanghai call centre and worked from home four days a week, spending the fifth in the office.
2.The Rule of Saint Benedict, chapter 1, “The Kinds of Monks.” Benedict of Nursia (c. 480–c. 547) wrote the Rule in the sixth century, and Benedictine communities still live by it. English text: Saint John’s Abbey, https://saintjohnsabbey.org/rule.
3. The explanation of upanishad as “sitting down near” (upa, near; ni, down; sad, to sit) is old and widely repeated, but modern scholars hold that the word originally meant “connection” or “equivalence.” See “Upanishad,” Encyclopaedia Britannica, https://www.britannica.com/topic/Upanishad. A gurukula was the traditional school in which pupils lived with their teacher’s family.
4. Nicholas Bloom, Ruobing Han and James Liang, “Hybrid Working from Home Improves Retention without Damaging Performance,” Nature 630 (2024): 920–925, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-07500-2. The six-month trial, run in 2021 and 2022, involved 1,612 employees; performance and promotions were tracked for up to two years.
John Britto Kurusumuthu
Rise & Inspire · riseandinspire.co.in
In response to the WordPress Daily Writing Prompt, 17 November 2026: Would you rather work from an office or remotely?
A favourite is something we discover, not something we owe. And sometimes the thing we treasure most was never on the screen at all.
John Britto Kurusumuthu | Rise & Inspire | 16 November 2026 | 7-minute read
The Short Answer No. Many thoughtful people cannot name a single favourite film, and that is entirely normal. A favourite is a conclusion we reach through repeated, personal encounter, not an obligation we owe anyone. What matters more is whether stories, on the screen or in life, can still move us.
Opening Scene
Why I Cannot Name My Favourite Movie of All Time
“Favourite movie of all time?”
It sounds like the easiest question in the world. For me, it is one of the hardest.
That is no small admission where I live. In South India, cinema is close to a public faith: fan clubs, first-day-first-show queues, film dialogues quoted at weddings and tea stalls. Film stars here have gone on to become chief ministers, most famously M. G. Ramachandran and J. Jayalalithaa in Tamil Nadu and N. T. Rama Rao in Andhra Pradesh.1 In such a place, a person without a favourite film can seem to have missed something important.
I have considered that honestly. I do not believe I have.
Reel One
Why Does “Favourite of All Time” Feel Like a Test?
“Of all time” is a heavy phrase. It asks not simply what we enjoy, but what we would place above everything else, permanently. Many people have a ready answer, and I respect that enthusiasm, even though I do not share it.
Part of the weight is social. In Distinction (1979), his landmark study of French tastes in music, art, food and film, the sociologist Pierre Bourdieu observed that “taste classifies, and it classifies the classifier.”2 When we name a favourite, we are quietly being sorted: cultured or ordinary, serious or light, one of us or not. I touched on a cousin of this idea when I asked whether the weirdest movie is really on the screen: what we say about a film often reveals more about us than about the film.
So some answers, I suspect, are borrowed: the respected classic, the title one is expected to name, the film that sounds good in conversation. There is nothing wrong with loving a classic. The trouble begins only when we name it because we feel we should.
I believe personal preferences should never become obligations. A favourite is a conclusion we reach after years of returning to something. It is not a certificate we must produce on demand.
Reel Two
What Do Good Films Give Us?
None of this is a complaint against films. A good film slows us down. It makes us notice a face, a silence, a hesitation we would hurry past in real life. Films carry their own storyteller’s toolkit, as I explored when comparing the techniques of novels and films: they hand us a whole world of sight and sound at once.
Indian aesthetic thought understood this power long before cameras existed. The Natyashastra, the ancient Sanskrit treatise on drama traditionally attributed to the sage Bharata, placed rasa, the “taste” of an emotion, at the centre of performance. Later thinkers, notably Anandavardhana in the ninth century and Abhinavagupta in the tenth and eleventh, used a word for the ideal spectator: the sahridaya, literally the “like-hearted” person, whose feelings answer to what is shown.3
That is the real gift of any story: it trains us to be sahridaya. The question is whether the screen is the only place where such a heart is trained.
Reel Three
What Was I Really Treasuring?
The closest I have come to naming a favourite is Life Is Beautiful, Roberto Benigni’s 1997 film. It arrived in our home some years after its release, on the recommendation of my father, who was not by disposition a man given to cinema. When it ended, neither of us spoke for a long time. Earlier this year, when a prompt asked which film I would watch again for the first time, I finally understood what I wanted back. I wrote then:
The film I can rewatch. The evening I cannot.
That sentence explains my hesitation better than any argument. In his 1935 essay “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction”, the German critic Walter Benjamin observed that film, the new art of his time, is reproducible by its very nature: every screening offers the same frames in the same order. Yet even the most perfect copy, he argued, lacks the original’s “presence in time and space”.4
A film can be copied endlessly. The evening around it has no copy. Perhaps, when we name a favourite film, we are often naming an evening: the person beside us, a season of life, a version of ourselves we can no longer visit.
Reel Four
Where Do Stories Live When the Screen Goes Dark?
A favourite is the habit of returning. Life asks for the discipline of not missing.
Most of the stories I carry were never filmed: a shopkeeper’s patience with a difficult customer, a student’s face at the moment of understanding, a friend whose voice softens when he speaks of a parent who is gone. No director arranged these scenes, yet they hold everything a film tries to hold. Even a day that looks entirely ordinary can carry quiet significance for anyone paying attention.
Christian spirituality knows this discipline well. Brother Lawrence, the seventeenth-century Carmelite lay brother who worked for years in the kitchen of a Paris monastery, said that amid its noise, with several people calling for different things at once, he possessed God as tranquilly as when he knelt in prayer.5 The sahridaya of Indian aesthetics and the monk at his pots are describing the same capacity: a heart awake to what is in front of it. Our kitchen may be a bus stop, a classroom or a dinner table.
Reel Five
How Can You Practise This Tonight?
You need not give up cinema to take something from this. Two small practices are enough.
Answer honestly. The next time someone asks for your favourite film, book or song, give the true answer, even if it is “I don’t have one yet.” Taste that is allowed to grow slowly is usually truer than taste produced on demand.
Replay one unrecorded scene. Before you sleep tonight, recall one moment from your day that no camera captured: a gesture, a sentence, a face. Replay it once in your mind and ask why it mattered. That is the one rerun life allows.
Research on a similar habit is encouraging. In a widely cited 2005 study, the psychologist Martin Seligman and his colleagues asked participants to write down, each night for one week, three things that had gone well and why. Those who did so reported greater happiness and fewer depressive symptoms for up to six months.6 I have written before about a gentler version of this ritual: one line of gratitude each night.
Closing Credits
The Story Worth Watching
Having a favourite movie is wonderful. Not having one is equally acceptable. What matters is keeping the heart of a sahridaya, ready to be moved wherever the story happens to be playing.
I may not have a favourite movie, but I certainly appreciate a good story. And the best of them, I find, are rarely the ones I can rewatch.
Your Turn
What About You?
Do you have a film that has stayed in your heart through the years? If so, is it the film you treasure, or the evening around it? Or, like me, do you find your favourite scenes outside the cinema hall? I would love to hear your thoughts in the comments.
Every one of us has a different story to tell. Perhaps the most interesting story is the one we are living ourselves.
For Quick Reference
Questions Readers Ask
Is it normal not to have a favourite movie?
Yes. Favourites usually grow out of repeated, personal encounters with a film, and many people never have, or never seek, that kind of encounter. Not having a favourite says nothing about your intelligence or taste. It may simply mean your most meaningful stories come from elsewhere: books, music, faith, nature or the people around you.
Why is “What is your favourite movie of all time?” such a hard question?
“Of all time” asks for one permanent ranking, while our tastes change as we age. The question also carries social weight. As the sociologist Pierre Bourdieu argued, our tastes classify us in the eyes of others, so the question can feel more like a test than a conversation.
Why do favourite films often feel so personal?
Because we rarely remember a film alone. We remember who we watched it with, what we were going through and who we were at the time. The film can be rewatched endlessly, but the circumstances of that first viewing cannot, and that is often what we are really treasuring.
How can I notice the stories in everyday life?
Slow down and pay attention to people and small moments. Before sleeping, recall one unrecorded scene from your day and reflect on why it mattered. Research on similar nightly reflection exercises, such as the “three good things” practice, links them to greater happiness over time.
End Credits
Notes and Sources
Encyclopaedia Britannica, “M. G. Ramachandran”. Britannica notes that he was the first actor to become a chief minister in India, followed by N. T. Rama Rao in Andhra Pradesh (1983) and J. Jayalalithaa in Tamil Nadu (1991). https://www.britannica.com/biography/M-G-Ramachandran
Pierre Bourdieu, Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste, trans. Richard Nice (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1984), p. 6. First published in French in 1979. Catalogue record: https://search.worldcat.org/oclc/10323218
National Institute of Open Schooling, Natyakala (Course 285), Lesson 8, “Concept of Sahridaya”, which notes that the term is used extensively by Anandavardhana and Abhinavagupta: https://nios.ac.in/media/documents/285-Natyakala/English/Ch-8T.pdf. See also Kapila Vatsyayan, Bharata: The Nāṭyaśāstra (New Delhi: Sahitya Akademi, 1996).
Brother Lawrence (Nicholas Herman of Lorraine, 1611–1691), The Practice of the Presence of God, compiled and published shortly after his death. Christian Classics Ethereal Library edition: https://www.ccel.org/ccel/lawrence/practice.html
Martin E. P. Seligman, Tracy A. Steen, Nansook Park and Christopher Peterson, “Positive Psychology Progress: Empirical Validation of Interventions”, American Psychologist 60, no. 5 (2005): 410–421. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.60.5.410
A Note on Terms
First-day-first-show: South Indian English for the very first public screening of a new film on its release day, often attended by its most devoted fans.
Rasa: in Indian aesthetics, the emotional “flavour” or essence that a performance awakens in its audience.
Sahridaya: Sanskrit for the responsive, “like-hearted” spectator or reader who can genuinely savour that emotion.
John Britto Kurusumuthu
Rise & Inspire · riseandinspire.co.in
In response to the WordPress Daily Writing Prompt, 16 November 2026: Favourite movie of all time?
Not the letters, the long talks or the unplanned visits themselves, but the effort they once demanded. Why that effort carried the message, and how to bring some of it back.
John Britto Kurusumuthu · 15 November 2026 · Daily Prompts · 9-minute read
THE SHORT ANSWER What most of us miss about the old days is not the objects or customs themselves, but the effort they required. A handwritten letter, an unhurried conversation, a festival prepared together and an unannounced visit all cost time and trouble, and that cost told the other person they mattered. Convenience removed the cost, and much of the message went with it. The answer is not to reject technology, but to choose some of that effort freely.
A letter from a distant relative once took a week or more to reach us. It came on a pale blue inland letter card, every inch of it filled, the last few lines squeezed sideways into the margins because the writer had run out of space long before running out of things to say.
Now the same news arrives in a second. Nobody writes in the margins any more.
Today’s WordPress prompt asks what I miss from the old days. The easy answer is a list: handwritten letters, unhurried conversations, festivals that gathered everyone, visits without appointments. Anyone who remembers life before the internet could write that list without pausing. I miss everything on it. But the longer I sit with the question, the less comfortable the honest answer becomes.
What I miss is not the things themselves. It is the trouble they took.
Convenience did not take away our letters, our conversations or our visits. It took away their cost. And without our noticing, the cost had been carrying the message.
1. Handwritten letters mattered because they were slow
Someone had to find paper, sit down, think, write without a delete key, walk to the post box and then wait. The reader knew all of this. So a letter carried more than information; it carried the hours its writer had given. That is why letters were kept for years in drawers and tin boxes, and why almost nobody keeps a text message.
Psychologists have a name for part of this. In a 2004 series of experiments, people rated the same poem and the same paintings more highly, and judged the paintings to be worth more, when they were told the work had taken longer to make. The researchers called it the effort heuristic: we read effort as a sign of worth (Kruger et al., 2004). A later study found that people who wrote letters of gratitude consistently underestimated how happy their recipients would feel and how surprised they would be by what the letter said, and overestimated how awkward it would make them feel (Kumar & Epley, 2018).
The letter we hesitate to write is usually worth more than we think. Gratitude, as an earlier Rise & Inspire post argued, is a way of living rather than a passing feeling, and a letter is one of its most lasting forms.
2. Conversations lingered because there was nowhere else to go
No screen waited in anyone’s pocket. Often nothing important was discussed, yet those evenings brought people closer. We listened, laughed, disagreed and understood one another. Being together was itself the pleasure. The mobile phone did not end conversation. It simply gave every conversation an exit.
There is some evidence that the exit matters even when no one uses it. In two experiments at the University of Essex, pairs of strangers who talked with a mobile phone merely lying nearby felt less close to each other, and in a meaningful conversation trusted each other less, than pairs who had a notebook in the same place (Przybylski & Weinstein, 2013). The finding should be held lightly: a larger replication in 2021 found the effect harder to reproduce (Linares & Sellier, 2021). Yet most of us need no laboratory to tell a friend who is listening from a friend who is waiting for a notification. Learning to recognise when it is time to unplug is part of being present.
3. Festivals united us because they needed many hands
Cleaning, cooking, decorating, preparing for worship: the work took days and many people. Togetherness was not an optional extra; it was the only way the festival could happen at all. A traditional Kerala holiday feast, with its many dishes and family recipes handed down the years, was never one person’s work.
When a celebration can be ordered, delivered and photographed, it needs fewer people, and so it gathers fewer.
4. Unannounced visits were precious because they were a risk
To arrive without warning was to say: I came because I wanted to see you, not because it fitted a calendar. You might find your friend away, or busy, or halfway through a meal. You went anyway. A visit was not an interruption; it was an expression of affection.
Friendship has always run on this kind of spending. The communication researcher Jeffrey Hall estimated that it takes roughly 50 hours together to turn an acquaintance into a casual friend, around 90 hours to become friends, and more than 200 hours to become close friends. Hours spent working side by side counted for much less than time spent simply enjoying each other’s company (Hall, 2019). The unannounced visit was one of the ways those hours were found. As I wrote recently, growing older has changed how I understand friendship: it is tested less by enjoyment than by whether it endures.
The ledger of the old days
Set side by side, the four memories read like entries in an account book. Each one cost something, and the cost was the message.
What we did
What it cost
What it told the other person
Wrote a letter by hand
An evening of writing and a week of waiting
You were worth my time
Talked without hurry
An evening with nowhere else to be
You have my full attention
Prepared a festival together
Days of work by many hands
We belong to one another
Visited without warning
A journey, with no promise of finding anyone at home
I came only to see you
What older traditions already knew
None of this is a modern discovery. Kalidasa’s Meghaduta imagines an exiled lover who asks a passing monsoon cloud to carry his message to his wife in the distant Himalayas: surely the slowest postal service ever described, and still read some fifteen centuries later. The classical Tamil poets went further and gave waiting a landscape of its own. Mullai, the forest country named after the jasmine, is where a woman waits patiently for a beloved who promised to return with the rains.
Hospitality, too, was built around the unexpected. The Taittiriya Upanishad teaches atithi devo bhava, “let the guest be as a god to you”, and the Sanskrit word for guest, atithi, is traditionally explained as one who comes without a fixed day. Genesis describes Abraham sitting at his tent door in the heat of the day and running to welcome three strangers he had not expected. Japanese tea masters speak of ichigo ichie, “one time, one meeting”: no gathering can ever be repeated, so give it your whole attention.
Different lands, different centuries, one shared insight: what costs us something tells the other person they matter.
Why we feel nostalgic, and why the feeling is worth heeding
The word itself has an instructive history. Nostalgia was coined in 1688 by Johannes Hofer, a medical student at Basel, from the Greek nostos, homecoming, and algos, pain. He used it to describe the homesickness of Swiss soldiers serving far from home, and for a long time afterwards doctors treated it as a disease.
Modern research tells a kinder story. In a series of studies, psychologists at the University of Southampton and the University of Missouri found that nostalgic memories usually place us among the people we love, that nostalgia is often triggered by low mood and loneliness, and that it strengthens our sense of social connection (Wildschut et al., 2006). The ache for the old days, in other words, is often an ache for one another.
That ache is widespread. In 2025 the World Health Organization’s Commission on Social Connection reported that about one in six people worldwide is affected by loneliness, which it linked to an estimated 871,000 deaths a year (World Health Organization, 2025). Strong relationships, as the science of connection consistently shows, are not a luxury but part of a healthy life.
The other side of the ledger: were the old days really better?
Every ledger has two columns, and honesty requires reading both.
Memory is a generous editor. In a well-known 1997 study, people who went on a European trip, a Thanksgiving holiday or a three-week cycling tour in California remembered those experiences more fondly afterwards than they had rated them at the time (Mitchell et al., 1997). Psychologists call this the rosy view. Some of the warmth we remember was added later.
Slowness also had its victims. A letter carrying news of an illness sometimes arrived after the funeral. Much of the festive warmth of those years rested on the unseen labour of women in hot kitchens. The unannounced guest was easy to welcome only because someone was always at home to make the tea. Technology has lifted real burdens. A grandparent who sees a grandchild’s face across an ocean every Sunday has gained something no inland letter could give.
So the answer is not to go back. As an earlier post on this site put it, we cannot truly move forward while clinging to the past. The answer is to choose the cost freely, instead of letting it fall on someone else.
Settling the account: how to bring back the right kind of effort
None of this requires giving up the phone or the calendar. It requires spending a little effort on purpose.
Write one letter a year, by hand, to someone who would never expect it. The research suggests it will mean more to them than you imagine.
When a friend comes over, put the phone in another room, not face down on the table. In two experiments with nearly 800 people, those whose phones were in another room performed best on demanding tests of memory and attention, and those whose phones lay face down on the desk performed worst (Ward et al., 2017).
Do one festival task the slow way, together, even when it could be bought ready-made.
Visit someone for no particular reason. If courtesy now asks for a message first, keep the message short and the visit long.
Spent, not merely sent
The old days were not warmer because people were better. They were warmer because affection had to be spent, not merely sent.
We cannot bring back yesterday. But we can still pay yesterday’s price, gladly, for the people we love.
A THOUGHT TO CARRY WITH YOU
Progress makes life convenient. The effort we freely give one another is what makes it meaningful.
What about you?
What do you miss from the old days? And if you look closely, is it the thing itself you miss, or the effort someone once made for you through it?
Share your memories in the comments. Your story may help someone else rediscover a kind of care worth keeping.
Frequently asked questions
Why do we miss the old days?
Research suggests that nostalgia is often triggered by loneliness or low mood, and that nostalgic memories usually centre on close relationships. What we miss is frequently not the period itself but the connection and attention we associate with it, much of which came from the effort that slower ways of living required.
Is nostalgia good or bad for you?
In moderation, mostly good. Studies find that nostalgia tends to lift mood, strengthen feelings of social connection and support self-esteem (Wildschut et al., 2006). It becomes unhelpful when it turns into a reason to reject the present rather than a guide to improving it.
Were the old days really better?
Not simply. Memory tends to soften past difficulties, a pattern researchers call the rosy view. Slower times also carried real costs, from delayed news to unequal household labour. Some things were genuinely better, above all the attention people gave one another, and those are worth keeping.
Does a phone on the table really affect a conversation?
It may. One influential study found that the mere presence of a phone reduced feelings of closeness during meaningful conversations, although later replications have been mixed. Separate research shows that a visible phone draws on attention even when it is not being used. Putting it in another room is the simplest safeguard.
How can I bring old-fashioned connection into modern life?
Choose small acts of effort on purpose: write an occasional handwritten letter, keep phones out of sight during time with others, prepare part of a celebration together instead of buying it ready-made, and visit people simply because you want to see them.
Notes for readers
Inland letter card. A prepaid letter sheet sold by India Post for domestic mail, which folds and seals to form its own envelope.
Meghaduta (The Cloud Messenger). A Sanskrit lyric poem by Kalidasa, generally dated to the fourth or fifth century CE. An exiled yaksha, an attendant of Kubera, the god of wealth, asks a monsoon cloud to carry his message from Ramagiri in central India to his wife in Alaka, in the Himalayas.
Mullai. Classical Tamil love poetry of the Sangam age (roughly the early centuries CE) sets each poem in one of five symbolic landscapes, a scheme codified in the ancient grammar Tolkappiyam. Mullai, the forest and pasture country named after the jasmine flower, stands for patient waiting, usually in the rainy season, when an absent husband has promised to return.
Atithi devo bhava. From the Taittiriya Upanishad (Shiksha Valli 1.11.2), a text of the Yajur Veda. The reading of atithi as “one who comes without a fixed day” is a traditional explanation rather than a settled etymology.
Abraham and the three strangers. Genesis 18:1–8.
Ichigo ichie. A Japanese expression from the tea ceremony tradition, associated with the sixteenth-century tea master Sen no Rikyu and set down in writing by Ii Naosuke in Chanoyu Ichie Shu (1858).
References
Hall, J. A. (2019). How many hours does it take to make a friend? Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 36(4), 1278–1296. https://doi.org/10.1177/0265407518761225
Hofer, J. (1688). Dissertatio medica de nostalgia, oder Heimwehe [Medical dissertation on nostalgia]. University of Basel. English translation: Anspach, C. K. (1934). Medical dissertation on nostalgia by Johannes Hofer, 1688. Bulletin of the Institute of the History of Medicine, 2(6), 376–391.
Kalidasa. (2017). Meghadutam: The cloud message (S. Reddy, Trans.). Penguin Classics. (Original work c. fourth–fifth century CE)
Kruger, J., Wirtz, D., Van Boven, L., & Altermatt, T. W. (2004). The effort heuristic. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 40(1), 91–98. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0022-1031(03)00065-9
Kumar, A., & Epley, N. (2018). Undervaluing gratitude: Expressers misunderstand the consequences of showing appreciation. Psychological Science, 29(9), 1423–1435. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797618772506
Linares, C., & Sellier, A.-L. (2021). How bad is the mere presence of a phone? A replication of Przybylski and Weinstein (2013) and an extension to creativity. PLOS ONE, 16(6), e0251451. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0251451
Mitchell, T. R., Thompson, L., Peterson, E., & Cronk, R. (1997). Temporal adjustments in the evaluation of events: The “rosy view.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 33(4), 421–448. Kellogg School of Management research record
Przybylski, A. K., & Weinstein, N. (2013). Can you connect with me now? How the presence of mobile communication technology influences face-to-face conversation quality. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 30(3), 237–246. https://doi.org/10.1177/0265407512453827
Ward, A. F., Duke, K., Gneezy, A., & Bos, M. W. (2017). Brain drain: The mere presence of one’s own smartphone reduces available cognitive capacity. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, 2(2), 140–154. https://doi.org/10.1086/691462
Wildschut, T., Sedikides, C., Arndt, J., & Routledge, C. (2006). Nostalgia: Content, triggers, functions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 91(5), 975–993. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.91.5.975
Classical sources cited in the text: Genesis 18:1–8; Taittiriya Upanishad, Shiksha Valli 1.11.2; Tolkappiyam, Porulatikaram (the tinai landscapes of Tamil akam poetry); Ii Naosuke, Chanoyu Ichie Shu (1858).
We all live with fear, but have you ever wondered whether you are afraid of the wrong things? Scripture invites us to look beyond our fears and discover how the fear of God can transform our choices, strengthen our faith and free us to live with courage and love. This Sunday’s reflection poses a searching question that may change the way you understand your fears—and your relationship with God.
RISE & INSPIRE | SUNDAY BIBLE SERIESCategory: Wake-up CallsSunday Series No. 14 — 15 November 2026 · Thirty-Third Sunday in Ordinary Time · World Day of the PoorScriptures of the week: 9 – 15 November 2026
Are You Afraid of the Right Thing?
A prophet asleep in a storm, three young men before a furnace, an army outnumbered on the plain, and the one fear that sets all the others free
Three Fears Before Noon
Before noon today, in parishes of the Roman Rite on every continent, three things will be said about fear, and at first hearing they do not agree.
The first reading will close with the portrait of a woman praised for one quality above charm and beauty: “a woman who fears the LORD is to be praised” (Proverbs 31:30). The responsorial psalm will turn that quality into a beatitude: Blessed are those who fear the Lord (Psalm 128:1). And then the Gospel will tell of a man who loses everything for one reason, which he gives with disarming honesty: “I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground” (Matthew 25:25).
So in a single hour of worship, fear is praised twice and condemned once. It is the crown of a good life and the ruin of a servant. Which is it?
This week’s seven verses, which reached us one morning at a time from Monday to today, do not settle the puzzle so much as sharpen it. On Saturday, Moses told an outnumbered army: do not fear them. On Friday, a prophet running for his life told a crew of terrified sailors: I fear the LORD — though the translation we were given says, quite reasonably, I worship. On Tuesday, three young men faced a furnace without, it seems, being afraid of it at all. And this morning, a psalmist who has already been rescued once admits that he is surrounded again, and asks God not to lock his mercy away.
Lay them side by side and a pattern begins to show. Scripture is not much interested in whether we are afraid. Everyone is afraid of something, and the Bible is too honest to pretend otherwise. It is intensely interested in what we fear, and in what our fear makes us do.
That is the question beneath the week:
Are you afraid of the right thing?
The answer these texts give is one we seldom hear, either from pulpits or from the self-help shelf. The cure for fear, in Scripture, is almost never the absence of fear. It is a greater fear — different in kind, aimed at a different object — that makes every lesser fear smaller.
We will meet fear this week in four disguises. The fear that runs: a prophet on a ship bound for the edge of the world, and a proud nation whose towers and ships cannot save it. The fear that bows: a plain in Babylon where everyone kneels when the music starts, and an army told to count the enemy’s horses and then stop counting. The fear that buries: a servant with a spade, and a singer who refused to hide what he had been given. The fear that calls: the cry the prophet Joel promised would never go unheard. And at the end we will stand beside an old apostle who wrote that the decisive victory has already been won.
Scripture is quoted from the New Revised Standard Version, the translation in which most of this week’s verses were given, unless otherwise stated. Monday’s verse reached us in the wording of the Revised Standard Version, which we keep. Readers using the NABRE will find two of the verses under different numbers: Joel 2:32 is Joel 3:5, and Psalm 40:11 is Psalm 40:12.
Part One · The Fear That Runs
1. A Wake-up Call from a Pagan Captain
Friday, 13 November · Jonah 1:9
“I am a Hebrew,” he replied. “I worship the LORD, the God of heaven, who made the sea and the dry land.”
Of all the wake-up calls in Scripture, the most humbling is delivered by a sea captain who does not yet know the name of Israel’s God.
The story opens with a command: “Go at once to Nineveh, that great city, and cry out against it” (1:2). Nineveh was the great city of Assyria, the empire whose armies destroyed the northern kingdom of Israel in 722 BC. Jonah son of Amittai is mentioned in one other place in the Bible, as a prophet in the reign of Jeroboam II in the eighth century, who had foretold the expansion of Israel’s borders (2 Kings 14:25). The book that carries his name was probably written later, and its genre is debated: sober history, prophetic parable, a narrative full of deliberate irony, or something in between. Catholic scholars hold a range of views. The book’s meaning does not hang on the answer, and Jesus himself treats Jonah as a sign (Matthew 12:39–41).
Jonah does set out — in the opposite direction. He goes down to Joppa, the port on the Mediterranean coast that is today’s Jaffa, and buys passage to Tarshish: a distant place in the far west, perhaps Tartessos in southern Spain, which to an Israelite meant the end of the known world. The narrator tells us why twice in a single verse: “away from the presence of the LORD” (1:3).
The way down
Watch the verbs. Jonah went down (יָרַד, yārad) to Joppa; he went down into the ship (1:3); he had gone down into the hold, and there he lay down and fell into a deep sleep — וַיֵּרָדַם, wayyērādam, a verb whose sound echoes yārad (1:5). From the belly of the fish he will later say, “I went down to the land whose bars closed upon me forever” (2:6). God’s first word to him had been Get up — in Hebrew, קוּם (qûm), which the NRSV renders “Go at once.” Jonah keeps going down.
Meanwhile “the LORD hurled a great wind upon the sea” (1:4). The verb for hurl, hēṭîl, comes back again and again: the sailors hurl the cargo (1:5), Jonah tells them to hurl him (1:12), and in the end they do (1:15). The storm is so violent that, in a striking Hebrew personification, the ship thought it would break up (1:4); the NRSV says it “threatened to.” The ship has a keener sense of danger than the prophet below its deck.
“Get up, call on your god!”
The sailors do what frightened people in every age have done. “The mariners were afraid, and each cried to his god. They threw the cargo that was in the ship into the sea, to lighten it for them” (1:5). Then the captain finds his passenger asleep:
“What are you doing sound asleep? Get up, call on your god! Perhaps the god will spare us a thought so that we do not perish.” (1:6)
In Hebrew the captain’s words are almost exactly God’s. God had said קוּם לֵךְ … וּקְרָא, qûm lēkh … ûqərāʾ, “Get up, go … cry out” (1:2). The captain says קוּם קְרָא, qûm qərāʾ, “Get up, call!” Without knowing it, a pagan sailor repeats to the prophet the very command the prophet has fled. It is the original wake-up call: the world shaking the believer awake and asking him to pray.
The lots fall on Jonah, and the sailors fire five questions at him at once (1:8). His answer is Friday’s verse.
The creed of a runaway
עִבְרִי אָנֹכִי וְאֶת־יְהוָה אֱלֹהֵי הַשָּׁמַיִם אֲנִי יָרֵא אֲשֶׁר־עָשָׂה אֶת־הַיָּם וְאֶת־הַיַּבָּשָׁהʿivrî ʾānōkhî, wəʾet-YHWH ʾĕlōhê haššāmayim ʾănî yārēʾ, ʾăšer-ʿāśāh ʾet-hayyām wəʾet-hayyabbāšāh “A Hebrew am I; and the LORD, the God of heaven, I fear — who made the sea and the dry land.”
The NRSV’s “I worship” is a fair rendering of יָרֵא (yārēʾ), which means fearing, and its choice is ancient. The Jewish scholars who translated the prophets into Greek wrote sebomai, “I revere.” In Hebrew, the fear of the LORD is the nearest thing to a single word for religion itself; it is “the beginning of knowledge” (Proverbs 1:7). The Greek version also makes a second change. Where the Hebrew has “I am a Hebrew,” it has Jonah say δοῦλος κυρίου ἐγώ εἰμι, “I am a servant of the Lord.” Scholars differ on why — a slightly different reading of the Hebrew letters, perhaps, or a memory of 2 Kings 14:25, where Jonah is called God’s servant.
Both translations are defensible. But the plainer “I fear” keeps the story’s irony in full view, and the irony is the point.
Notice the Hebrew word order. “The LORD, the God of heaven” stands before the verb, for emphasis. It is a flawless confession. Jonah names the God of heaven as Maker of the sea — while sailing across that sea to get away from him. He claims to fear the Lord of the storm, and the storm is his own disobedience coming after him. His theology is impeccable. His feet are going the wrong way.
This is the first face of fear the week shows us: the fear that runs. It is not irreligious. It can recite the creed perfectly. What it cannot do is stay where God has put it. And the book later tells us what Jonah was really afraid of. It was not Nineveh’s cruelty. It was God’s kindness: “I knew that you are a gracious God and merciful, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love, and ready to relent from punishing” (4:2). He ran because he was afraid that mercy would reach the wrong people.
A fear that changes its object
Now watch the sailors. Their fear passes through three stages:
“The mariners were afraid” (1:5) — afraid of the storm.
“The men were even more afraid” — literally, they feared a great fear (1:10) — when they learn whose storm it is.
“The men feared the LORD even more” — literally, they feared a great fear, the LORD — “and they offered a sacrifice to the LORD and made vows” (1:16).
Their fear does not disappear when the sea grows calm. It changes its object. It began with the waves and ended with the Maker of the waves. The pagans who heard Jonah’s creed finish the chapter more God-fearing than the man who recited it. (The narrator, by the way, keeps reaching for one word: great. A great city, a great wind, a great storm, a great fear, a great fish. Everything in this story is great except the prophet’s obedience.)
Even the phrase “the sea and the dry land” carries a history. יַבָּשָׁה (yabbāšāh), dry land, is the word of the third day of creation — “let the dry land appear” (Genesis 1:9) — and the word of the Exodus, when Israel went “into the sea on dry ground” (Exodus 14:16, 22, 29). The first act of Jonah’s story ends with the same word: “the fish … spewed Jonah out upon the dry land” (2:10). The God Jonah confessed was the God who makes a path through the sea. In the end, that is exactly where he put him.
Something greater than Jonah
Every Gospel reader will hear another boat in this story. Mark tells of a night crossing of the Sea of Galilee, a great windstorm, waves filling the boat, and a passenger asleep in the stern. The disciples wake him with almost the sailors’ words: “Teacher, do you not care that we are perishing?” (Mark 4:38). Jesus rebukes the wind, there is a dead calm, and he asks, “Why are you afraid? Have you still no faith?” (4:40).
Then Mark writes a phrase that a reader of the Greek Scriptures could hardly miss:
καὶ ἐφοβήθησαν φόβον μέγαν — kai ephobēthēsan phobon megan — “and they feared a great fear” (Mark 4:41)
The NRSV renders it “they were filled with great awe.” It is the phrase the Greek Bible uses of Jonah’s sailors (Jonah 1:10; compare 1:16). The disciples’ fear, like the sailors’, does not vanish. It moves — from the storm to the One whom “even the wind and the sea obey.” And the difference between the two boats is the one that matters most. In Jonah’s ship, the sleeper is the problem and has to be thrown overboard. In Mark’s boat, the sleeper is the answer. He speaks, and the sea obeys its Maker. “Something greater than Jonah is here” (Matthew 12:41).
One more echo, centuries later, in the same harbour town. A man whom Matthew calls “Simon son of Jonah” (Matthew 16:17) was praying on a rooftop in Joppa when the vision came that sent him to a Roman centurion named Cornelius — to the Gentiles he would once have avoided (Acts 10:9–23). Jonah at Joppa went down to the harbour and boarded a ship. Peter at Joppa went down from the roof and opened the door.
Anyone who has lived along the coasts of Kerala or Kanyakumari knows that Jonah’s sea is not a literary device. Fishing families there have prayed for generations before the boats put out, and many still remember the nights of Cyclone Ockhi in late 2017, when boats did not come home. Psalm 107 knew such nights: “Some went down to the sea in ships … Then they cried to the LORD in their trouble … he made the storm be still” (107:23, 28–29). The God of Jonah 1:9 is not a theory about the sea. He is the One the frightened call upon when the sea is all there is.
The fear that runs recites the creed and boards the ship anyway. Its cure is not a better creed. It is getting up.
2. Every Ship of Tarshish
Wednesday, 11 November · Isaiah 2:12
“For the LORD of hosts has a day against all that is proud and lofty, against all that is lifted up and high.”
Jonah bought his ticket on a ship of Tarshish. Two days before his verse reached us, Isaiah had already named that very kind of ship in a list of things God will bring down.
Isaiah son of Amoz preached in Jerusalem in the second half of the eighth century BC, through years of prosperity and years of menace. His second chapter opens with one of the best-loved visions in the Bible: the mountain of the LORD’s house raised highest of all, the nations streaming to it, and swords beaten into ploughshares (2:2–4). A bronze statue of a man hammering a sword into a ploughshare, presented by the Soviet Union in 1959, still stands in the garden of the United Nations in New York. Wednesday’s verse reached us on 11 November — Armistice Day, the 108th anniversary of the morning in 1918 when the guns fell silent on the Western Front.
But Isaiah does not stay on the mountain. He looks at Judah as it actually is:
“Their land is filled with silver and gold, and there is no end to their treasures; their land is filled with horses, and there is no end to their chariots. Their land is filled with idols.” (2:7–8)
Hold on to those horses and chariots; we shall meet them again on Saturday. The vision of peace becomes a vision of a Day, and the Day comes “against” a long list:
“… against all the cedars of Lebanon, lofty and lifted up; and against all the oaks of Bashan; against all the high mountains, and against all the lofty hills; against every high tower, and against every fortified wall; against all the ships of Tarshish, and against all the beautiful craft.” (2:13–16)
It is an inventory of everything human beings admire because it is tall or far-reaching: the great forests of the north, the mountains, the towers and walls built for security, the ocean-going merchant ships built for the longest voyages and the richest trade (1 Kings 10:22). “By the east wind you shattered the ships of Tarshish,” says Psalm 48:7. Twice the poem halts for its refrain: “and the LORD alone will be exalted on that day” (2:11, 17).
A word at the end of the line
Honesty about the text belongs to faithfulness to it, and this verse has a small puzzle at its end.
The traditional Hebrew text ends with וְשָׁפֵל (wəšāpēl), “and low.” Read literally, the line says, “against all that is lifted up — and low,” which is awkward. Many translators take the word as a verb, “and it shall be brought low” (so the King James Version and the ESV), matching the refrain of verse 17. The NRSV and RSV instead follow the ancient Greek translation and read “and high,” noting the Hebrew in a footnote. Either way, the movement of the verse is the same: from high to low. The line enacts what it announces.
“High and lifted up”
Look at the words for height. גֵּאֶה (gēʾeh) is proud; רָם (rām) is lofty; נִשָּׂא (niśśāʾ) is lifted up. Isaiah uses the pair rām and niśśāʾ together in two other famous places, and both times the subject is God. In the Temple: “I saw the Lord sitting on a throne, high and lofty” (6:1). And in a later chapter: “thus says the high and lofty one who inhabits eternity, whose name is Holy: I dwell in the high and holy place, and also with those who are contrite and humble in spirit” (57:15).
In Isaiah, high and lifted up is practically a divine title. Chapter 2 describes the Day when every impostor to that title — cedar, tower, ship, empire — is stripped of it.
Then comes the surprise. One more figure in Isaiah is given the same vocabulary:
“See, my servant shall prosper; he shall be exalted and lifted up, and shall be very high.” (52:13)
And the very next lines describe that servant as “marred … beyond human semblance,” despised, “crushed for our iniquities” (52:14; 53:5). Scholars such as Richard Bauckham have drawn attention to how rare this combination of words is, and to how the first Christians read it: the only human being whom Isaiah calls high and lifted up is the one who is brought lowest. John’s Gospel sets Isaiah 53 and Isaiah 6 side by side (John 12:38–41), and gives us Jesus’ own words: “And I, when I am lifted up from the earth, will draw all people to myself” (12:32). The cross is where the true Height bent down.
Pride is fear dressed as confidence
What has all this to do with fear? Read on in Isaiah 2. On that Day the proud do not stand defiant. They run.
“Enter into the rock, and hide in the dust from the terror of the LORD, and from the glory of his majesty.” (2:10; again in 2:19, 21)
They fling their idols of silver and gold “to the moles and to the bats” (2:20). The Book of Revelation takes up this scene centuries later: kings, generals and the rich hiding in caves, calling to the mountains, “Fall on us and hide us” (Revelation 6:15–16).
Isaiah’s phrase is “from the presence of the terror of the LORD” — מִפְּנֵי פַּחַד יְהוָה, mippənê paḥad YHWH. Jonah fled “from the presence of the LORD” — millifnê YHWH (Jonah 1:3). Pride and flight turn out to be the same movement. The proud are not people without fear. They are people who have spent their lives fearing the wrong things — loss of status, loss of control, being made to look small — and who, when they finally meet the right object of fear, can only hide from it.
That is why Isaiah ends the chapter with a sentence that reads almost like a remedy for anxiety: “Turn away from mortals, who have only breath in their nostrils, for of what account are they?” (2:22). Every tower ever built was built by someone who breathes.
Today’s second reading at Mass carries Isaiah’s Day into the New Testament: “the day of the Lord will come like a thief in the night” (1 Thessalonians 5:2). Paul’s response is not panic but wakefulness: “let us keep awake and be sober” (5:6).
Pride is the fear that runs, dressed up as confidence. Its cure is not self-contempt. It is accuracy: seeing who alone is high.
Part Two · The Fear That Bows
3. “But If Not”
Tuesday, 10 November · Daniel 3:17
“If our God whom we serve is able to deliver us from the furnace of blazing fire and out of your hand, O king, let him deliver us.”
Jonah’s fear ran from God. The crowd on the plain of Dura shows us a fear that does not move at all. It simply kneels when the music starts.
A machine set to music
Daniel 3 is one of the court stories of Daniel 1–6, set in the Babylonian exile of the sixth century BC among young Judeans trained for the king’s service: Daniel and his three companions, whose Hebrew names — Hananiah, Mishael and Azariah — were replaced with the Babylonian names Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego (1:6–7). A large part of the book, including this chapter, is written not in Hebrew but in Aramaic, the international language of the empires (2:4b–7:28). Many scholars, Catholic scholars among them, think the book reached its final form in the second century BC, when the Seleucid king Antiochus IV tried to force the Jews to abandon the Law and sacrifice to foreign gods (1 Maccabees 1:41–50). If so, these stories of the exile were read by people facing furnaces of their own.
King Nebuchadnezzar sets up “a golden statue whose height was sixty cubits and whose width was six cubits” (3:1) — something like twenty-seven metres high and under three wide, proportions so slender that some imagine a figure on a tall pedestal, others something closer to an obelisk. The Aramaic word for statue, צְלֵם (ṣəlēm), belongs to the same family as the Hebrew צֶלֶם (ṣelem) of Genesis 1:27, where humanity is created “in the image of God.” There is quiet theology in the collision: human beings made in God’s image are commanded to bow before an image made at a king’s command.
Then the narrator does something easy to skim and important not to. He repeats. The officials summoned to the dedication — satraps, prefects, governors, counsellors, treasurers, justices, magistrates — are listed in full, twice (3:2, 3). The royal orchestra — “the horn, pipe, lyre, trigon, harp, drum, and entire musical ensemble” — is listed four times (3:5, 7, 10, 15). Three of those instrument names are borrowed from Greek, one of the clues scholars weigh when they date the book. And the repetition is satire. The empire is a machine. Everyone has a title, every title has a place, and when the music plays the whole machine bends at once: “all the peoples, nations, and languages fell down and worshiped the golden statue” (3:7).
The furnace is the threat (3:6). The music is the method. Most of the people on that plain were neither brave nor cowardly. They did what the sound told them, because everyone around them was doing it. This is the second face of fear: the fear that bows.
An emperor’s sneer
Three young men stay standing, and “certain Chaldeans” report them. The charge is precise: “they do not serve your gods” (3:8–12). The king offers them a second chance, and adds a sneer: “who is the god that will deliver you out of my hands?” (3:15). It is the boast of every empire. The Assyrian envoy had shouted something very like it outside the walls of Jerusalem a century before (2 Kings 18:33–35).
The reply begins with a sentence that deserves to be read slowly: “O Nebuchadnezzar, we have no need to present a defense to you in this matter” (3:16). It is not insolence. It is calm. They have no need to win the argument.
The hardest small word in the chapter
Then comes Tuesday’s verse, and in the original it opens with a small word that has kept translators busy for centuries:
הֵן אִיתַי אֱלָהַנָא דִּי־אֲנַחְנָא פָלְחִיןhēn ʾîtay ʾĕlāhanāʾ dî-ʾănaḥnāʾ pāləḥîn “If there is our God whom we serve …”
The Aramaic particle אִיתַי (ʾîtay) normally means there is, exists. How it fits the sentence is genuinely difficult, and English Bibles divide three ways:
“If our God whom we serve is able to deliver us … let him deliver us” (NRSV; similarly NABRE).
“If it be so, our God whom we serve is able to deliver us … and he will deliver us” (King James, RSV, ESV) — that is, if we are thrown in, our God is able.
“If our God whom we serve exists, he is able to rescue us” (NET Bible) — a direct answer to the king’s sneer that no such god exists.
None of these readings has the three men doubting God’s power. And every reading arrives at the same next verse, which is not difficult at all:
וְהֵן לָא — wəhēn lāʾ — “But if not, be it known to you, O king, that we will not serve your gods and we will not worship the golden statue that you have set up.” (3:18)
Faith is not a forecast
Here is the insight Daniel 3 has given to generation after generation of believers. The three men did not know what God would do. They knew whom they served.
The Aramaic verb פְּלַח (pəlaḥ), to serve or to worship, is the hinge on which the whole chapter turns, returning again and again (3:12, 14, 17, 18, 28). Their God is identified not by what he will deliver but by their relationship with him: “our God whom we serve.”
A faith that obeys only on condition of rescue is a contract. “But if not” is covenant. It is the faith of people who have stopped trying to predict God and decided simply to belong to him.
On 5 November 1967, five months before his assassination, Martin Luther King Jr. preached a sermon at Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta titled “But If Not.” He drew from these three words a whole account of conscience: that some commands must be refused even when deliverance is not guaranteed, and that the refusal is not cancelled by its cost.
Four men in the fire
They are bound and thrown in. The furnace is so hot that its flames kill the soldiers who throw them (3:22). And then the king leaps to his feet:
“But I see four men unbound, walking in the middle of the fire, and they are not hurt; and the fourth has the appearance of a god.” (3:25)
The Aramaic says “like a son of the gods,” and the king himself later calls the figure God’s “angel” (3:28). Many early Christian readers saw in that fourth figure a foreshadowing of the Son of God, who does not always keep his people out of the fire but walks with them in it. The text says no more than that, and we should not make it say more.
Then the details, set down with evident delight: the fire “had not had any power over the bodies of those men; the hair of their heads was not singed, their tunics were not harmed, and not even the smell of fire came from them” (3:27). Not even the smell.
And the king who demanded worship ends by blessing their God, “who has sent his angel and delivered his servants who trusted in him. They disobeyed the king’s command and yielded up their bodies rather than serve and worship any god except their own God” (3:28).
What the Greek Bible heard inside the fire
Catholic and Orthodox Bibles contain more of this chapter than Jewish and Protestant ones. The ancient Greek version includes, between verses 23 and 24, the Prayer of Azariah and the Song of the Three Young Men. Catholic Bibles print them as part of the canonical text of Daniel (numbered 3:24–90); Protestant Bibles place them among the Apocrypha.
In the middle of the flames, Azariah does not boast. He confesses the sins of his people and pleads:
“Do not withdraw your mercy from us, for the sake of Abraham your beloved …” (Prayer of Azariah 12; Daniel 3:35 in Catholic Bibles)
And a few lines later: “with all our heart we follow you; we fear you and seek your presence” (Prayer of Azariah 18; Daniel 3:41). The men who would not fear the king confess, inside the fire, that they fear God. And their plea for mercy is very nearly the prayer of this morning’s psalm.
What follows is the great canticle known by its Latin opening, Benedicite: Bless the Lord, all you works of the Lord — sun and moon, fire and heat, seas and rivers, whales and everything that swims — the whole of creation summoned to praise from inside a furnace. In the Liturgy of the Hours of the Roman Rite it is sung at Morning Prayer on the Sundays of the first and third weeks of the psalter. This morning was one of them. Before most of us reached church, the Church at prayer was already singing the song of the three young men, with an antiphon recalling how they cried out with one voice from the midst of the flames.
Those who were not delivered
Not every “but if not” ends with an open furnace door. The Letter to the Hebrews remembers believers who “quenched raging fire” (11:34) — and, three verses later, others who “were stoned to death … sawn in two … killed by the sword” (11:37). The dying Mattathias told his sons that “Hananiah, Azariah, and Mishael believed and were saved from the flame” (1 Maccabees 2:59), and then sent them into a war from which several did not return.
The Church calls the second kind of witness martyrdom, “the supreme witness given to the truth of the faith” (CCC 2473). The three young men’s courage did not depend on knowing which kind of story they were in. That is precisely what made it courage. The Catechism names the virtue at work: fortitude, which “enables one to conquer fear, even fear of death” (CCC 1808).
The fear that bows is rarely chosen. It is absorbed from the music of a crowd. Its cure is not bravado but belonging — knowing “our God whom we serve” well enough to say, “But if not.”
4. Count the Horses, Then Stop Counting
Saturday, 14 November · Deuteronomy 20:1
“When you go out to war against your enemies and see horses and chariots, an army larger than your own, do not fear them, for the LORD your God is with you, who brought you up from the land of Egypt.”
If Dura shows us a fear that bows to a crowd, Deuteronomy 20 shows us a fear that does arithmetic.
Deuteronomy presents itself as the farewell speeches of Moses on the plains of Moab, on the eve of Israel’s entry into the land. Many scholars think its core took shape in the seventh century BC, in the reign of King Josiah, and spoke to a small kingdom living in the shadow of great empires. Chapters 12–26 gather the laws by which Israel was to live in the land, and chapter 20 regulates war.
Horses and chariots
To an Israelite in the hill country, סוּס וָרֶכֶב (sûs wārekhev), horse and chariot, meant the armoured superiority of the plains: the Canaanite cities with their “chariots of iron” (Joshua 17:16; Judges 1:19), and above all Egypt, whose pursuing army was “all of Pharaoh’s horses, chariots, and chariot drivers” (Exodus 14:23). The phrase “an army larger than your own” is literally עַם רַב מִמְּךָ (ʿam rav mimməkā), “a people more numerous than you.” The verse describes, with complete realism, a battle Israel ought to lose.
Then comes the command, לֹא תִירָא מֵהֶם (lōʾ tîrāʾ mēhem), “do not fear them,” and two reasons for it.
The first is presence: “the LORD your God is with you” — עִמָּךְ (ʿimmākh), the same little preposition with that Isaiah would turn into a name: ʿImmānû-ʾēl, “God is with us” (Isaiah 7:14; Matthew 1:23).
The second is memory: “who brought you up from the land of Egypt” — הַמַּעַלְךָ (hammaʿalkhā), a participle, literally “the one bringing you up.” Deuteronomy does not give a date; it gives a description. The Exodus has become part of God’s name.
Memory is the strategy. The chariots Israel feared most were already at the bottom of the sea. “Horse and rider he has thrown into the sea” (Exodus 15:1). Every new army was to be measured against the one already drowned.
Four words for fear, and an army made smaller
The verses that follow are even more surprising. Before the battle a priest addresses the troops:
“Hear, O Israel! Today you are drawing near to do battle against your enemies. Do not lose heart, or be afraid, or panic, or be in dread of them; for it is the LORD your God who goes with you, to fight for you against your enemies, to give you victory.” (20:3–4)
Hebrew has a rich vocabulary of fear, and the priest uses four words of it in a single breath: a soft heart (rakh), fear (yārēʾ), the alarm that makes people rush about (ḥāpaz), and the dread that makes them tremble (ʿāraṣ). And the phrase “to give you victory” is, in Hebrew, ləhôšîaʿ, “to save you.” In Scripture, victory is a kind of salvation. It is received before it is won.
Then the officers begin sending people home: anyone who has built a house and not yet dedicated it, planted a vineyard and not yet enjoyed it, become engaged and not yet married (20:5–7). And finally:
“Is anyone afraid or disheartened? He should go back to his house, or he might cause the heart of his comrades to melt like his own.” (20:8)
Read that as a general would. Israel’s law of war deliberately makes an outnumbered army smaller. The story of Gideon pushes the principle to its limit. “Whoever is fearful and trembling, let him return home,” and twenty-two thousand go (Judges 7:3), until three hundred remain — so that Israel would not “take the credit away from me, saying, ‘My own hand has delivered me'” (7:2). The point is not that numbers do not matter in war. The point is that Israel’s security was never meant to rest on them.
Notice, too, why the fearful are sent home: fear is contagious. One melting heart melts others. It is the plain of Dura again.
A hard chapter, honestly read
The same chapter goes on to set out laws of siege, and a command to destroy utterly certain Canaanite cities (20:16–18). These are among the most troubling pages of Scripture, and the Church does not ask us to pretend otherwise. The Second Vatican Council teaches that the books of the Old Testament contain some things “incomplete and temporary,” and yet show us God’s patient teaching of his people across history (Dei Verbum 15). Pope Benedict XVI, in Verbum Domini (42), asks that such “dark” passages be read within the whole story of salvation and in the light of Christ. The verse we were given this week is not a charter for violence. Its lasting word is about the source of courage.
And Jesus moves the battlefield. “Do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul” (Matthew 10:28). “Our struggle,” Paul writes, “is not against enemies of blood and flesh” (Ephesians 6:12).
Horses of fire, and a soldier without a shield
Two stories show what Deuteronomy 20:1 looks like when it is lived.
When the king of Aram surrounded the town of Dothan with “horses and chariots” to capture the prophet Elisha, his servant panicked. Elisha said, “Do not be afraid, for there are more with us than there are with them,” and prayed that the young man’s eyes be opened — and he saw “the mountain was full of horses and chariots of fire all around Elisha” (2 Kings 6:15–17). The arithmetic had been right. The count had been incomplete.
And on Wednesday the Church kept the memorial of St Martin of Tours, the fourth-century Roman soldier who asked to leave the army. His friend and biographer Sulpicius Severus records his words to the emperor Julian: “I am the soldier of Christ: it is not lawful for me to fight” (Life of St Martin, 4). Accused of cowardice, Martin offered to stand in front of the battle line the next day without shield or helmet, protected only by the sign of the cross. According to Sulpicius, the enemy sent envoys to sue for peace before the battle could begin. Historians read such early lives with care; but the shape of the story is unmistakable. Martin was made fearless before an army not by a larger army, but by a greater allegiance.
The fear that counts usually gets the sum right and the answer wrong. Deuteronomy’s cure is memory: measure every army against the one already drowned.
Part Three · The Fear That Buries
5. The Servant with the Spade, and the Singer Who Would Not Hide
Sunday, 15 November · Psalm 40:11
“Do not, O LORD, withhold your mercy from me; let your steadfast love and your faithfulness keep me safe forever.”
This morning’s verse arrives on the same day as this morning’s Gospel, and the two belong together.
In the parable of the talents, a man going on a journey entrusts his property to three slaves: five talents, two, and one (Matthew 25:14–15). A talent was an enormous sum. At a denarius for a day’s labour (Matthew 20:2), it represented well over fifteen years of a worker’s wages. The first two servants trade and double what they were given. The third takes a spade. When the master returns, he explains himself:
“Master, I knew that you were a harsh man, reaping where you did not sow, and gathering where you did not scatter seed; so I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground. Here you have what is yours.” (25:24–25)
καὶ φοβηθεὶς ἀπελθὼν ἔκρυψα τὸ τάλαντόν σου ἐν τῇ γῇkai phobētheis apelthōn ekrypsa to talanton sou en tē gē “And being afraid, I went off and hid your talent in the earth.”
Commentators often point out that burying was regarded in that world as a responsible way of guarding money in one’s keeping. The third servant was not a thief. He was careful. His failure was fear — and notice where his fear came from. “I knew that you were a harsh man.” The fear that buries begins with a false picture of the Master.
This is the third face: the fear that buries. It keeps everything safe and so loses everything. It is the gift never used, the word never spoken, the risk never taken, the money kept “just in case” while someone else’s case is already here.
A psalm that would not hide
Psalm 40 is a portrait of the opposite. It opens in thanksgiving: “I waited patiently for the LORD” — in Hebrew, qawwōh qiwwîtî, “waiting, I waited” — “he drew me up from the desolate pit, out of the miry bog, and set my feet upon a rock” (40:1–2). And then:
“He put a new song in my mouth, a song of praise to our God. Many will see and fear, and put their trust in the LORD.” (40:3)
In Hebrew, see and fear rhyme: yirʾû, “they will see”; yîrāʾû, “they will fear.” Seeing what God has done produces fear, and that fear is joined at once to trust. It is a different fear altogether from the third servant’s.
A few verses later come words the Letter to the Hebrews places on the lips of Christ as he comes into the world: “Here I am … I delight to do your will, O my God” (Psalm 40:7–8; Hebrews 10:5–7). And then the psalmist lists three things he has not done:
“I have told the glad news of deliverance in the great congregation; see, I have not restrained my lips, as you know, O LORD. I have not hidden your saving help within my heart, I have spoken of your faithfulness and your salvation; I have not concealed your steadfast love and your faithfulness from the great congregation.” (40:9–10)
Not restrained. Not hidden. Not concealed. The psalmist had received a gift — rescue from the pit — and he refused to bury it.
אַתָּה (ʾattāh), “You”, stands first and is emphatic. The psalmist turns from the great congregation and speaks to God face to face.
תִכְלָא (tikhlāʾ), “withhold,” comes from כָּלָא (kālāʾ), to restrain, hold back, shut up. It is the very verb of verse 9: “I have not restrained (lōʾ ʾekhlāʾ) my lips.” And from the same root comes כֶּלֶא (keleʾ), prison; “put this fellow in prison” in 1 Kings 22:27 is, literally, “put him in the house of restraint.” So the two verses answer each other: I did not lock up my lips. You, LORD, do not lock up your compassion.
רַחֲמִים (raḥămîm), which the NRSV translates “mercy,” is closely related to רֶחֶם (reḥem), womb. It is compassion with something of a mother’s depth.
חֶסֶד (ḥesed) and אֱמֶת (ʾĕmet), steadfast love and faithfulness, are the very pair the psalmist said he “did not conceal” in verse 10. What he proclaimed to others, he now asks to stand guard over him.
יִצְּרוּנִי (yiṣṣərûnî), “keep me safe,” comes from נָצַר (nāṣar), to guard, to keep watch — the work of a sentry. Steadfast love and faithfulness are pictured as two watchmen at the door. Psalm 61:7 uses the same image: “appoint steadfast love and faithfulness to watch over him!”
And תָּמִיד (tāmîd), “forever,” means continually, always. It is the word used of the lamp that was to burn always before the Lord (Exodus 27:20).
One further note on translation. The NRSV renders the first line as a petition: “Do not … withhold.” Grammarians point out that the Hebrew form can equally be read as a confident statement: “As for you, O LORD, you will not restrain your mercy from me” (ESV; similarly NASB and the NET Bible). Both readings make sense, and the uncertainty is itself instructive. The verse stands exactly on the hinge of the psalm, between what the psalmist knows and what he still needs.
Rescued, and in trouble again
For the very next verse turns:
“For evils have encompassed me without number; my iniquities have overtaken me, until I cannot see; they are more than the hairs of my head, and my heart fails me.” (40:12)
The man who sang the new song is back in the pit. (More troubles than the hairs of his head — and in Daniel’s furnace, not one hair was singed.) The closing verses, 13–17, appear again almost word for word as Psalm 70, an urgent prayer for help.
This is easy to miss. In Psalm 40, rescue comes first and trouble comes second. Mature faith is not a single deliverance after which we are exempt from fear for ever. It is a life of being rescued and needing rescue again — and of asking, each time, that God’s compassion not be locked away.
The psalm’s last words are these:
“As for me, I am poor and needy, but the Lord takes thought for me. You are my help and my deliverer; do not delay, O my God.” (40:17)
On the World Day of the Poor
Today is also the tenth World Day of the Poor, instituted by Pope Francis at the close of the Jubilee of Mercy (Misericordia et misera, 21). Pope Leo XIV has taken this year’s theme from another psalm — “The Lord is the refuge of the poor” (cf. Psalm 14:6) — and asks a question this morning’s verse makes sharper still: “Are we a sign of a God who is a refuge for the poor?”
Psalm 40 asks God not to lock his compassion away. The parable shows a man who locked a gift in the earth. And the woman praised in this morning’s first reading for her fear of the LORD is the one who “opens her hand to the poor” (Proverbs 31:20). What God is asked not to withhold, those who fear him rightly do not withhold either.
The fear that buries keeps everything safe and loses everything. Its cure is a truer picture of the Master: not a harsh man, but a God whose compassion is never locked away.
Part Four · The Fear That Calls
6. Everyone Who Calls
Thursday, 12 November · Joel 2:32
“Everyone who calls on the name of the LORD shall be saved.”
Running, bowing, burying. Is there any response to fear that Scripture blesses? Thursday’s verse answers in one word: call.
We know almost nothing about the prophet Joel, and the date of his book is disputed; proposals range across several centuries, though many scholars place it after the exile, in the Persian period. It opens with a plague of locusts so devastating that the prophet reads it as a warning of “the day of the LORD” (1:15; 2:1–2). It calls the people to return — “rend your hearts and not your clothing” (2:13), words the Church hears every Ash Wednesday — and grounds that call in Israel’s ancient creed about God: “gracious and merciful, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love, and relents from punishing” (2:13; compare Exodus 34:6–7).
Anyone who has just read Friday’s verse will recognise those words at once. They are the words Jonah threw back at God in his anger (Jonah 4:2). The same creed that sent Jonah running is the creed that, in Joel, brings a people home.
Then Joel promises that God’s spirit will be poured out “on all flesh” — sons and daughters, old and young, even male and female slaves (2:28–29) — and he describes terrifying signs “before the great and terrible day of the LORD comes” (2:31). The word for terrible is נוֹרָא (nôrāʾ), from the root yārēʾ: the great and fearsome day. And then, in the middle of all that fear, comes the promise:
“Then everyone who calls on the name of the LORD shall be saved; for in Mount Zion and in Jerusalem there shall be those who escape, as the LORD has said, and among the survivors shall be those whom the LORD calls.” (2:32)
A call, an escape, and another call
וְהָיָה כֹּל אֲשֶׁר־יִקְרָא בְּשֵׁם יְהוָה יִמָּלֵטwəhāyāh kōl ʾăšer-yiqrāʾ bəšēm YHWH yimmālēṭ “And it shall be: everyone who calls on the name of the LORD shall escape.”
כֹּל (kōl), everyone, has no qualification — no nation, rank, sex or age — just as the Spirit was promised to “all flesh.”
קָרָא בְּשֵׁם (qārāʾ bəšēm), to call on the name, is one of the oldest expressions for worship in the Bible. “At that time people began to invoke the name of the LORD” (Genesis 4:26); Abram “built an altar to the LORD and invoked the name of the LORD” (12:8). It means more than shouting for help. It means appealing to God as he has made himself known — by his name.
יִמָּלֵט (yimmālēṭ), “shall be saved,” comes from a root meaning to slip away, to escape. It is the word for survivors who get out of a burning city or a lost battle. Salvation here is pictured as a narrow escape.
And the verse ends with a lovely symmetry: “among the survivors shall be those whom the LORD calls” — אֲשֶׁר יְהוָה קֹרֵא (ʾăšer YHWH qōrēʾ). The verse begins with human beings calling on God and ends with God calling human beings. Two callings meet in the middle.
The sailors were right
Go back to the ship one more time. “Each cried to his god” (Jonah 1:5). “Get up, call on your god!” (1:6). And at the crisis: “Then they cried out to the LORD” — וַיִּקְרְאוּ אֶל־יְהוָה, wayyiqrəʾû ʾel-YHWH — and the sea ceased from its raging (1:14–15). Gentile sailors called, and were saved. Joel’s everyone had been proved true on a ship of Tarshish. Even Jonah learns it in the end: “I called to the LORD out of my distress, and he answered me” (2:2).
It was the same at the Red Sea. “In great fear the Israelites cried out to the LORD” (Exodus 14:10). Fear that calls is not yet faith. But it is fear facing the right direction. “I sought the LORD, and he answered me,” sings Psalm 34, “and delivered me from all my fears” (34:4). And Psalm 20 sets Joel’s name against Deuteronomy’s chariots in a single line: “Some take pride in chariots, and some in horses, but our pride is in the name of the LORD our God” (20:7).
A name with a face
At Pentecost, Peter quoted Joel 2:28–32 as fulfilled before the eyes of the crowd (Acts 2:16–21), and he ended his sermon with the last words of Thursday’s verse: the promise is “for all who are far away, everyone whom the Lord our God calls to him” (Acts 2:39).
Paul goes further still. “If you confess with your lips that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved … For, ‘Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved'” (Romans 10:9, 13). In Joel, the LORD translates the divine name itself. Paul applies it, without hesitation, to Jesus. It is one of the most striking moments in the New Testament, and the earliest Christians took it so seriously that they could be described simply as “all those who in every place call on the name of our Lord Jesus Christ” (1 Corinthians 1:2).
The Catechism draws the practical conclusion: “The invocation of the holy name of Jesus is the simplest way of praying always” (CCC 2668). It commends the ancient prayer of East and West, “Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on us sinners” (CCC 2667) — a prayer that joins Joel’s name to the mercy of this morning’s psalm.
Called at the edge of the sea
On 15 February 2015, twenty-one men — twenty Coptic Christians from Egypt and one man from Ghana — were killed on a beach in Libya by fighters of the so-called Islamic State. In the video their killers released, several of them can be heard calling on the Lord Jesus as they die. In May 2023 Pope Francis announced that they would be inscribed in the Roman Martyrology, saying they had been baptised “not only in water and the Spirit, but also in blood.”
They were not delivered from the knife. Joel’s promise was not broken. Here Thursday’s verse and Tuesday’s meet: “everyone who calls” and “but if not.” In Joel, salvation is an escape. In its fullest Christian sense, it is an escape through death, not around it — because the name they called belongs to the One who was himself lifted up, and raised.
The fear that calls is the first fear facing the right way. It does not run, bow or bury. It cries out — and discovers that it was already being called.
The Victory That Has Already Won
Monday, 9 November · Dedication of the Lateran Basilica · 1 John 5:4
“Whatever is born of God overcomes the world; and this is the victory that overcomes the world, our faith.” (RSV)
The week’s first verse is its last word.
The First Letter of John was written late in the first century by an elder pastor to communities that early tradition associates with the apostle John and with the city of Ephesus. They had been wounded by division: “They went out from us, but they did not belong to us” (2:19). It reads less like a letter than a sermon, and its author keeps calling his readers “little children.”
“The world” (κόσμος, kosmos) in John’s vocabulary is not the creation that God “so loved” (John 3:16). It is human life organised without God and against him: “the desire of the flesh, the desire of the eyes, the pride in riches” (1 John 2:16). That last phrase, alazoneia tou biou, describes a swaggering confidence in one’s own life and means. It is Isaiah’s “proud and lofty” in Greek. And John’s verdict on it echoes Isaiah’s Day: “the world and its desire are passing away” (2:17).
ὅτι πᾶν τὸ γεγεννημένον ἐκ τοῦ θεοῦ νικᾷ τὸν κόσμον· καὶ αὕτη ἐστὶν ἡ νίκη ἡ νικήσασα τὸν κόσμον, ἡ πίστις ἡμῶν.hoti pan to gegennēmenon ek tou theou nika ton kosmon; kai hautē estin hē nikē hē nikēsasa ton kosmon, hē pistis hēmōn.
Three details are worth slowing down for.
First, “whatever.” John writes πᾶν τὸ γεγεννημένον (pan to gegennēmenon), a neuter phrase — not everyone but everything that has been born of God — which is why the RSV and NRSV say “whatever.” The neuter seems to gather all believers into a single reality: the whole of what God has begotten. And the tense is perfect: a birth that has happened and goes on being true.
Second, the word for victory.νίκη (nikē) appears only here in the entire New Testament, though the verb nikaō, to conquer, is common, above all in the writings associated with John: “To everyone who conquers …” runs like a refrain through the letters to the seven churches in Revelation (2:7, 11, 17, 26; 3:5, 12, 21). The Greek cities of Asia Minor knew Nikē as the winged goddess of victory, honoured with statues and stamped on coins. John uses her name exactly once — and gives it to faith.
Third, the tense.ἡ νικήσασα (hē nikēsasa) is an aorist participle: literally, “the victory that conquered.” The RSV’s “overcomes” smooths a past tense into a present; the New Jerusalem Bible and the ESV have “has overcome.” Commentators debate which moment John has in view: his readers’ coming to faith and baptism, their recent stand against those who had left (“you are from God, and have conquered them,” 4:4), or the victory of Christ himself — “take courage; I have conquered the world!” (John 16:33). These need not compete. The believer’s victory is a share in a victory already won.
So John does not say that faith is a weapon with which, if we try hard enough, we may yet win. He says faith is the victory — the form that a finished conquest takes in a human life. “Who is it that conquers the world but the one who believes that Jesus is the Son of God?” (5:5).
Monday’s feast made the point without words. The Lateran Basilica, the cathedral of Rome and “mother of all churches,” was dedicated in the fourth century, for a Church that had come through nearly three centuries of intermittent persecution without ever raising an army.
Two fears, and a needle
What does this victory do to fear? John answers a few verses earlier: “There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear; for fear has to do with punishment” (4:18).
Does that contradict the psalm the Church sings today — Blessed are those who fear the Lord? St Augustine faced exactly this question in the sermons he preached on 1 John early in the fifth century. He distinguishes two fears. One is the fear of punishment, which love casts out. The other he calls chaste fear, a phrase he takes from the psalm that says the fear of the Lord is “pure, enduring forever” (Psalm 19:9) — in Augustine’s Latin Bible, chaste. The first is the fear of a slave who dreads the lash; the second, Augustine says, is the fear of losing the good things themselves — the fear of a lover who dreads losing the beloved (Homilies on 1 John, 9.5).
And then he reaches into the sewing basket for an image. When we stitch, he says, the bristle goes in first and draws the thread after it; the bristle must come out again for the thread to take its place. So fear “first occupies the mind,” but does not stay there: “it enters only in order to introduce charity” (9.4). Fear is the needle. Love is the thread.
The Catechism says the same in its own language: the Christian “no longer stands before God as a slave, in servile fear,” but as a son responding to the love of the One who loved us first (CCC 1828). It lists fear of the Lord among the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit (CCC 1831; Isaiah 11:2–3). And Pope Francis, ending a series of catecheses on those gifts, insisted that this gift “does not mean being afraid of God.” It reminds us, he said, how small we are before God and how great is his love, and it frees us to entrust ourselves to him like children (General Audience, 11 June 2014).
The third servant in today’s Gospel had the first kind of fear: “I knew that you were a harsh man.” Jonah’s sailors ended their night with the second.
The Sea Beneath the Week
Step back from the seven verses and something becomes visible, like a reef beneath clear water. Running under almost all of them is one story: the night Israel stood between Pharaoh’s chariots and the sea.
Read Exodus 14 again with this week in mind.
“In great fear the Israelites cried out to the LORD.” (14:10) — the fear that calls, as in Joel.
“Do not be afraid, stand firm, and see the deliverance that the LORD will accomplish for you today.” (14:13) — the command of Deuteronomy 20, and the posture of the three young men left standing on the plain.
“The LORD will fight for you, and you have only to keep still.” (14:14) — the priest’s speech in Deuteronomy 20:4.
“The Israelites went into the sea on dry ground.” (14:22) — the sea and dry land of Jonah’s creed.
“So the people feared the LORD and believed in the LORD.” (14:31) — fear redirected and joined to faith, as with Jonah’s sailors, as in Psalm 40:3, as in 1 John 5:4.
And then they sang (15:1), as the psalmist sang his “new song” and the three young men sang inside the fire.
At the far end of the Bible, the Book of Revelation sees the same scene transfigured: “those who had conquered the beast and its image” — its image, as on the plain of Dura (compare Revelation 13:15) — “standing beside the sea of glass,” singing “the song of Moses, the servant of God, and the song of the Lamb” (Revelation 15:2–3). Conquerors, using 1 John’s verb. An image refused. A sea crossed. A song. The whole week in a single vision.
Read together, this week’s Scriptures seem to teach three things we easily miss.
First, Scripture does not abolish fear; it re-aims it. From Jonah’s sailors to Israel at the sea to the disciples in Mark’s boat, fear is not removed but transferred. Jesus puts both halves of the movement into a few lines: “Do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul; rather fear him … So do not be afraid; you are of more value than many sparrows” — with every hair of your head counted (Matthew 10:28–31). The fear placed rightly is what makes the “do not be afraid” possible.
Second, the fear Scripture blesses is joined to trust and to love.“Many will see and fear, and put their trust in the LORD” (Psalm 40:3). “The people feared the LORD and believed” (Exodus 14:31). The third servant feared a harsh master who did not exist; the woman of Proverbs 31 feared a God whose goodness made her open her hands. So the decisive question is not “How afraid am I of God?” It is “Which God am I afraid of?”
Third, faith is not a forecast but a belonging, and it rests on a victory already won.“But if not” (Daniel 3:18). “The LORD your God is with you” (Deuteronomy 20:1). “The victory that has overcome the world” (1 John 5:4). Isaiah gathers fire and water — Daniel and Jonah — into one promise:
“Do not fear, for I have redeemed you; I have called you by name, you are mine. When you pass through the waters, I will be with you; and through the rivers, they shall not overwhelm you; when you walk through fire you shall not be burned, and the flame shall not consume you.” (Isaiah 43:1–2)
“I have called you by name.” Joel’s two callings, in a single line.
Where interpreters differ
Several questions raised this week remain open among careful readers. Scholars disagree about the genre and historicity of Jonah, and about the dates of Daniel and Joel. The Aramaic of Daniel 3:17 can be construed in more than one way. The traditional Hebrew text of Isaiah 2:12 ends with a word that translators either repoint or replace. Psalm 40:11 may be read as petition or as confident statement. Commentators weigh differently what moment the past tense of 1 John 5:4 refers to. And the war laws of Deuteronomy 20 raise moral questions that Catholic tradition answers by reading them within the whole of salvation history and in the light of Christ. None of these questions changes what the seven verses say together.
A Rise & Inspire Moment
Go back, one last time, to the deck of Jonah’s ship.
Twice in that chapter the sailors let go of something.
The first time is in the middle of the storm: “They threw the cargo that was in the ship into the sea, to lighten it for them” (1:5). Everything they had loaded at Joppa — the merchandise, the profit of the voyage, perhaps a family’s savings — went over the side in a panic. Fear made them let go.
The second time is after the sea has fallen silent: “they offered a sacrifice to the LORD and made vows” (1:16). Again they let go of something. But this time nothing was torn out of their hands. They gave.
Same sailors. Same ship. Same act of letting go. The difference was not how much they surrendered, but to whom.
Every life has both moments. The fears of this world will strip us anyway, sooner or later — of cargo, of reputation, of time, of health, at last of breath. The only question is whether, before the end, we will have learned to offer what fear would otherwise only have taken.
Fear of the storm throws things overboard. The fear of the Lord turns them into an offering.
The Question at the Centre
People who study our reactions to danger often speak of fight, flight and freeze; in recent decades some have added a fourth, fawn — the instinct to appease whatever threatens us. It is striking how closely this week’s Scriptures anticipate the list. Jonah takes flight. The crowd at Dura fawns, bowing on cue. The third servant freezes and buries. Scripture does not mock any of them. These are the reflexes of creatures who know they are small.
What is remarkable is the alternative Scripture offers. It is not, in the end, fight. At the Red Sea and in Deuteronomy alike, “the LORD will fight for you” (Exodus 14:14; Deuteronomy 20:4). Instead, Scripture offers two other verbs: call (Joel 2:32) and stand (Exodus 14:13; Daniel 3; “having done everything, to stand firm,” Ephesians 6:13).
So the tension at the heart of the week is not between fear and fearlessness. It is between two directions in which fear can face:
We are terrified of things that cannot finally harm us, and casual about the One who holds our life in his hands.
And what we fear most, we quietly obey. Fear the market, and the market becomes your master. Fear the crowd, and it will tell you when to kneel. Fear the critic, the superior, the diagnosis, the future, and each will rule you in turn. Fear the Lord — with the chaste fear of a child who cannot bear to lose a Father’s love — and every one of them shrinks back to its real size.
The question this week sets before each of us is not Am I afraid? It is this:
Whom do I fear enough to obey — and is that fear making me run, bow, bury, or call?
Where the Storm Finds Us
At work and in public life
The furnace rarely blazes in an office. It arrives as a transfer order, a promotion that quietly stalls, a hint that one ought to be more “cooperative,” a file one knows to be wrong and is expected to sign. The music of Dura still plays in boardrooms, ministries and committee rooms, and most people bow not because they believe in the statue but because the sound tells them to. “But if not” is a professional virtue as much as a spiritual one: integrity that does not depend on the outcome. Anyone who has held public office or a position of trust knows how costly it can be, and how much depends on the few who remain standing.
Online
The orchestra of Dura has been replaced by the algorithm. When outrage trends, everyone is expected to kneel — to post, to condemn, to join — and the fear of being out of step is one of the most powerful forces of our time. Deuteronomy’s observation still holds: fear is contagious, and one melting heart melts others. Sometimes faithfulness looks like simply not bowing — declining to share, to pile on, to perform.
In the family
Parents and grandparents carry fears for their children that no one else sees. Deuteronomy’s answer is memory. Israel was to face every new army by recalling “the one who brought you up from the land of Egypt.” Families can do the same: tell the children — perhaps this very week, with India’s Children’s Day just past — the stories of how God brought the family through illness, migration, poverty, grief. A child who knows the family’s Exodus will face their own Red Sea with more courage.
With money
The third servant’s spade is never far from our hands. Much hoarding is simply fear in a bank account: the “just in case” that never comes, while someone else’s case is already here. On this World Day of the Poor, Psalm 40 asks whether the compassion we beg God not to lock away is locked away in us.
In the life of faith
Jonah’s real fear was that God would be merciful to the wrong people. Parishes and movements can carry the same fear — of newcomers, of change, of people who do not look or worship as we do. And many believers carry the opposite fear: of speaking about their faith at all. The psalmist’s “I have not restrained my lips” (40:9) is not a call to aggressive preaching. It is a refusal to bury the one story that is not ours to hide.
In illness, ageing and the approach of death
The deepest fear of all is named in the Letter to the Hebrews: Christ came to “free those who all their lives were held in slavery by the fear of death” (Hebrews 2:15). Psalm 40 is a companion for anyone who has been rescued once — from an operation, an accident, a crisis — and finds the pit opening again. Mercy is not asked for once. It is asked for as often as it is needed, and it is never locked away.
A pastoral word
Not every fear is a spiritual failure. Anxiety disorders, panic and the long shadows of trauma are real conditions, and Scripture’s word to the frightened is never “just try harder.” Seeking medical or psychological help is not a lack of faith. It can be one of the ways we call on the name of the Lord — and receive his help through other hands.
Five Steps Off the Ship to Tarshish
1. Name your Tarshish (Jonah 1:2–3). Identify one thing you have been avoiding out of fear — a conversation, a decision, an apology, a duty. Before Wednesday, take one concrete step towards it. The captain’s word is enough: Get up.
2. Write your “but if not” (Daniel 3:17–18). Take one current worry and complete this sentence on paper: “Lord, I hope you will ______. But if not, I will still ______.” Keep it in your wallet or on your phone, and pray it each morning this week.
3. Count the drowned chariots (Deuteronomy 20:1). List three occasions when God brought you through something you feared. Then tell one of those stories to a younger person — a child, a grandchild, a student, a colleague — before next Sunday.
4. Dig up one talent (Matthew 25:25; Psalm 40:9–10). Name one gift you have kept buried out of fear of failure or criticism, and use it once, in the open, this week. And for the World Day of the Poor, give away one thing you have been keeping “just in case” — or give an hour to listening to someone who is poor, rather than merely speaking about them.
5. Call on the Name (Joel 2:32; CCC 2667–2668). Each time fear rises this week, pray slowly: Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me. And on one morning before Saturday, pray the song of the three young men (Daniel 3:57–88) aloud at the start of the day — the song first sung from inside a fire.
Questions for the Quiet Hour
In Jonah 1, the sailors’ fear grows and changes its object. What exactly changes between verse 5 and verse 16 — and what does that change reveal about the kind of fear Scripture praises?
Of the four faces of fear in this study — the fear that runs, bows, buries and calls — which do I recognise most in myself, and in which part of my life?
What “music” tells me when to kneel — at work, online, among friends, even in church — and when did I last remain standing?
What picture of God lies behind my fears? Is it closer to the third servant’s “harsh man,” or to the God whose compassion is never locked away?
Before next Sunday, what is one thing I will stop burying, and in what moment will I call on the name of the Lord instead of running?
A Litany Against Lesser Fears
Lord, God of heaven, Maker of the sea and the dry land, you see the storms I am in, and the ones I have made.
From the fear that runs from your call, and boards the ship to Tarshish with a creed on its lips — deliver me, Lord.
From the fear that bows when the music plays, and kneels because everyone else is kneeling — deliver me, Lord.
From the fear that counts the horses and forgets the sea, and measures my life by the size of what opposes me — deliver me, Lord.
From the fear that buries what you entrusted to me, because I imagined you harsh — deliver me, Lord.
From the pride that would rather hide in the rock than kneel before your height — deliver me, Lord.
Into the fear that calls upon your name — lead me, Lord.
Into the courage that stands and says, “But if not” — lead me, Lord.
Into the chaste fear of a child who cannot bear to lose his Father’s love — lead me, Lord.
Lord Jesus, lifted up on the cross and lifted up in glory, you slept in the storm and rose to command the sea; you walk in the fire with those who will not bow. Let my faith rest in the victory you have already won.
Where I have hidden your gifts, forgive me. Where I have kept silent about your love, open my lips. And do not lock your compassion away from me: let your steadfast love and your faithfulness stand guard over me, today and for ever. Amen.
To Carry Into the Week
Only the fear of the Lord is large enough to make every other fear small.
Before the King Comes
Next Sunday the Church closes its year with the Solemnity of Our Lord Jesus Christ, King of the Universe, and the Gospel takes up exactly where today’s leaves off, in Matthew 25 — with the King who says that whatever was done “to one of the least of these” was done to him (25:40). Advent begins a week later, on 29 November.
The disciples in Mark’s boat ended their night with a question they could not yet answer: “Who then is this, that even the wind and the sea obey him?” (Mark 4:41). Next Sunday the Church will give its answer. He is the One who is truly high and lifted up — and who was lifted up on a cross, so that no storm, no furnace, no army and no grave would ever again be the largest thing in our lives.
Until then, here is a question to carry slowly through the week, perhaps in the quiet before sleep:
What would I do this week, if I were no longer afraid of anything — except losing him?
Which passage of Scripture would you like us to open together in a future Sunday Series? Share it in the comments. The verse you cannot stop thinking about may be the very one another reader needs.
Rise & Inspire — Sunday Bible SeriesDepth over speed. Understanding over volume. Formation over information.
Written by John Britto Kurusumuthu
Each morning, His Excellency, Rt. Rev. Dr. Selvister Ponnumuthan, Bishop of the Diocese of Punalur, shares a verse from the Bible. The seven verses received over the course of each week are brought together and serve as the scriptural foundation for that week’s Sunday Bible Series.
Hard times rarely return us to who we were. A more honest way to stay resilient in hard times is not to bounce back, but to learn how to begin again.
John Britto Kurusumuthu · Rise & Inspire · 14 November 2026 · Daily Prompts
The word resilience comes from the Latin resilire, “to leap back.” Engineers still use it in that sense: a resilient material springs back to its original shape after being bent or compressed.
It is a useful picture, but a misleading one for human life. Hard times often leave no original shape to return to. Someone who loses a spouse after forty years, a career at fifty, or their health in midlife does not spring back into the person they were. Pretending otherwise only adds to the pain.
Over the years, I have come to understand that resilience is not about being strong all the time, or pretending that difficulties do not affect us. It is not about hiding our sadness, suppressing our fears, or convincing ourselves that everything will eventually happen as we wish.
More often, it begins with a simple but profound decision: accepting reality without surrendering to despair.
THE SHORT ANSWER Resilience is the capacity to adapt to hardship, not merely to return to how things were. It means accepting what has changed, feeling what it costs, drawing on what remains, and taking the next meaningful step. Most of us cannot go back. Resilience is the courage to begin again from where we stand.
What Resilience Really Means
Scientists who study resilience moved beyond the bounce-back picture long ago. In a 1996 essay, the ecologist C. S. Holling distinguished “engineering resilience,” which measures how quickly a system returns to a single stable state, from “ecological resilience,” which asks how much disturbance a system can absorb and still keep functioning, even if it settles into a different state. A forest that survives a fire may never regrow into the same forest. Yet it remains a living forest.
Psychology has reached a similar conclusion. The American Psychological Association defines resilience as “the process and outcome of successfully adapting to difficult or challenging life experiences.” The key word is adapting, not returning. The psychologists Stephen Lepore and Tracey Revenson describe three forms that resilience can take: recovery, resistance and reconfiguration. In the third, a person regains balance in a changed form, with important parts of life reshaped by what they have been through.
The encouraging part is that this capacity is not rare. The developmental psychologist Ann Masten famously described resilience as “ordinary magic”: it grows out of ordinary human resources such as relationships, routines and the everyday ability to adapt, rather than out of extraordinary strength. The APA likewise notes that resilience involves behaviours, thoughts and actions that anyone can learn and develop.
Five Ways to Stay Resilient in Hard Times
What follows is not a formula. These are five practices I have come to believe in, and on which the world’s wisdom traditions and modern research seem, remarkably, to agree.
1. Accept What Cannot Be Changed
In difficult times, we regret past decisions, replay old conversations, and long for circumstances that are no longer within our reach. In an earlier reflection on regret and hindsight, I wrote about the Buddhist image of the “second arrow”: the extra suffering we add by fighting what has already happened.
The Zhuangzi, a classic of Chinese Daoist thought, offers another image. Confucius, the story goes, once watched a man plunge into the torrent below the falls at Lüliang, where the water raced so fiercely that no fish could swim. Fearing the man would drown, Confucius sent his disciples to save him, only to find him strolling along the bank, singing. Asked how he had survived, the man said he went down with the whirl and came up with it again. In James Legge’s translation: “I follow the way of the water, and do nothing contrary to it of myself.”
Notice what the swimmer does not do. He does not fight the water. But he does not stop swimming either. That is acceptance at its best.
Acceptance does not mean approving of everything that happens. Nor does it mean giving up. It means acknowledging the truth of our situation and finding the wisdom to distinguish between what we can change and what we must learn to live with: the very wisdom asked for in the Serenity Prayer, now credited with reasonable confidence to the theologian Reinhold Niebuhr.
Acceptance is not resignation. A caution is needed here. Acceptance has a counterfeit, and its name is resignation. Resignation says, “Nothing can be done.” Acceptance says, “This has happened. Now, what can be done?” Some things we call unchangeable are only things we have grown tired of trying to change. An injustice, a strained relationship, a harmful habit: these may call for courage rather than acceptance. As I argued in an earlier essay, believing in destiny is no excuse to stop trying. Wisdom lies in knowing which is which, and in asking someone we trust when we cannot tell.
2. Allow Yourself to Feel
Resilience does not require us to be emotionally invincible. There are days when disappointment weighs heavily, uncertainty breeds anxiety, and even ordinary responsibilities feel demanding. It is perfectly human to feel discouraged. Even the APA’s own guidance acknowledges that the road to resilience is likely to run through considerable emotional distress.
The Book of Psalms, a book of prayer and praise, contains a psalm that never finds its way to comfort. Most laments in the Psalter turn towards trust before they end. Psalm 88 does not; in the Hebrew, its final word is “darkness.” Yet those who gathered the Psalms kept it. They seem to have understood that grief spoken honestly is not a failure of faith or of strength. It is part of coming through.
Modern neuroscience offers an intriguing echo. In a 2007 brain-imaging study at UCLA, Matthew Lieberman and his colleagues found that simply putting feelings into words reduced the response of the amygdala, a brain region involved in emotional distress. The researchers caution that the effect is modest. Still, the principle is old and sound: a sorrow that is named is easier to carry than one that is buried.
We need not pretend to be cheerful when we are struggling. We can pause, reflect, seek comfort, and give ourselves time to recover. Nor need we carry everything alone. Asking for help is often the wisest use of whatever strength we have left. Sharing a burden with friends who have stood the test of time does not make it disappear, but it can make it bearable.
3. Look at What Remains
When life takes something away from us, our attention naturally fixes on what we have lost. If it stays fixed there, we overlook what remains: people who still care about us, relationships worth nurturing, small joys still within reach, and opportunities to contribute to the lives of others. Often, life’s greatest gifts are the ones too familiar to notice.
Gratitude does not deny the loss. It simply refuses to let the loss become the only thing we can see.
Faith, too, can be an inner anchor in uncertain times. Prayer, meditation and spiritual reflection, in whatever tradition we practise them, can help us accept our limitations, release unnecessary worries, and trust that we are not alone in our struggles. The APA itself lists spiritual practices such as prayer and meditation among the ways people rebuild connection and hope. We may not receive immediate answers to our questions, but we can find comfort in believing that life still holds meaning beyond our present difficulties. I have written elsewhere about what life taught me, rather late, about control and faith: that doing my part and leaving the outcome in God’s hands is not the same as giving up.
4. Take the Next Step, Not the Whole Road
When we face a difficult situation, the distance between where we are and where we wish to be can overwhelm us. Instead of worrying about the entire journey, we can concentrate on the next meaningful step: completing an unfinished responsibility, having an honest conversation, keeping a healthier routine, seeking professional guidance, or simply beginning another day.
The Japanese psychiatrist Shoma Morita (1874–1938) built an entire therapy around this insight. Its central principle, arugamama, is usually translated “as it is.” It asks us to accept our feelings as they are, without fighting or fleeing them, and to do what needs to be done anyway. We do not have to feel brave before we act. Often the courage comes after the step, not before it.
TRY THIS TODAY: THE TWO-COLUMN PAGE Draw a line down the middle of a page. On the left, write what you cannot change. On the right, write what you can. Then choose one item from the right-hand column and act on it today, however small. The left-hand column is not a list of failures. It is a list of things you are learning to let go of.
Small steps may not transform our circumstances overnight, but they gradually restore our confidence and sense of direction. Resilience is built through these ordinary decisions, repeated patiently over time. It is, in the end, less a single feat than a personal philosophy of moving forward.
5. Hope Without Illusions
I have learned that hope does not mean expecting life to fulfil all our wishes. It means remaining open to possibilities even when the present seems unfavourable.
This kind of hope is not naive. About six months after the September 11 attacks, the psychologist George Bonanno and his colleagues surveyed 2,752 people living in and around New York City. By the study’s definition, no more than one symptom of post-traumatic stress, 65.1 per cent were resilient. Resilience was less common among those most heavily exposed, a reminder that it is a capacity, not a guarantee. But it is far more common than we tend to assume.
A difficult chapter is part of our story; it need not become the whole of it. Circumstances may change, new opportunities may emerge, and we may discover strengths we never knew we possessed. Even when full recovery is no longer possible, as I explored in what gives life value when recovery seems impossible, something worthwhile can still be lived for.
We cannot always control what happens to us, but we can work towards choosing how we respond. That choice does not make every hardship disappear. It gives us a way to face it without allowing despair to take control.
The Courage to Begin Again
So resilience is not really about bouncing back at all. A spring returns to its old shape; a person who has come through real hardship rarely does. We come out changed: sometimes more cautious, sometimes more compassionate, often wiser about what truly matters.
Research on post-traumatic growth bears this out. The psychologists Richard Tedeschi and Lawrence Calhoun, who developed the concept, found that many people who struggle through serious crises later report a greater appreciation of life, deeper relationships, a stronger sense of personal strength, changed priorities and a richer spiritual life. They are careful to add that the events themselves remain deeply distressing, and that growth must never be expected of everyone who suffers. Growth comes from the struggle, not from the suffering itself.
Resilience, then, is not the power to return. It is the courage to begin again from where we actually stand.
Acceptance helps us make peace with the present; hope gives us the courage to face tomorrow. We may not be able to choose every circumstance that life brings us, but we can keep choosing courage over helplessness, gratitude over bitterness, and hope over despair.
That, to me, is resilience.
A Question for Reflection
When life takes an unexpected turn, what helps you accept reality, regain your inner strength, and find the courage to begin again?
I would love to hear your thoughts and experiences in the comments.
Frequently Asked Questions About Resilience
What is resilience in simple terms?
Resilience is the ability to adapt well to hardship, loss or serious stress. The American Psychological Association describes it as both a process and an outcome: we keep functioning, find meaning and move forward, even when life does not return to exactly what it was before.
Is resilience the same as bouncing back?
Not always. Some setbacks allow a full return to normal, but major losses usually change us. Researchers distinguish returning to a previous state from adapting to a new one. For many people, resilience means beginning again in a changed life rather than going back to the old one.
What is the difference between acceptance and resignation?
Acceptance acknowledges what has happened and then asks what can still be done. Resignation concludes that nothing can be done. Acceptance leads to wise action; resignation leads to withdrawal. Some situations, such as injustice or a harmful habit, call for action rather than acceptance.
Is it normal to feel sad or anxious while trying to be resilient?
Yes. Resilience does not mean feeling no pain. The APA notes that the road to resilience is likely to involve considerable emotional distress. Naming your feelings honestly, to yourself or to someone you trust, is part of coming through hard times, not a sign of weakness.
How can I build resilience in hard times?
Start small. Accept what cannot be changed, name what you feel, stay connected to people who care about you, notice what still remains, and take one meaningful step each day. Research suggests that resilience is built from ordinary resources and habits that anyone can learn and practise.
When should I seek professional help?
If distress lasts for weeks, disrupts your sleep, work or relationships, or if you have thoughts of harming yourself, speak to a doctor or mental health professional promptly. In India, the government’s free Tele-MANAS helpline is available 24 hours a day on 14416 or 1-800-891-4416.
Bonanno, G. A., Galea, S., Bucciarelli, A., & Vlahov, D. (2006). Psychological resilience after disaster: New York City in the aftermath of the September 11th terrorist attack. Psychological Science, 17(3), 181–186. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2006.01682.x
Holling, C. S. (1996). Engineering resilience versus ecological resilience. In P. C. Schulze (Ed.), Engineering within ecological constraints (pp. 31–44). National Academy Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/4919
Lepore, S. J., & Revenson, T. A. (2006). Resilience and posttraumatic growth: Recovery, resistance, and reconfiguration. In L. G. Calhoun & R. G. Tedeschi (Eds.), Handbook of posttraumatic growth: Research and practice (pp. 24–46). Lawrence Erlbaum. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315805597-4
Lieberman, M. D., Eisenberger, N. I., Crockett, M. J., Tom, S. M., Pfeifer, J. H., & Way, B. M. (2007). Putting feelings into words: Affect labeling disrupts amygdala activity in response to affective stimuli. Psychological Science, 18(5), 421–428. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2007.01916.x
Shapiro, F. (2014, May 15). How I discovered I was wrong about the origin of the Serenity Prayer. Religion News Service. https://religionnews.com/?p=73196
Tedeschi, R. G., & Calhoun, L. G. (2004). Posttraumatic growth: Conceptual foundations and empirical evidence. Psychological Inquiry, 15(1), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327965pli1501_01
Strive to rise above challenges. Strive to inspire others.
Not every gut feeling is intuition. Two stories, one landmark piece of research and four questions to help you tell the difference before you act.
John Britto Kurusumuthu · 13 November 2026 · Daily Prompts
At a Glance: Intuition or emotion? Intuition is experience recognising a pattern faster than words can explain it. Emotion is often a reaction to our own state: hurry, fear, pride or an old hurt. A gut feeling deserves trust when it grows from long, honest experience of similar situations, points to something you can observe, and survives a pause.
Two Decisions, Two Very Different Outcomes
A fire lieutenant once led his crew into a burning house. The fire appeared to be in the kitchen, but the water they turned on it made little difference. Something felt wrong. He could not say what, yet he ordered everyone out. Moments after they left, the floor they had been standing on collapsed. The real fire was in the basement beneath them.[1]
In an ancient Tamil epic, a king was hurrying to make peace with his queen after a quarrel when the royal goldsmith stopped him with news: the thief who had stolen her anklet had been found. The king asked no questions. He ordered the man killed and the anklet brought to the queen’s chambers.[2]
Both men acted on an inner certainty, within moments. One saved his crew. The other put an innocent man to death.
Today’s prompt asks, “What’s a time you ignored your gut — and paid for it?” When I look back on decisions I came to regret, I notice that the trouble was not always that I ignored my gut. Sometimes I obeyed a feeling I had mistaken for it.
Fear may speak in the voice of wisdom. Anxiety may present itself as a warning. A past hurt we have never let go of may pass judgment on a person who has done nothing to deserve it. Feelings deserve attention, but they do not always deserve unquestioned obedience.
When Can You Trust Your Gut? What the Research Says
The firefighter’s story comes from the psychologist Gary Klein, who studied how experienced professionals make decisions under pressure. The lieutenant first credited a sixth sense. Questioned later, he found the real reasons: the room was far hotter than a kitchen fire should have made it, and strangely quiet. Years of fires had taught him what a kitchen fire feels like. This one did not fit.[1,4]
Klein and the Nobel laureate Daniel Kahneman, once on opposite sides of the debate on intuition, later set out together when a gut feeling deserves trust. Two conditions must be met. The situation must be regular enough to have patterns, and the person must have had long practice in it with honest feedback. They added a warning that goes to the heart of this essay: “Subjective experience is not a reliable indicator of judgment accuracy.”[3] Feeling sure is not the same as being right.
Intuition, in that sense, is experience speaking faster than words. The king’s certainty had no such foundation. His mind was already in the queen’s chambers. His feeling came from his hurry, not from the man accused before him.
The firefighter’s feeling was about the fire. The king’s feeling was about the king.
How to Tell Intuition from Emotion: Four Questions to Cross-Examine a Feeling
Before a strong feeling makes a decision for you, ask it four questions.
1. Has this feeling earned its authority?
Have I met this kind of situation often, and learned honestly from the results? A nurse’s unease about a patient may carry years of experience. My first impression of a stranger usually carries far less than it seems to.
2. Is it about the situation, or about me?
Intuition points outward, to something in front of me that does not fit. Emotion often points inward, to my hurry, my pride, my fear of failure, or an old disappointment.
3. Can I name what I noticed?
Genuine intuition rests on something observed, even when it takes time to put into words. The firefighter could later name the heat and the silence. If, after honest reflection, I can name nothing but discomfort, the discomfort may be the whole story.
4. Will it survive a pause?
Two traditions, far apart, point the same way. The Stoic teacher Epictetus advised meeting a forceful impression with the words, “Wait for me a little, O impression; allow me to see who you are.”[5] Some fourteen centuries later, Ignatius of Loyola, guiding people in spiritual discernment, counselled “in time of desolation never to make a change,” but to stay firm in the resolution made before it.[6] A real intuition usually survives a night of quiet reflection. A passing mood rarely does.
The Case for the Other Side: When Reason Misleads Too
None of this makes reason the safer guide by default. Reason wears disguises too. We are skilled at building arguments for what we already want. Many regrets begin with a clear inner warning that we talked ourselves out of, because we trusted someone’s assurances or did not want to disappoint others.
In an emergency, there is no time for four questions. The firefighter had seconds. That is precisely why a trained instinct matters: it is built in ordinary years for the moment that allows no thought.
Regret, then, should not make us suspicious of every opportunity or every person. It should make us better judges of our own feelings.
The Verdict: What the King Teaches Us
The epic is the Silappatikaram.[2] When the condemned man’s widow, Kannagi, broke open her remaining anklet before the court, rubies spilt out. The queen’s anklet had held pearls. The king asked how a king could have acted on the word of a goldsmith, declared that he himself was the thief, and died of remorse.
His tragedy was not that he ignored his gut. It was that he never questioned it.
Don’t ignore your gut, but don’t let your emotions make decisions in the name of intuition.
Sometimes, the most important voice to listen to is not the loudest feeling within us, but the quiet understanding that emerges when we pause, reflect, and think clearly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between intuition and emotion?
Intuition is rapid pattern recognition built from experience. It notices that something in a situation does not fit, often before you can explain why. Emotion is a reaction that frequently reflects your own state, such as fear, hurry, pride or an old hurt. Both can feel like certainty, which is why they are so easily confused.
When can you trust your gut feeling?
According to Daniel Kahneman and Gary Klein, intuition deserves trust when the situation is regular enough to contain patterns, and you have had long practice in it with honest feedback. An experienced nurse’s unease about a patient meets that test far more often than a first impression of a stranger.
How do you know whether it is fear or intuition?
Ask where the feeling points. Intuition usually points to something outside you that can eventually be named. Fear often points to what might happen to you. Time also helps: a passing fear often looks different after rest, while a grounded intuition tends to remain.
Should you ever act on a gut feeling immediately?
Yes, in a genuine emergency, especially when the instinct has been trained by experience, as the firefighter’s was. Outside emergencies, there is usually time to pause, test the feeling and then decide.
A Question for You
Have you ever mistaken fear, anxiety, or a past disappointment for intuition? Or have you talked yourself out of a warning that later proved right? Share your experience in the comments. It may help someone else learn to tell the difference.
Note for Readers
The Silappatikaram (The Tale of an Anklet), attributed to the poet-ascetic Ilango Adigal, is the earliest of the five great epics of classical Tamil literature. Modern scholars generally date it to around the fifth or sixth century CE, though some place it earlier. In it, Kovalan, a merchant, is falsely accused by the royal goldsmith of stealing the Pandyan queen’s anklet and is executed without inquiry. His wife, Kannagi, proves his innocence before King Nedunchezhiyan in the canto known as Vazhakkurai Kathai (“The Pleading of the Case”).
References
1. Klein, Gary. Sources of Power: How People Make Decisions. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1998. Source of the fire lieutenant’s account.
2. Ilango Adigal. The Cilappatikāram of Iḷaṅkō Aṭikaḷ: An Epic of South India. Translated by R. Parthasarathy. New York: Columbia University Press, 1993. See also V. R. Ramachandra Dikshitar, trans., The Silappadikaram (Oxford University Press, 1939), and the summary by the National Virtual Library of India: /Internet Archive link
3. Kahneman, Daniel, and Gary Klein. “Conditions for Intuitive Expertise: A Failure to Disagree.” American Psychologist 64, no. 6 (2009): 515–526. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0016755.
4. Kahneman, Daniel. Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2011. Chapter 22, “Expert Intuition: When Can We Trust It?”
5. Epictetus. Discourses 2.18. In Epictetus: The Discourses as Reported by Arrian, the Manual, and Fragments, vol. 1. Translated by W. A. Oldfather. Loeb Classical Library. London: William Heinemann, 1926. https://archive.org/details/epictetusdiscour01epicuoft.
6. Ignatius of Loyola. The Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola. Translated by Elder Mullan, S.J. New York: P. J. Kenedy & Sons, 1914. Rules for perceiving the movements caused in the soul (the Rules for the Discernment of Spirits), First Week, Fifth Rule (§318 in the standard numbering). https://www.ccel.org/ccel/ignatius/exercises.all.html.
By John Britto Kurusumuthu · Rise & Inspire · 12 November 2026 · 6-minute read
Today’s prompt asks what I have forgiven but not forgotten. There is something. I will not name it here. Naming it would mean telling the story once more, and every retelling puts the same person back in the wrong. I stopped doing that some time ago.
The prompt quietly assumes that the “not forgotten” part is a leftover, a sign that the forgiving is unfinished. I have come to believe the opposite. You cannot forgive what you have forgotten.
IN BRIEF Forgiveness does not require forgetting; it requires memory. To forgive is to decide about a wrong you remember. What forgiveness releases is not the memory, but the resentment and the sense that a debt is still owed. Memory, kept without rehearsal, also protects the boundaries and the slow rebuilding of trust that forgiveness alone cannot restore.
1. Forgetting Is Not the Summit of Forgiveness; It Is Its Absence
Forgiveness is a decision about something you know. A debt can be cancelled only by someone who remembers that it is owed; a debt that has slipped off the books has not been cancelled, merely lost. Forgiveness is a gift precisely because the giver knows what it costs.
Psychology arrives at the same place. Robert Enright, a pioneer of forgiveness research, defines forgiveness in part as “a willingness to abandon one’s right to resentment.”1 No one can give up a right they have forgotten they hold.
2. “Forgive and Forget”: Why the Plea Often Comes from the Wrong Side
We say “forgive and forget.” Shakespeare has it the other way round. Near the end of King Lear (Act 4, Scene 7), the old king wakes in the care of Cordelia, the daughter he disowned. He tells her she has some cause not to love him. She replies, “No cause, no cause.” Later in the scene he pleads, “Pray you now, forget and forgive. I am old and foolish.”2
Notice who asks for forgetting, and that he puts it first. Forgetting is often the convenience of the one who caused the wound. Cordelia, for her part, never claims to have forgotten. She declares that what she remembers will no longer count as a cause. That is forgiveness in four words.
3. The Enemy Is Not Memory but Rehearsal
The Dhammapada, a Pali collection of the Buddha’s sayings, draws this line precisely. Its third verse lists four complaints: he insulted me, he struck me, he defeated me, he robbed me. Where such thoughts are constantly revisited, it says, hatred does not cease. The fourth verse repeats the four complaints word for word: where they are not revisited, hatred comes to rest.3
The wrong is named in both verses. What changes is not the memory but the habit of revisiting it: replaying the conversation, rehearsing the reply we should have given, reopening files we had long since closed.
Modern psychology has put this ancient intuition to the test. In three longitudinal studies, Michael McCullough and his colleagues found that as people ruminated more about a hurt, their forgiveness declined, largely because rumination kept their anger alive. In the third study, the evidence suggested that the rumination came first.4
There is a difference between remembering a wound and continuing to live inside it. The former can make us wiser; the latter can prevent us from finding peace.
4. Why Forgiveness Needs Memory to Stay Wise
Forgiveness settles the past. Trust is credit extended to the future, and it has to be earned again; forgiveness does not automatically hand back the keys. As the psychologist Everett Worthington puts it, “Forgiveness happens inside people’s skin. Reconciliation happens between people.”5
In The Book of Forgiving, Desmond Tutu and his daughter Mpho Tutu describe a fourfold path: telling the story, naming the hurt, granting forgiveness, and renewing or releasing the relationship.6 The first two steps are acts of remembering. The last admits that a relationship may be released without forgiveness being withdrawn.
We can forgive someone and still establish boundaries. We can wish them well without returning to the same relationship. We can treat them with kindness without giving them the same place in our lives. None of this is possible without memory.
5. Does the Highest Forgiveness Require Forgetting?
Some traditions seem to say so. Through the prophet Jeremiah, God promises, “I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more” (Jeremiah 31:34). If God forgives by forgetting, why should we remember?
The Hebrew verb for “remember,” zakar, often means more than recall; it carries the sense of acting on what is remembered.7 When Genesis says that “God remembered Noah” (Genesis 8:1), it does not mean that God had lost track of him. The very next words tell of a wind sent over the earth to make the waters recede. To remember sin no more, then, is to promise never again to bring it forward as a charge. Paul speaks in the same spirit of the Lord choosing not to count sin against the forgiven (Romans 4:8). That is not amnesia. It is Cordelia’s answer: the memory remains, but it no longer counts as a cause.
I concede this much. Some hurts do fade with time, and we should let them go gratefully. But that fading is a mercy given to us, not a forgiveness given by us.
6. Forgiveness Is a Practice, Not a Single Event
Worthington distinguishes two movements within forgiveness. Decisional forgiveness is a resolve to treat the offender differently; emotional forgiveness is a slower change of heart in which resentment gives way to feelings such as empathy and compassion.5 The decision can be made in a day. The feelings follow at their own pace, and memory is where that work is done.
If forgiveness depends on memory, a memory’s return is not a failure. Each time it comes back, unbidden, it brings a fresh choice: to reopen the account and wait again for an apology that may never come, or to decline, once more, to treat it as a cause.
Conclusion: What I Have Forgiven but Not Forgotten
So what have I forgiven but not forgotten? I have answered without quite answering. I remember what happened. I have simply stopped keeping the account.
Perhaps that is the real strength of forgiveness: to remember without resentment, to forgive without losing wisdom, and to move forward without allowing yesterday’s pain to determine tomorrow’s happiness. Let us forgive where we can, learn where we must, and protect the peace we have worked so hard to find.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you forgive someone without forgetting what they did?
Yes. Forgiveness releases resentment, not memory. The International Forgiveness Institute notes that forgiving does not erase the memory of the event; the two can exist side by side.1 In fact, you can forgive only a wrong you remember. What changes is not whether you remember, but whether the memory still demands payment.
Is forgiveness the same as reconciliation?
No. Forgiveness is an inner decision; reconciliation is a restored relationship, and it needs trust on both sides.5 You can forgive someone and still decide, with good reason, not to resume the relationship. Where both sides are willing, the work of reconciliation can begin.
Does forgiveness require an apology?
No, though an apology helps. Many people forgive while still waiting for an apology that never comes. Reconciliation is another matter: it is far more likely when there is a genuine apology and a real change of behaviour.
Why do painful memories return after I have forgiven?
Because the decision to forgive and the healing of feelings move at different speeds.5Hurts that are never examined tend to resurface as repeated patterns. A returning memory is not proof that forgiveness failed. It is an invitation to give it again, and to stop rehearsing the old complaint.
Does the Bible say God forgets our sins?
Jeremiah 31:34 promises that God will “remember their sin no more.” In Hebrew usage, however, to remember often means to act upon. The promise is that sin will no longer be held against the forgiven, not that divine knowledge has lapsed.7
A Question for Reflection
Is there something you have forgiven but not forgotten? When the memory returns, do you take it as proof that your forgiveness failed, or as a chance to give it again?
Strive to rise above resentment, learn from experience, and inspire others through the wisdom you gain.
Notes and References
1. Robert D. Enright’s definition of forgiveness, as presented in Rosemary Kite, “The Art and Science of Forgiveness,” International Forgiveness Institute, 5 October 2019. The same article notes that forgiving does not erase the memory of the event. internationalforgiveness.com
2. William Shakespeare, King Lear, Act 4, Scene 7. Online text: The Complete Works of William Shakespeare, MIT. shakespeare.mit.edu
3. Dhammapada, verses 3–4 (Yamakavagga, “The Pairs”), paraphrased. For a public-domain translation, see F. Max Müller, trans., The Dhammapada, Sacred Books of the East, vol. 10 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1881), Project Gutenberg eBook no. 2017. gutenberg.org
4. Michael E. McCullough, Giacomo Bono and Lindsey M. Root, “Rumination, Emotion, and Forgiveness: Three Longitudinal Studies,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 92, no. 3 (2007): 490–505. doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.92.3.490
5. Everett L. Worthington Jr., The Science of Forgiveness (Virginia Commonwealth University, April 2020; published online by the John Templeton Foundation), pp. 4 and 9. templeton.org
6. Desmond Tutu and Mpho Tutu, The Book of Forgiving: The Fourfold Path for Healing Ourselves and Our World (New York: HarperOne, 2014).
7. W. E. Vine, Merrill F. Unger and William White Jr., Vine’s Complete Expository Dictionary of Old and New Testament Words (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 1996), s.v. “remember”; see also Sandra Aviv, “What Does ‘Remember’ Mean in Hebrew?,” Israel Bible Center, 31 August 2026. israelbiblecenter.com
Scripture quotations are from the King James Version.
Today’s prompt asks which video game world I would choose to live in. I am the wrong person to ask. A fortnight ago I confessed that my first video game had no screen at all: a circle in the dust, a few marbles and two pieces of wood.
So I did what an outsider should do. I read what the players chose. Among today’s answers I found a quiet farming village, the world of Pokémon, even the bare court of Pong. Each was chosen with confidence, and each rested on the same unspoken assumption.
1. Every answer arrives as the hero
No one imagines entering a favourite world as the man who sweeps the tavern floor. We picture ourselves as the player: the one who explores, collects, grows stronger and saves the day. That is natural. In a game, you are always the player.
2. Most of a game world is scenery
Every game is built around one person. Everyone else is what gamers call a non-player character: the shopkeeper, the guard, the villager who repeats the same three lines whenever you pass. They exist so that the hero’s story can happen. To live in such a world, rather than play it, means you would very likely be one of them.
3. A test from philosophy
In 1971 the American philosopher John Rawls proposed a test for a fair society.[1] He said we should choose its rules from behind a “veil of ignorance”, not knowing whether we will be born rich or poor, strong or weak, favoured or forgotten. Rules you would accept from any position are fair rules.
4. Run our favourite worlds through it
They change shape at once. Pong has two paddles and one ball, so you have a one-in-three chance of spending eternity being struck back and forth. In the world of Pokémon the trainers are few and the creatures many; you are more likely to live in the ball than to throw it. In the heroic kingdoms, someone must be the villager whose house burns in the opening scene so that the adventure can begin. In the cozy farming village, someone runs the small shop that the big new store is driving out of business.
None of this is a complaint against games. It is simply what the word “live” adds to the word “play”.
5. A poet who measured a kingdom from the bottom
Kamban, the Tamil poet who retold the Ramayana, gives many verses to the prosperity of Kosala, Rama’s homeland.[2] The verse most often quoted describes no palace. In Kosala, it says, there was no charity, because there was no poverty. There was no show of valour, because there were no enemies. Truth needed no defending, because no one lied. Kamban did not measure his ideal kingdom from the throne. He measured it from the place where a beggar would have stood, and found no one standing there.
6. The city with one cellar
Ursula K. Le Guin imagined the opposite in her 1973 story “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas”.[3] Omelas is a city of music, festivals and contented people. Its happiness depends on one child kept alone in a dark cellar, and every citizen knows it. Most make their peace with that. A few quietly walk away. Choose a world as its hero, and you may never visit the cellar. Choose it from behind the veil, and the cellar might be yours.
7. The fair objection
A gamer will say I have missed the point. Games are escapes, and nobody plays to be the baker. That is true, and for an evening there is no harm in being the hero. But the prompt does not ask where we would spend an evening. It asks where we would live, and living means accepting the place we are given. None of us chose our character in this world either. That is exactly why the test is worth taking.
8. My choice
So I would not choose the world with the grandest adventure. I would choose the one in which I could be content as its least important person. That person never enters the hero’s story and keeps a small field at the edge of the map. He is still safe, fed and fairly treated when the hero rides past. A few of the gentler worlds in today’s answers might pass that test. I shall not name one, because the name matters less than the test.
And the test does not stay inside the screen. The world we already live in deserves the same question: how does it treat the people nobody would choose to be?
Your turn: If you couldn’t choose your character, would you still choose your world? Tell me which world, and who you think you would most likely be in it.
Notes for readers
[1] John Rawls (1921 to 2002) was an American political philosopher. He set out the “veil of ignorance” in his book A Theory of Justice (1971).
[2] Kamban composed the Ramavataram, popularly called the Kamba Ramayanam, usually dated to the twelfth century. The verse appears in the Nattu Padalam (the canto on the country) of the Bala Kandam; verse numbers differ between editions. Its opening line runs “Vanmai illai or varumai inmaiyal”: there is no charity, for there is no poverty.
[3] Ursula K. Le Guin (1929 to 2018) first published “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas” in 1973, and it won the Hugo Award for best short story in 1974. She subtitled it “Variations on a theme by William James”. In his 1891 essay “The Moral Philosopher and the Moral Life”, James imagined a world whose happiness was bought by the lonely suffering of one lost soul.
John Britto Kurusumuthu
Rise & Inspire · riseandinspire.co.in
In response to the WordPress Daily Writing Prompt, 11 November 2026: If you got to live inside a video game world, which one would you choose?
For years I treated outcomes as my responsibility and my reactions as something that simply happened to me. Life taught me the reverse, and showed me where faith begins.
John Britto Kurusumuthu · Founder, Rise & Inspire · About 8 minutes’ reading
WordPress Daily Writing Prompt:What life lesson did you learn too late?
I had heard this lesson many times before I learned it. Some truths arrive early as information and late as understanding, and the distance between the two can take decades to cross.
Put simply, the lesson about control and faith that I learned too late is this: I cannot control everything, and I do not need all the answers to live by faith. What took me years to see was not the truth of it, but how completely I had been living against it.
Last month, answering a related prompt, I wrote that hindsight is a teacher, not a judge. Today’s question asks for something more personal: not what I would tell a younger self, but what I myself understood only late.
THE SHORT ANSWER
I had control the wrong way round. I spent years trying to manage outcomes that were never mine, and too little effort governing the responses that always were. Faith begins where control ends: it means doing my part fully and trusting God with the rest, even when no explanation is given.
1. I had the map upside down
For much of my life, I treated outcomes as my responsibility and my reactions as something that simply happened to me. I lost sleep over decisions that rested with other people: a promotion, a result, an opinion someone else would form. Yet when someone spoke harshly to me, I would say, “He made me angry,” as though my response were his to command.
Life taught me the reverse. Outcomes are seldom entirely mine. My choices, my attitude, my words and my response to difficulty always are. I had been guarding territory I did not own and neglecting the one place where I truly governed.
Psychologists have a name for the first half of this mistake. The psychologist Ellen Langer named it the illusion of control: the tendency to expect more influence over events than the facts allow.1 It is a flattering illusion. If everything depends on me, then every good outcome is my achievement and every bad one my failure. Both conclusions are usually wrong.
2. Worry is not the same as responsibility
I assumed that a person who cared would worry, and that a person who stopped worrying had stopped caring. Worry felt like conscientiousness. In practice, it mostly rehearsed futures that never arrived.
Research bears this out. In a study published in Behavior Therapy in 2020, Lucas LaFreniere and Michelle Newman of Penn State asked twenty-nine people with generalised anxiety disorder to record their worries over ten days and then track what actually happened. About 91 per cent of the worries did not come true, and the most common result for an individual participant was that none of them did.2 The sample was small and clinical, so it should not be stretched too far, but its direction matches what most of us discover by middle age.
Epictetus understood this without a study. Born a slave at Hierapolis in Phrygia and lame for much of his life, he controlled almost nothing about his circumstances. Yet the handbook his student Arrian compiled from his teaching opens with one plain sentence: “Some things are in our control and others not.”3 If a man with so little control could build a philosophy on that distinction, I had little excuse for confusing the two.
Today, when a worry arrives, I ask one question before any other: is this mine to act on? If it is, I act. If it is not, I pray, and I set it down. I have described the small, practical ways I set worries down elsewhere; the point here is simpler. Worry is not a duty I owe to the people I love.
3. Letting go of control is not giving up
This is where the lesson is most easily misread, and where I misread it longest. Giving up abandons the effort. Letting go releases my claim on the result.
The Bhagavad Gita draws the line with precision. Krishna tells Arjuna that his right is to the work alone, never to its fruits, and in the same verse warns him against clinging to inaction.4 Acceptance, then, is not permission to stop trying. It is permission to stop pretending that the harvest is mine to decree.
Nor is acceptance a reason to tolerate what I can and should change: an unfair arrangement, a neglected duty, a habit that harms. Letting go applies to outcomes, not to responsibilities. So I still plan, still work hard and still hope, and I try to commit the work to God rather than carry it alone. I simply no longer measure my worth by results that were never wholly in my hands.
4. Faith does not wait for explanations
Some questions stay unanswered. Why do sincere prayers sometimes seem unheard? Why do careful plans collapse? I once thought faith meant having answers to such questions. I now see it as the willingness to trust God when answers are unavailable.
“Trust in the LORD with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding.”
Proverbs 3:5 (NIV)5
Notice what the verse does not say. It does not ask me to discard my understanding. It asks me not to lean on it, not to rest my whole weight on it as though it could bear everything. Elsewhere the same book admits that we cannot fully understand our own ways (Proverbs 20:24). Faith is what lets us keep walking anyway.
Faith, in this sense, is not passive resignation. It is doing my part sincerely, praying for guidance, and leaving the outcome in God’s hands. It also means making peace with the words “I don’t know”, which I now count as a mark of honesty rather than a failure of faith.
5. What I would tell my younger self
I once wrote that I would hand my younger self a compass rather than a map and say as little as possible. On this lesson I would make an exception and speak plainly:
Do your best, but do not assume that everything depends on you. Plan carefully, but remain flexible. Work sincerely, but do not measure your worth only by results. Care for people, but do not try to run their lives. And when circumstances move beyond your understanding, do not let uncertainty take away your faith.
The face that did not change
In the Kamba Ramayanam, the classical Tamil retelling of the Ramayana, the poet Kamban describes Sita, held captive in Lanka, remembering her husband’s face.6 When Rama was told he would be crowned, and when he was told to give up the kingdom and leave for the forest, his face looked the same: like a red lotus in a painting. A living lotus closes at dusk. A painted one stays open whatever the hour.
That is the composure I have come to admire. Not a life spared from reversal, but a spirit that reversal cannot fold shut. It does not come from controlling events. It comes from no longer staking one’s peace on them.
Too late, or just in time?
Did I learn this lesson too late? Late, certainly. But a lesson comes too late only if it changes nothing. Learned today, it still governs every day that remains.
Life is not always about finding answers. Sometimes it is about learning to live peacefully with unanswered questions. I cannot control every chapter of my life, nor understand every turn in its story. But I can live responsibly, respond with patience, treat others with kindness, and trust God with the pages I have not yet read.
A question for you, dear reader
Which lesson about control, acceptance or trust reached you later than you wish it had, and what changed once it arrived?
Share your thoughts in the comments. Your experience may offer someone else the wisdom they need today.
Frequently asked questions
What does it mean to let go without giving up?
Giving up abandons the effort; letting go releases your claim on the outcome. You keep doing your part fully, but you stop treating results that depend on other people, on timing or on chance as your personal responsibility.
What is the dichotomy of control?
It is the Stoic principle, set out at the start of Epictetus’s Handbook, that separates what is within our power (our judgements, intentions and actions) from what is not (other people, reputation, circumstances and outcomes). The Stoics held that peace comes from attending to the first and accepting the second.
Do most of our worries actually come true?
The evidence suggests not. In a small 2020 study of people with generalised anxiety disorder, about 91 per cent of recorded worries did not come true, and participants who saw more of their worries prove false improved more in treatment.
Does faith require having all the answers?
No. Proverbs 3:5 asks the believer to trust God rather than lean on their own understanding. Faith in this sense is not certainty; it is trust that continues when explanations are unavailable, alongside sincere effort and prayer.
Notes and references
Ellen J. Langer, “The Illusion of Control,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 32, no. 2 (1975): 311–328, https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.32.2.311. The general tendency to overestimate one’s influence over events is cited here. One well-known demonstration, that simply choosing a lottery ticket raises confidence of winning, was not supported by seventeen later experiments: Joowon Klusowski, Deborah A. Small and Joseph P. Simmons, “Does Choice Cause an Illusion of Control?” Psychological Science 32, no. 2 (2021): 159–172, https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797620958009. That experiment is therefore not relied on.
Lucas S. LaFreniere and Michelle G. Newman, “Exposing Worry’s Deceit: Percentage of Untrue Worries in Generalized Anxiety Disorder Treatment,” Behavior Therapy 51, no. 3 (2020): 413–423, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2019.07.003. Participants recorded worries for ten days and tracked their outcomes over thirty days.
Epictetus, Enchiridion 1, trans. Elizabeth Carter (1758), MIT Internet Classics Archive. Epictetus (c. 50–c. 135 CE) was born a slave at Hierapolis in Phrygia, in present-day Türkiye. He wrote nothing himself; his teaching was recorded by his student Arrian in the Discourses and the Enchiridion (Handbook), both of which open with the distinction between what is and is not in our power.
Bhagavad Gita 2.47, paraphrased. The Gita is a 700-verse dialogue between Krishna and the warrior prince Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukshetra, and forms part of the Mahabharata. Sanskrit text and translation: shlokam.org.
Kamban, Kamba Ramayanam (Iramavataram), Sundara Kandam, Kaatchi Padalam. Kamban, usually dated to the twelfth century, wrote the best-known Tamil version of the Ramayana. In this verse Sita, in the Ashoka grove, recalls that Rama’s face was like a red lotus in a painting both when he was told to take the throne and when he was told to renounce it: ‘மெய்த் திருப்பதம் மேவு’ என்ற போதினும், ‘இத் திருத் துறந்து ஏகு’ என்ற போதினும், சித்திரத்தின் அலர்ந்த செந்தாமரை ஒத்திருக்கும் முகத்தினை உன்னுவாள். Verse numbers differ between editions; the English rendering here is a paraphrase. Tamil text as reproduced by the Tamil Virtual Academy.
When I was younger, I thought friendship was about spending time together, sharing experiences, enjoying conversations and having people around me. A good friend was someone who made life more enjoyable, joined me in celebrations and shared my interests.
That view was not wrong. Shared time is how most friendships begin. But it was incomplete, because it measured friendship by what we enjoyed together. The passing years have taught me to measure it by something harder: what it can survive.
We are usually told that adversity is the real test. A friend in need is a friend indeed. The Roman poet Ennius said as much more than two thousand years ago, in a line preserved by Cicero: a sure friend is discerned in an unsure time.1 I do not doubt it. But growing older has shown me that hardship is not the only test of friendship, and perhaps not even the hardest.
1. Success is a harder test than sorrow.
Most decent people will stand by a friend in trouble, because sorrow invites sympathy. Success invites comparison instead. Many of us have received congratulations that arrived a day late and a word short. Oscar Wilde observed that anybody can sympathise with a friend’s sufferings, but it takes a very fine nature to sympathise with a friend’s success.2
The test runs both ways. One of India’s best-loved stories of friendship concerns the friend who prospered. When Kuchela, poor and threadbare, arrives at the palace of his boyhood friend Krishna carrying only a small bundle of flattened rice, the king rises to embrace him and relishes the humble gift as though it were a feast.3
Once, I assumed that a friendship that went quiet was dying. Now I know that people carry families, responsibilities and private struggles of their own. Some friendships fall silent for months, and then a call comes that picks up as though the last one ended yesterday. A sincere conversation after a long silence can mean more than countless casual exchanges.
The Lebanese-American poet Kahlil Gibran wrote that what we love most in a friend may be clearer in absence, as a mountain is clearer to the climber from the plain.4 I have learned not to judge friendship by how often someone calls, but by the sincerity behind the call.
3. Honest disagreement is a form of loyalty.
A friend who agrees with everything I say is pleasant company and little help. Often the most valuable words a friend can offer are the three nobody else will risk: “Are you sure?” I now value someone who tells me the truth, even when it is uncomfortable, and who can differ from me without letting the difference damage the relationship.
It may be objected that these standards are too high. Perhaps they are, and I have made peace with that. Not everyone who walks beside us is meant to remain. Some friendships belong to a particular season, and their ending need not be a betrayal. At this stage of life, I no longer feel the need to impress people or keep friendships for social recognition. I would rather have a few relationships in which I can be myself, speak honestly and be met with respect.
5. Every test is one I must also pass.
This is the part I missed for years. Do I rejoice when a friend overtakes me? Do I let a friendship rest in silence without keeping score of who called last? Can I hear disagreement without becoming distant?
Friendship is not simply about what we receive; it is equally about what we contribute. Perhaps the real change in my understanding is this: I began by asking what makes a good friend, and I have ended by asking whether I am one. Becoming a better friend, I believe, is an important part of becoming a better human being.
When I was younger, I looked for friends who made my life enjoyable. As I grew older, I began to value friends who made my life meaningful.
A Thought to Reflect On
A true friend does not feel smaller when you rise, does not disappear when you struggle and does not demand that you become someone else to earn their acceptance.
Growing older does not make us need friendship less; it teaches us to recognise genuine friendship more clearly.
Which of these tests has your closest friendship passed, and which have you had to pass for someone else?
Strive to elevate in life.
Notes for Readers
1. Cicero, On Friendship (De Amicitia), section 64, quoting the Roman poet Quintus Ennius (239–169 BCE): Amicus certus in re incerta cernitur. In the same passage Cicero asks where one might find a person who places a friend’s advancement above his own.
2. Oscar Wilde, The Soul of Man under Socialism (1891).
3. The story is told in the tenth book of the Bhagavata Purana (chapters 80 and 81), a Sanskrit devotional text, where the friend is simply a poor, poorly dressed Brahmin. Later tradition names him Sudama in North India; in the South he is known as Kuchela, from the Sanskrit for “the poorly clad”.
4. Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), “On Friendship”.
5. Ralph Waldo Emerson, “Friendship”, Essays: First Series (1841).
John Britto Kurusumuthu
Rise & Inspire · riseandinspire.co.in
In response to the WordPress Daily Writing Prompt, 9 November 2026: Has your idea of what makes a good friend changed as you’ve gotten older?
Ask people what they cannot live without, and the answers come quickly: food, water, shelter, the people they love. My answer is not on that list. Strictly speaking, I could survive without it. Many people do.
It is the desire to keep learning. More precisely, it is the question I have not yet answered.
That may seem a strange thing to depend on: something I do not yet possess. Yet I have come to believe that a mind is kept alive less by what it knows than by what it still wants to know.
When I was a postgraduate student of economics, the book I loved most was Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations. Smith is usually remembered as the champion of self-interest. Yet seventeen years earlier he had published The Theory of Moral Sentiments, which opens by observing that however selfish a person may be, something in human nature makes us care about the fortunes of others. Read side by side, the two books say more than either says alone. A book I have loved for decades still had something to teach me, because I had not stopped asking it questions.
2. Experience is not the same as wisdom
I believe the greatest danger is not growing old but becoming intellectually stagnant. Age may bring experience, but experience alone does not guarantee wisdom. Left unexamined, it hardens into certainty.
Tamil grammarians conceded this about language itself. The Nannool [1], composed around the turn of the thirteenth century by the Jain scholar Pavanandi, accepts that old usages fall away and new ones come in. It declares this no fault: it is simply the way of time. If a grammar can concede that much, so can a mind. Letting an old certainty give way to a better understanding is not a betrayal of experience. It is what experience is for.
3. Every tradition begins with wanting
Many traditions begin not with knowledge but with the desire for it. The Brahma Sutra, a foundational text of Vedanta, opens with a single line: athato brahma jijnasa, “now, therefore, the desire to know Brahman” [2]. The word jijnasa does not mean knowledge. It means the wish to know. In the Qur’an, the Prophet is taught a prayer that asks not for completion but for more: “My Lord, increase me in knowledge” (Surah Ta-Ha 20:114).
Neither text treats the unanswered question as a failure. One places the wanting at the very beginning; the other turns it into a prayer. The more we discover, the more clearly we see how much remains unknown, and that is exactly what keeps the search fresh.
4. Must every question stay open?
Here I must argue against myself. A life made only of open questions would be a life without an anchor. Some things I hold firmly: my faith, my values, the people I love. I do not reopen them each morning, and I would be wary of anyone who did. Curiosity that refuses every conviction is not openness. It is drift.
The difference lies in the kind of question we keep. Anselm of Canterbury, the eleventh-century theologian, described his work as faith seeking understanding [3]. The question I cannot live without is rarely whether to keep what I hold. It is how to understand it more deeply. Conviction gives a question its roots; the question keeps the conviction alive.
5. The appetite has to be fed
Curiosity does not survive on good intentions alone. A few habits help at any age. Keep a list of questions, not only answers, and let some of them stay open for a while before asking a search engine or an AI to close them. Return to a book you think you know and ask it something new. Learn something from a person much younger than you, in a field they understand better. And once a year, take an opinion you have held for a long time, about people, work or the world, and ask honestly what would change your mind.
Age will take its share of things in time. I would rather it never took my questions.
I want to keep reading, writing, observing and questioning, and to learn from people, from nature, from technology and from the wisdom handed down through generations. I want each new day to show me something I did not understand yesterday. I may not discover everything, answer every question or master every subject. But I hope never to lose the enthusiasm to explore what I do not yet know.
So the one thing I cannot live without is, in the end, something I do not yet possess: the next question. I hope I never run out of them.
A question for you
What is the one thing you cannot imagine living without? Is it something you already have, or something you are still reaching for? Share your answer in the comments. It may help another reader see their own life a little differently.
Notes
[1] The Nannool (“the good book”) is a Tamil grammar composed between about 1178 and 1216 by Pavanandi Munivar, a Jain scholar. It is regarded as the most important Tamil grammar after the Tolkappiyam. The line paraphrased here, “Pazhaiyana kazhithalum puthiyana puguthalum vazhuvala kaala vagaiyinaane”, comes from its section on words (Sollathikaram). It is still quoted in Tamil Nadu at Bhogi, the festival on which old things are cleared away to make room for the new.
[2] The Brahma Sutra, traditionally attributed to Badarayana, is a foundational text of the Vedanta schools of Indian philosophy. Jijnasa is a Sanskrit desiderative form meaning, literally, “the desire to know”.
[3] Anselm of Canterbury (1033–1109) gave his Proslogion the original title Fides quaerens intellectum, “faith seeking understanding”.
John Britto Kurusumuthu
Rise & Inspire · riseandinspire.co.in
In response to the WordPress Daily Writing Prompt, 8 November 2026: What is one thing you can’t live without?
Near Jerusalem, an inscription once set above an ancient tomb made one blunt promise to anyone who might break in: there is nothing of value inside. This week’s seven Scriptures take that old warning and turn it gently towards us, asking what we have quietly been calling ours and what was only ever placed in our keeping. They travel through a forbidden boast, a key laid on a servant’s shoulder and a prisoner who stood with nothing, and they arrive at an answer few of us would think to look for.
RISE & INSPIRE | SUNDAY BIBLE SERIESCategory: Wake-up CallsSunday Series No. 13 — 8 November 2026 · Thirty-Second Sunday in Ordinary TimeScriptures of the week: 2 – 8 November 2026
What Can You Truly Call Your Own?
A royal steward’s empty tomb, a key held in trust, a prisoner who owned nothing, and a song that outlasts every inventory
An Inventory Cut in Stone
In 1870 a young French scholar named Charles Clermont-Ganneau was studying the ancient tombs of Silwan, the village that spills down the eastern slope of the Kidron Valley, facing the old city of Jerusalem. Many of those tombs had long since been absorbed into village life — turned into cisterns, storerooms, the back walls of houses. Above the doorway of one of them, cut into the limestone, he found a line of old Hebrew letters, and beside it a shorter inscription. He could not read them. Afraid they would be lost, he had both panels cut out of the rock. Within a year they were in the British Museum in London, where they remain. The tomb still bears the two rectangular scars where they were removed.
For more than eighty years nobody could read them. Then, in 1953, the Israeli scholar Nahman Avigad, working from photographs and a cast sent from London, deciphered the longer text. Rendered into English, it says something very close to this:
This is [the tomb of …]yahu, who is over the house. There is no silver and no gold here — only [his bones] and the bones of his ʾamah with him. Cursed be whoever opens this.
The word ʾamah usually means a female servant, and can also describe a wife of lower, dependent status; some scholars have wondered whether it might be a title for a woman of rank. The inscription does not say which.
The name has broken away exactly where we most want it. But the title survived. “Who is over the house” — in Hebrew ʾasher ʿal-habbayit — was the title of the royal steward, the highest official of the king’s household and one of the most powerful men in the kingdom of Judah. The shape of the letters resembles the famous inscription found nearby in King Hezekiah’s water tunnel, and points to a date around 700 BC.
Anyone who knows the Book of Isaiah feels a small shiver at this point. Isaiah 22 contains a fierce oracle against a royal steward of that very period — “Shebna, who is master of the household,” bearing that very title — and the charge against him is precisely that he has cut a tomb for himself in the rock. Could this be his? Clermont-Ganneau suspected so. Avigad thought the idea worth weighing but called it conjectural, and honest readers must leave it there. Names ending in -yahu could be shortened, so a Shebanyahu could become a Shebna; but the Bible never spells his name the longer way. We do not know whose bones lay behind that door.
Nor should we read the inscription as a confession of humility. On the sarcophagus of Tabnit, a king of Sidon, a similar assurance appears: there is no silver or gold inside. It was a practical warning to tomb robbers. Don’t bother. There is nothing here worth stealing.
And yet the stone tells a truer story than its author meant to tell. Whatever that steward possessed in life — the keys of a king’s house, the seal of office, the chariots, the robe and sash, the authority to open and to shut — none of it went into the rock with him. The inventory of what remained fits into one line: bones. Every grave in the world could carry the same sentence.
This week’s verses began at the graves. The first of them reached us on Monday, 2 November — All Souls’ Day, when Catholic families from Thiruvananthapuram to Toronto stood among the tombs of people they love, lighting candles over names cut in stone. The last of them arrives this morning. In between, Scripture kept circling one question, and it is the question Isaiah put to the proud steward in a phrase that translations render in different ways:
The NRSV renders it idiomatically: “What right do you have here? Who are your relatives here?” The King James Version stays closer to the Hebrew: “What hast thou here? and whom hast thou here?” Biblical Hebrew has no verb to have; it expresses possession by saying that something is to someone. So beneath the prophet’s indignant question lies, quite naturally, a question about what a person has and holds.
Read in that light — and this is the reading of this study, not a translation — it becomes a question a lawyer would recognise: a question of title. Not what do you hold? but what do you own? Not what is in your hands? but what is truly yours?
So this is the question the week sets before us:
What can you truly call your own?
How This Study Is Built
This Sunday we will not walk through the seven verses in the order they arrived. We will follow the question the tomb at Silwan raises, in three movements.
The Claim listens to the voices that say mine: the self-made man of Deuteronomy, the gods bought with gold in Babylon, and the steward who carved his own name into the rock.
The Trust turns to what is placed in our keeping: a key laid on a servant’s shoulder, a little that is better than much, and a wealthy widow who named God by the people with nothing.
The Song stands before a prisoner who owned nothing and claimed everything, and ends with a psalm that has outlived every empire that ever drew up an inventory.
Along the way, each verse will add one line to a new inventory — a very different list from the one carved over the door at Silwan.
Scripture is quoted from the New Revised Standard Version, the translation in which this week’s verses were given, unless otherwise stated.
Movement One · The Claim
1. The Sentence Moses Forbade
Wednesday, 4 November · Deuteronomy 8:17
“Do not say to yourself, ‘My power and the might of my own hand have gotten me this wealth.'”
Last Sunday we stood in this same chapter, twelve verses earlier, where Moses looked back over forty years in the wilderness and called them a father’s schooling: hunger and manna, a long road and sandals that never wore out (8:2–5). Now he turns round and looks forward, across the Jordan, into the land Israel is about to enter.
What he sees there is not danger but abundance. “A land of wheat and barley, of vines and fig trees and pomegranates, a land of olive trees and honey” (8:8). A land where they will eat bread “without scarcity” and mine copper from the hills (8:9). And then he sketches, in a single breathless sentence, the shape of a prosperous life: “When you have eaten your fill and have built fine houses and live in them, and when your herds and flocks have multiplied, and your silver and gold is multiplied, and all that you have is multiplied …” (8:12–13). Listen to the verb. In Hebrew, multiply comes round three times in a single verse, like a ledger whose columns keep lengthening.
Then the warning: “do not exalt yourself, forgetting the LORD your God” (8:14). And then our verse.
The whole chapter turns on two verbs. Remember (8:2, 18). Do not forget (8:11, 14, 19). The wilderness was dangerous because Israel might die. The land would be dangerous because Israel might forget.
A sentence spoken in the heart
The NRSV’s “Do not say to yourself” translates a Hebrew phrase that means, literally, “and you say in your heart” (וְאָמַרְתָּ בִּלְבָבֶךָ, wəʾāmartā bilvāvekhā). The sin Moses names is not a public boast. It is a sentence spoken where no one else can hear it — in the private room where each of us narrates our own life to ourselves.
Deuteronomy uses the device more than once, and the twin of our verse comes in the very next chapter:
“When the LORD your God thrusts them out before you, do not say to yourself, ‘It is because of my righteousness that the LORD has brought me in to occupy this land.'” (9:4)
Read the two together and you have the two great self-made sentences of the human heart. My strength earned me this wealth.My goodness earned me this blessing. One is economic, the other spiritual. Moses forbids both, and for the same reason: neither is true.
The words in the sentence
Every word of the forbidden sentence repays a moment’s attention.
כֹּחִי וְעֹצֶם יָדִי עָשָׂה לִי אֶת־הַחַיִל הַזֶּהkōḥî wəʿōṣem yādî ʿāśāh lî ʾet-haḥayil hazzeh “My strength and the might of my hand has made for me this wealth.”
כֹּחַ (kōaḥ) means strength, power, ability — the capacity to do things. עֹצֶם יָד (ʿōṣem yād), the might of the hand, is a rare and emphatic phrase: muscle, grip, the force a person can exert. עָשָׂה לִי (ʿāśāh lî) means has made for me. And the object, חַיִל (ḥayil), is a word with a remarkable range. It can mean strength or ability; wealth; an army; valour. The gibbôr ḥayil is a mighty warrior. The ʾēšet ḥayil is the capable woman of Proverbs 31 and the worthy woman Boaz recognises in Ruth (Ruth 3:11). Ḥayil is wealth understood as strength — what you have because of what you can do.
Now read the very next verse:
“But remember the LORD your God, for it is he who gives you power to get wealth.” (8:18)
The same two words come back — kōaḥ and ḥayil — but now they stand in their proper order. The power was given. The wealth was made with a gift.
Notice what Moses does not say. He does not say the Israelites will do no work. The phrase “to get wealth” — literally “to make ḥayil” — honours real effort: ploughing, herding, trading, building. He does not say wealth is evil; the land is good, and the chapter says so again and again. He does not even ask the people to feel guilty for eating well. On the contrary:
“You shall eat your fill and bless the LORD your God for the good land that he has given you.” (8:10)
That verse became the scriptural foundation of the Jewish grace after meals, the Birkat ha-Mazon. It is the antidote to verse 17. The cure for “my hand has made me this” is not refusing the meal. It is blessing the Giver at the table.
What Moses denies is not effort. It is title. You may work; you may not claim to be the author of your own capacity to work.
The word to remember for Thursday
When Jewish scholars in Alexandria translated the Law of Moses into Greek, in the third century before Christ, they rendered the forbidden sentence like this:
ἡ ἰσχύς μου καὶ τὸ κράτος τῆς χειρός μου ἐποίησέν μοι τὴν δύναμιν τὴν μεγάλην ταύτην “My strength (ischys) and the might (kratos) of my hand made for me this great power (dynamis).”
The Greek translators chose δύναμις (dynamis) for ḥayil — power. In Greek, the self-made man does not merely say I made this money. He says I made this great power for myself. And in verse 18, God “gives you strength to make power.”
Keep that word in mind. On Thursday it will reappear in a courtroom at night, on the lips of a prisoner, as a name for God.
The idolatry nobody notices
The Catechism, explaining the first commandment, insists that idolatry is not only a matter of ancient statues. It “remains a constant temptation to faith,” and among the creatures a person may revere in God’s place it lists, without embarrassment, money (CCC 2113). Deuteronomy 8:17 shows how quietly that happens. Nobody bows down to a bank balance. They simply say, in the heart, I did this — and from then on, the thing they did becomes the thing they trust.
On Wednesday, the day this verse arrived, the Church remembered a man who had every reason to say Moses’ forbidden sentence. Charles Borromeo was born into one of the great noble families of Lombardy and made a cardinal while still in his early twenties. When plague struck Milan in 1576, he spent his fortune on the sick and the hungry, and went into debt to feed them. He had wealth. He did not mistake it for his own making.
For the new inventory:Wealth — made with a strength that was given. Mine to use; not mine to boast of.
2. Gods Bought with Gold
Tuesday, 3 November · Isaiah 46:13
“I bring near my deliverance; it is not far off, and my salvation will not tarry.”
Deuteronomy warned about a man who makes himself. Isaiah 46 mocks people who make their god. In both cases the raw material is the same: their own wealth.
The chapter belongs to the second great movement of the Book of Isaiah (chapters 40–55), addressed to Judeans in exile in Babylon in the sixth century before Christ, as the Persian king Cyrus rose in the east (44:28; 45:1). It opens with a picture of Babylon’s great gods on the move:
“Bel bows down, Nebo stoops, their idols are on beasts and cattle; these things you carry are loaded as burdens on weary animals. They stoop, they bow down together; they cannot save the burden, but themselves go into captivity.” (46:1–2)
Bel — Lord — was the title of Marduk, the patron god of Babylon. Nebo, or Nabu, was his son, the god of scribes and writing, patron of the nearby city of Borsippa. Each spring, at the great New Year festival, their statues were carried in solemn procession. Isaiah sees them carried differently: loaded on exhausted animals, lurching out of the city, going into exile with the people who made them. The image was not far-fetched. When Cyrus took Babylon in 539 BC, his own propaganda boasted of sending back to their shrines the divine statues that the previous king had gathered into the capital. In that world, gods could be freight.
Some weeks ago, in this series, we looked at the contrast that follows — a god you have to carry, or a God who carries you (46:3–4). This week, look instead at what Isaiah says the gods are made of:
“Those who lavish gold from the purse, and weigh out silver in the scales — they hire a goldsmith, who makes it into a god; then they fall down and worship! They lift it to their shoulders, they carry it, they set it in its place, and it stands there; it cannot move from its place. If one cries out to it, it does not answer or save anyone from trouble.” (46:6–7)
The god is purchased. It is, quite literally, the worshipper’s money in another shape. And notice the verbs of the last sentence. It stands there. It cannot move from its place. It does not answer. It does not save.
Now hear how the chapter ends:
“Listen to me, you stubborn of heart, you who are far from deliverance: I bring near my deliverance, it is not far off, and my salvation will not tarry; I will put salvation in Zion, for Israel my glory.” (46:12–13)
Everything the purchased god cannot do, the living God does. The idol cannot move; God’s salvation comes near. The idol stands where it is put; God’s deliverance will not tarry. You must go to the idol. The true God comes to you.
Two words worth weighing
The NRSV’s “deliverance” translates צְדָקָה (ṣədāqāh), the word usually rendered righteousness — as the King James Version has it: “I bring near my righteousness.” Both translations are defensible, and the difference matters. In these chapters of Isaiah, God’s righteousness is not first of all a standard by which people are measured and found wanting. It is God’s faithfulness to his promises in action — and so, very often, it means rescue. That is why it stands here in parallel with תְּשׁוּעָה (təšûʿāh), salvation, a word from the root y-š-ʿ, the same root that gives the name Yeshua, Jesus: “you are to name him Jesus, for he will save his people from their sins” (Matthew 1:21).
Now look at whom this is addressed to. אַבִּירֵי לֵב (ʾabbîrê lēv), “stubborn of heart,” is literally “mighty of heart” or “stout-hearted.” The word ʾabbîr is used of the strong — warriors, bulls, chieftains. These are people who are strong in themselves. And they are, the verse says, “far from deliverance.”
To them — not to the deserving, not to those already near — God says: I am bringing it near.
This is easy to miss and difficult to overstate. The salvation the idol could never provide is not offered as a prize to those who finally stop being stubborn. It is brought, on its own feet, towards those who are still far away. Deuteronomy’s self-made man and Babylon’s god-makers are not simply left with their claim. They are met by a gift.
For the new inventory:Salvation — never purchased, never carried home. Brought near, as a gift, to the far-off.
3. “What Have You Here?”
The steward who carved his own name — Isaiah 22:15–19
Saturday’s verse, as we shall see, is about a good steward. But it cannot be understood without the bad one who comes first, and he belongs to this movement.
Isaiah 22 opens with an oracle concerning “the valley of vision,” a picture of Jerusalem in a crisis — very probably a time of siege. The city’s leaders do everything a competent administration should do. They inspect the weapons in the royal armoury. They survey the breaches in the walls. They count the houses and pull some down to strengthen the fortifications. They build a new reservoir for the water supply (22:8–11). And then comes the sentence that judges the whole programme:
“But you did not look to him who did it, or have regard for him who planned it long ago.” (22:11)
It is Deuteronomy 8:17 on the scale of a city. The leaders’ competence is real. Their mistake is to trust it.
Immediately afterwards comes the oracle against one leader in particular:
“Thus says the Lord GOD of hosts: Come, go to this steward, to Shebna, who is master of the household, and say to him: What right do you have here? Who are your relatives here, that you have cut out a tomb here for yourself, cutting a tomb on the height, and carving a habitation for yourself in the rock?” (22:15–16)
Shebna was the king’s steward, and in a moment of national danger he was making arrangements for his own monument. Isaiah’s charge goes on: the LORD will hurl him away like a ball into a wide land, where “your splendid chariots shall lie, O you disgrace to your master’s house!” (22:18). Notice the phrase your master’s house. Shebna’s office existed for a house that was not his. He behaved as though it were.
The question God asks him — “What have you here, and whom have you here?” — is not only rhetorical. It is a question about belonging. Shebna had no ancestral claim to that hillside; no family of his lay in that rock. He was carving a permanent title out of a temporary office.
There is a quiet historical footnote. When the Assyrian army stood outside Jerusalem in 701 BC, the officials who went out to negotiate were “Eliakim son of Hilkiah, who was in charge of the palace, and Shebna the secretary” (Isaiah 36:3; compare 2 Kings 18:18). If the Shebna of chapter 36 is the same man — and most readers assume he is — then the oracle had already begun to take effect. The steward had become a secretary. Someone else now held the keys.
For the new inventory:Office — a robe that can be put on someone else. Never a monument to oneself.
Movement Two · The Trust
4. A Key on a Servant’s Shoulder
Saturday, 7 November · Isaiah 22:22
“I will place on his shoulder the key of the house of David; he shall open, and no one shall shut; he shall shut, and no one shall open.”
Here is the oracle’s second half, and the contrast could hardly be sharper:
“On that day I will call my servant Eliakim son of Hilkiah, and will clothe him with your robe and bind your sash on him. I will commit your authority to his hand, and he shall be a father to the inhabitants of Jerusalem and to the house of Judah. I will place on his shoulder the key of the house of David …” (22:20–22)
Shebna had carved for himself. Eliakim is called עַבְדִּי (ʿavdî), “my servant.” Shebna’s robe and sash — the visible signs of office — are taken off him and put on another man. The office does not change. The holder does. That alone tells us what kind of thing authority is in Scripture: a garment, not a skin.
And the purpose of the office is named: “he shall be a father to the inhabitants of Jerusalem.” The steward’s authority exists for the people of the house — for their protection and provision, as a father’s authority exists for his children.
The key and the shoulder
מַפְתֵּחַ (maftēaḥ), key, comes from the verb פָּתַח (pātaḥ), to open. A key is, by its very name, an opener. Its whole identity lies in what it does for a door and for the people who need to pass through it.
The key is laid עַל־שִׁכְמוֹ (ʿal-šikhmô), “on his shoulder.” Ancient keys could be large — wooden or bronze bars that worked the bolts inside a door — and some commentators picture one literally slung over the shoulder; others take the image as a symbol of office. We cannot be certain. But the same Hebrew phrase appears in one of the best-known prophecies of the same book:
“For a child has been born for us, a son given to us; authority rests upon his shoulders.” (Isaiah 9:6)
Upon his shoulder — ʿal-šikhmô in both places. In Isaiah, authority is carried on the shoulder, the way a load is carried. It is a burden borne for others, not a jewel worn for oneself.
Then the decisive power: “he shall open, and no one shall shut; he shall shut, and no one shall open.” The steward’s decisions are real and binding within the house. But notice the first words of the verse: “I will place.” The authority is delegated. Eliakim does not seize the key. He is given it.
When the peg gives way
Isaiah does not end with a tidy happy ending, and neither should we. The oracle continues:
“I will fasten him like a peg in a secure place, and he will become a throne of honor to his ancestral house. And they will hang on him the whole weight of his ancestral house, the offspring and issue, every small vessel, from the cups to all the flagons. On that day, says the LORD of hosts, the peg that was fastened in a secure place will give way; it will be cut down and fall, and the load that was on it will perish.” (22:23–25)
Commentators have long debated these verses. Many think they come from a later moment, reflecting what eventually happened to Eliakim’s position; others read them as a warning built into the original oracle. Either way, the picture is unforgettable. The good steward’s relatives hang their whole family’s fortunes on him — every small vessel, from the cups to all the flagons — until the peg pulls out of the wall.
Shebna treated his office as private property. Eliakim’s family treated it as family property. Both ended the same way. The key of the house of David was for the house of David — not for the man who carried it, and not for his cousins.
Anyone who has served in public office, sat on a governing board, led a parish committee or managed a family business knows exactly what this looks like. It rarely begins with corruption. It begins with a cup — one small favour hung on the peg — and then the flagons follow.
The keys of the kingdom
Christians have never read Isaiah 22:22 as only a story about two officials in Hezekiah’s court. The Book of Revelation applies its words directly to the risen Christ: “the holy one, the true one, who has the key of David, who opens and no one will shut, who shuts and no one opens” (Revelation 3:7). And when Jesus says to Peter, “I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven” (Matthew 16:19), many interpreters, especially in the Catholic tradition, hear Isaiah’s steward in the background: a royal household, a king, and one servant entrusted with the keys. Matthew does not quote Isaiah directly, so the link is an inference rather than a citation — but it is an old and widely held one. The Catechism describes the power of the keys as “authority to govern the house of God, which is the Church” (CCC 553).
Every word of that sentence is a steward’s word. Authority — given. Govern — serve. The house of God — not Peter’s house. Since the time of Pope Gregory the Great, at the end of the sixth century, the Bishop of Rome has called himself servus servorum Dei, servant of the servants of God. The Church will celebrate the feast of the Dedication of the Lateran Basilica, the Pope’s own cathedral, on Monday, 9 November — a fitting occasion to remember that even the keys of Peter are held in trust.
And in a few weeks, as Advent draws towards Christmas, the Church will sing on 20 December the antiphon O Clavis David — O Key of David — praying to Christ as the One who opens what no one can shut. The key Eliakim carried for a palace, Christ carries for the world.
Title, possession and trust
Lawyers distinguish between possession and title. A tenant possesses a house; the owner holds title. A trustee may hold property, sometimes even in their own name, but holds it for the benefit of others. Roman law had a precise word for a related arrangement, inherited by many legal systems since: usufruct, the right to use and enjoy the fruits of something that belongs to someone else, provided its substance is not destroyed — a right that ended, in its classical form, with the death of the one who held it.
Scripture’s account of human ownership sounds very much like that. “The land shall not be sold in perpetuity,” God says in Leviticus, “for the land is mine; with me you are but aliens and tenants” (Leviticus 25:23). The Catechism puts it in a single sentence: “The ownership of any property makes its holder a steward of Providence” (CCC 2404). And Pope Francis, preaching on the seventh commandment, drew the conclusion in words worth memorising: “What I truly own is what I am able to give.” Whatever we cannot give, he went on to say, has begun to own us (General Audience, 7 November 2018).
Shebna had possession and mistook it for title. Eliakim was given possession and called to hold it as a father holds a house for his children.
For the new inventory:Authority — a key carried on the shoulder for the sake of the house. Kept only for yourself, a key stops being a key and becomes a trophy.
5. Better a Little
Monday, 2 November · All Souls’ Day · Psalm 37:16
“Better is a little that the righteous person has than the abundance of many wicked.”
The week’s first verse came to us on the day of the graves, and it comes from the mouth of an old man. “I have been young, and now am old,” the psalmist says, “yet I have not seen the righteous forsaken or their children begging bread” (37:25). Psalm 37 is not the cry of someone in the middle of a crisis. It is the counsel of someone who has watched a great many lives from beginning to end.
It is a wisdom psalm, closer in spirit to Proverbs than to the hymns and laments around it, and it is an acrostic: its stanzas begin with the successive letters of the Hebrew alphabet, roughly one letter for every two verses. Our verse opens the stanza of the letter ṭet, and the word that opens it is טוֹב (ṭôv), “better” — in its broadest sense, simply good.
The psalm has one pastoral problem in view, and it is a very modern one: the prosperity of people who do wrong. Three times it says, “Do not fret” (37:1, 7, 8). The Hebrew verb, תִּתְחַר (titḥar), comes from a root meaning to burn; it describes heating yourself up, letting the comparison smoulder. Anyone who has watched a dishonest colleague promoted, a ruthless competitor thrive, or a careless neighbour’s fortunes multiply knows the feeling exactly.
The psalm’s answer is not that the wicked are secretly miserable. It is a comparison between two kinds of abundance.
A little, and a roar
The word translated “abundance” is הָמוֹן (hāmôn), and its range is revealing. It can mean wealth or plenty. But at its root it is a word of noise: the roar of the sea, the tumult of a crowd, the din of a marching army. Set against it is מְעַט (məʿaṭ), a little.
So the line can be heard as a contrast between a little and a roar. The wealth of the wicked is loud. The Book of Proverbs makes the same comparison in its own better-sayings: “Better is a little with the fear of the LORD than great treasure and trouble with it” (Proverbs 15:16), where trouble is a word for turmoil and confusion; and Ecclesiastes adds, “Better is a handful with quiet than two handfuls with toil, and a chasing after wind” (Ecclesiastes 4:6).
And notice what the meek receive in the same psalm: “the meek shall inherit the land, and delight themselves in abundant prosperity” (37:11). The Hebrew for “abundant prosperity” is rōv šālôm — literally abundance of peace. The psalm does not say the righteous will have nothing in abundance. It says they will have an abundance of a different kind. The wicked have plenty of noise. The meek have plenty of peace.
What the psalm does not say
It would be easy to read this verse as a praise of poverty, or as a promise that the righteous will always be poor and the wicked always rich. It says neither.
It does not praise having little. It praises the little that belongs to the righteous — and the psalm tells us what kind of little that is: “the righteous are generous and keep giving” (37:21); “They are ever giving liberally and lending, and their children become a blessing” (37:26). The little in Psalm 37:16 is a little that keeps leaving the hand. It is enough, held open.
Nor does the psalm deny that the righteous may hold land. On the contrary, five times it promises that they will inherit it (37:9, 11, 22, 29, 34). The verb is יָרַשׁ (yāraš), and it matters. In Israel’s theology, nobody earned the land. It was received as an inheritance from God, who remained its owner. The only secure title in this psalm is title by gift. Jesus would take up its eleventh verse in the Sermon on the Mount: “Blessed are the meek, for they will inherit the earth” (Matthew 5:5).
On All Souls’ Day the Church prays for those who have gone ahead of us, every one of whom left the land behind. The psalm of the old man reminds us that inheritance was always the right word. We received; we pass on.
For the new inventory:Enough — a little, held open, is better than much held tight.
6. The God of the Underdogs
Friday, 6 November · Judith 9:11
“For your strength does not depend on numbers, nor your might on the powerful. But you are the God of the lowly, helper of the oppressed, upholder of the weak, protector of the forsaken, savior of those without hope.”
The verse given to us on Friday was the second half of this sentence. The first half belongs with it, and it turns out to hold a key to the whole week.
A widow’s prayer before a battle
The Book of Judith belongs to the deuterocanonical books of the Old Testament, received by the Catholic and Orthodox Churches and placed among the Apocrypha in Protestant Bibles. Its earliest surviving text is in Greek; its author and date are unknown, though many scholars place it in the second century before Christ. It opens with what seems a deliberate historical scramble — “Nebuchadnezzar, who ruled over the Assyrians in the great city of Nineveh” (1:1), when the historical Nebuchadnezzar was king of Babylon and Nineveh had already fallen. Many interpreters take this as the author’s signal: this is a story told to teach, a theological drama rather than a chronicle. Its question is the one that has run through our whole week. Where does real power lie?
The Assyrian general Holofernes has besieged the Israelite town of Bethulia and cut off its water. The people are dying of thirst, and the town’s leaders promise to surrender if God has not rescued them within five days (7:30–31). Then Judith appears: a widow, devout, and — the book is explicit — very wealthy. Her husband Manasseh had left her “gold and silver, men and women slaves, livestock, and fields; and she maintained this estate” (8:7).
She rebukes the leaders for presuming to set God a deadline (8:11–17). And then she prays. She puts on sackcloth and ashes, and she times her prayer to the hour when the evening incense is being offered in the Temple in Jerusalem, far away (9:1) — joining her lone voice in a besieged hill town to the worship of the whole people.
The vocabulary of power, set right
Now read the first half of verse 11 in Greek:
οὐ γὰρ ἐν πλήθει τὸ κράτος σου, οὐδὲ ἡ δυναστεία σου ἐν ἰσχύουσιν “For your might (kratos) is not in numbers, nor your sovereignty (dynasteia) in the strong (ischyontes).”
These are the words of Deuteronomy 8:17. The Greek Deuteronomy had the self-made man say: my strength (ischys) and the might (kratos) of my hand made me this power (dynamis). Judith takes the same vocabulary and turns it the right way up. Kratos does not belong to the strong. It belongs to God, who does not need them. Three verses later she names him “the God of all power (dynamis) and might (kratos)” (9:14).
And notice what she asks for. Two verses earlier she has prayed, in the Greek, “give into my hand — a widow’s hand — the might (kratos) that I have planned” (9:9). Deuteronomy’s man claimed the might of his hand as his own. Judith, with an entire estate behind her, asks for it as a gift.
Five names for God
Then come the five titles of our verse. Each is worth hearing in the original:
θεὸς ταπεινῶν (theos tapeinōn), God of the lowly — people of low station, without standing, helpless before the powerful.
ἐλαττόνων βοηθός (elattonōn boēthos), helper of the “oppressed” — but the Greek literally means the lesser ones, the smaller, those ranked beneath others. One commentator on the Greek suggests the underdogs. They are the ones who always come off worse.
ἀντιλήμπτωρ ἀσθενούντων (antilēmptōr asthenountōn), upholder of the weak. The noun comes from a verb meaning to take hold of, to lay hold in order to support. God is the one who grips the weak and holds them up. And the weak here are not so much the physically frail as those who cannot defend themselves.
ἀπεγνωσμένων σκεπαστής (apegnōsmenōn skepastēs), protector of the forsaken. A skepastēs is one who covers, shelters, puts a roof over someone. The forsaken are those who have been given up on — written off by others, or by themselves.
ἀπηλπισμένων σωτήρ (apēlpismenōn sōtēr), savior of those without hope — literally, of those who have despaired, who have stopped expecting anything at all.
Three of those titles — helper, protector, saviour — appear in the same order in the Greek of the Song of Moses after the crossing of the Red Sea: “The Lord became my helper and protector, for salvation” (Exodus 15:2, Greek version). Judith is praying in the language of the Exodus. And the biblical scholar Toni Craven noticed something more: in verses 11 and 12, Judith’s divine titles are arranged with care, five on either side of her plea, “hear my prayer.” On one side: God of the lowly, helper of the lesser ones, upholder of the weak, protector of the forsaken, saviour of the hopeless. On the other: God of my father, God of the heritage of Israel, Lord of heaven and earth, Creator of the waters, King of all your creation (9:12).
The same God is named from the bottom of the world and from the top. The King of all creation chooses to be called the God of the underdogs.
What is easy to miss
The woman who prays this prayer is not poor. She is one of the wealthiest people in Bethulia. And she names God by his relation to the people with nothing — and places herself among them, in sackcloth, as a widow. Her estate did not tell her who she was.
The end of her story confirms it. Judith lived to the age of one hundred and five. She set her maid free. And before she died, she distributed her property among her husband’s relatives and her own (16:23–24). She held her wealth the way Psalm 37 asks: open.
Honesty requires one further word. Judith asks God to bless “the deceit of my lips” (9:10; compare 9:13), and she brings down Holofernes by guile. Readers have long found this troubling, and they are right to think about it carefully. The Church reads the Book of Judith as a story of faith and courage in a desperate hour, not as a manual of tactics. Her prayer is its heart, and it is her prayer that has entered the Church’s memory.
Where this prayer leads
The vocabulary of Judith 9:11 runs straight into the New Testament. Mary sings that God “has lifted up the lowly” and “has helped his servant Israel” (Luke 1:52, 54) — and the Greek verb for helped, antelabeto, belongs to the same family as Judith’s antilēmptōr, the one who takes hold. When Paul begs to be relieved of a weakness, the Lord answers him: “My grace is sufficient for you, for power is made perfect in weakness” (2 Corinthians 12:9). Power there is dynamis; weakness is astheneia, from the same family as Judith’s asthenountes, the weak.
Power belongs to God, and he does not need the strong to exercise it. That was Judith’s faith. In a courtroom in Jerusalem, on a night we are about to enter, it would be put to its ultimate test.
For the new inventory:Power — God’s might does not depend on the strong. It takes hold of the weak.
Movement Three · The One Who Owned Nothing
7. “I Am”
Thursday, 5 November · Mark 14:62
“Jesus said, ‘I am; and “you will see the Son of Man seated at the right hand of the Power,” and “coming with the clouds of heaven.”‘”
Every voice we have heard so far has been speaking about what people own. Now we stand in a room with someone who owns nothing at all.
An inventory taken by night
Mark’s Gospel, which most scholars regard as the earliest of the four and which early tradition links with the preaching of Peter, tells the story of Jesus’ last night with stark economy. Read chapter 14 and watch how much is stripped away in a few hours.
His friends: “All of them deserted him and fled” (14:50).
The last possession of one follower: “A certain young man was following him, wearing nothing but a linen cloth. They caught hold of him, but he left the linen cloth and ran off naked” (14:51–52). It is one of the strangest details in the Gospels, and its meaning has been debated for centuries. At the very least, it shows us a man who saved himself by letting go of the last thing he had.
His freedom: “Then they laid hands on him and arrested him” (14:46).
His right to a fair hearing. He is taken by night to the high priest’s house, where the council looks for testimony against him and cannot find any that agrees (14:55–59). The Law of Moses required that a charge be established “on the evidence of two or three witnesses” (Deuteronomy 19:15). This court cannot even make its evidence agree.
And outside, in the courtyard, his most prominent disciple. Peter has followed at a distance and is sitting with the guards, “warming himself at the fire” (14:54). Mark’s Greek says, literally, that he warmed himself at the light — pros to phōs.
Mark arranges these scenes with deliberate art. The story of Peter begins (14:54), the trial is told (14:55–65), and then the story of Peter resumes (14:66–72), so that each scene frames the other. Inside, in the dark house, Jesus will be asked who he is. Outside, at the light, Peter will be asked who he is.
The answer
For most of the trial Jesus says nothing (14:61), like the Servant of Isaiah, who “did not open his mouth” before his shearers (Isaiah 53:7). Then the high priest asks him directly:
“Are you the Messiah, the Son of the Blessed One?” (14:61)
The Blessed One is a reverent way of avoiding the divine name. And Jesus replies:
Ἐγώ εἰμι — Egō eimi — “I am.”
It is the plainest answer to that question in any of the Gospels. In Matthew he says, “You have said so” (Matthew 26:64); in Luke, “You say that I am” (Luke 22:70). Mark’s version has no veil at all. Throughout his Gospel Jesus has silenced those who announced who he was (for example, 8:29–30). Now, bound, accused and alone, he says it outright.
Does Egō eimi mean more than “Yes, I am he”? In its immediate setting, it is first of all a clear affirmative answer to the high priest’s question. But Mark has used the same words once before, when Jesus came walking across the sea to his terrified disciples: “Take heart, it is I [egō eimi]; do not be afraid” (6:50) — a scene full of echoes of the God who “trampled the waves of the Sea” (Job 9:8). In the Greek Old Testament, egō eimi is also how God speaks of himself (for example, Isaiah 43:10). Many interpreters believe Mark wants us to hear that further resonance here; others caution against reading too much into a simple reply. It is wise to hold both: the answer is a plain yes, and it is a yes spoken by the Son of the God whose name is I am.
“The Power”
Then Jesus goes further, joining two passages of Scripture. “Sit at my right hand” comes from Psalm 110:1, where the LORD invites the king to share his throne. “Coming with the clouds of heaven” comes from Daniel 7:13, where “one like a human being” — literally, one like a son of man — comes before the Ancient of Days.
And Jesus calls God ἡ δύναμις (hē dynamis), “the Power.” It is another reverent substitute for the divine name, as the Blessed One was. Later rabbinic texts use the Hebrew equivalent, ha-Gevurah, in the same way; the Talmud speaks of Israel hearing the first commandments “from the mouth of the Power” (Babylonian Talmud, Makkot 24a).
Do you remember Wednesday’s verse in its Greek dress? “My strength and the might of my hand made for me this great dynamis.” Here, at the far end of the week, the word has found its true owner. The self-made man called his wealth dynamis. Jesus, stripped of everything, calls God the Dynamis — and claims a place at his right hand.
Notice, too, that the place is given. In Psalm 110 the king sits because he is invited: “The LORD says to my lord, ‘Sit at my right hand.'” In Daniel, the son of man does not seize the kingdom: “To him was given dominion and glory and kingship” (Daniel 7:14). The Catechism, explaining what it means that Christ is seated at the Father’s right hand, makes the connection explicit: it signifies “the inauguration of the Messiah’s kingdom,” the fulfilment of Daniel’s vision (CCC 664). Even the kingship Jesus claims on the night of his arrest is received, not grasped.
And the verb is plural: “you will see.” The judges will one day look upon the prisoner enthroned. The court sitting in judgment is itself under judgment.
The robe and the light
The high priest’s response is immediate: “Then the high priest tore his clothes and said, ‘Why do we still need witnesses? You have heard his blasphemy!'” (14:63–64). What exactly made Jesus’ answer blasphemous in their eyes is debated. Later Jewish law, recorded in the Mishnah, required the actual pronouncing of the divine name — which Jesus had carefully avoided. Many scholars therefore think the offence lay in the claim itself: to share God’s throne, and to come as the judge of his judges.
The man with the house, the office and the robe tears his robe. The man with nothing keeps the one thing that cannot be taken from him. He knows who he is before God, and he says so.
Outside, at the light, a servant-girl says to Peter, “You also were with Jesus.” And Peter, three times, refuses his own identity: “I do not know this man you are talking about” (14:67–71). Jesus, losing everything, kept his name. Peter, keeping warm, nearly gave his away.
Mark does not leave him there. On Easter morning the young man at the empty tomb tells the women: “go, tell his disciples and Peter” (16:7). The one who denied his identity is singled out by name.
What he would not grasp
Paul, writing perhaps a decade or so before Mark, had already put the meaning of this night into a hymn:
“Christ Jesus, who, though he was in the form of God, did not regard equality with God as something to be exploited, but emptied himself, taking the form of a slave.” (Philippians 2:5–7)
The Greek word translated “something to be exploited,”ἁρπαγμός (harpagmos), comes from a verb meaning to seize, to snatch, to grasp. Set it beside Deuteronomy 8:17. The self-made man had nothing he had not been given, and grasped it as his own. The Son had everything by right, and did not grasp. “Though he was rich, yet for your sakes he became poor, so that by his poverty you might become rich” (2 Corinthians 8:9).
For the new inventory:Identity — the one possession no court can confiscate: who you are before God.
The Song
“While I Have Being”
Sunday, 8 November · Psalm 104:33
“I will sing to the LORD as long as I live; I will sing praise to my God while I have being.”
After the tomb, the claim, the key and the courtroom, the week ends with music.
A walk through God’s property
Psalm 104 is one of the great creation hymns of the Bible, and it forms a pair with the psalm before it: both begin and end with the same words, “Bless the LORD, O my soul.” Psalm 103 blesses God for his mercy to sinners. Psalm 104 blesses him for the world.
It moves through creation almost like a guided walk. God is “wrapped in light as with a garment” (104:2). The waters are set within their bounds; springs run in the valleys; birds sing among the branches; the cattle graze; there is “wine to gladden the human heart, oil to make the face shine, and bread to strengthen the human heart” (104:15). There are cedars and storks, wild goats on the high mountains and small creatures sheltering in the rocks. The moon marks the seasons; the sun “knows its time for setting” (104:19). Lions roar at night; people go out to their work “until the evening” (104:23). There is the sea, “great and wide,” with its ships, and Leviathan, “that you formed to sport in it” (104:25–26).
Many scholars have noticed resemblances between parts of this psalm and the Great Hymn to the Aten, an Egyptian hymn to the sun-disc composed in the fourteenth century before Christ, under the pharaoh Akhenaten. Whether there is any direct connection is debated. But the comparison throws one difference into sharp relief. Near its close, the Egyptian hymn declares that no one truly knows the god except the king, his son. Knowledge of the divine belongs to the palace. In Psalm 104, the sun is not a god but a servant that knows when to set; every creature looks to the Creator; and the one who sings at the end is not a pharaoh but an ordinary worshipper. No one holds a monopoly on God.
Then comes the line that, for this week, matters most in the whole psalm:
“O LORD, how manifold are your works! In wisdom you have made them all; the earth is full of your creatures.” (104:24)
The Hebrew word translated “creatures” is קִנְיָנֶךָ (qinyānekhā). Creatures is the usual and entirely sound rendering here. But the noun קִנְיָן (qinyān) belongs to the vocabulary of acquisition and possession: Genesis uses it of the livestock and goods Jacob had acquired (Genesis 31:18); Proverbs uses it of everything a person gets (Proverbs 4:7). The King James Version translated our verse, “the earth is full of thy riches.” The root קָנָה (qānāh) can mean both to acquire and to create — Melchizedek blesses Abram by “God Most High, maker of heaven and earth” (Genesis 14:19), where older translations say possessor.
So the word carries a resonance that no single English word can hold. Without forcing the translation, we may hear in it, at the end of the walk through the whole created order, a verdict spoken in the language of ownership: the earth is full of what is yours. The cattle and the cedars, the ships and the sea, the wine and the oil and the bread — and the human beings who work until evening and call these things theirs — all belong to Someone else.
Breath on loan
And then the psalm shows what that means for the creatures:
“These all look to you to give them their food in due season; when you give to them, they gather it up; when you open your hand, they are filled with good things. When you hide your face, they are dismayed; when you take away their breath, they die and return to their dust. When you send forth your spirit, they are created; and you renew the face of the ground.” (104:27–30)
Even breath is on loan. The Hebrew uses the same word, רוּחַ (rûaḥ), for the creatures’ breath that God takes away and the spirit that God sends forth. Life is not a possession we carry about. It is a gift we are continually receiving — and one day, like a Roman usufruct, it returns to its Owner. The Church prays verse 30 at Pentecost and in the familiar prayer to the Holy Spirit: “Send forth your Spirit, and they shall be created; and you shall renew the face of the earth.”
בְּחַיָּי (bəḥayyāy), “in my life” — as long as I live. And בְּעוֹדִי (bəʿôdî), “while I have being,” built on the little word ʿôd, which means still, yet, more. Literally: “while I am still.” The psalmist does not measure his life by its possessions, or even by its years. He measures it by the length of a song. As long as I am still here, I will be singing.
Now look at the possessives in the last verses of this enormous psalm — after the oceans, the mountains, the vineyards and the stars. “My God” (104:33). “My meditation” (104:34). “My soul” (104:35). After surveying everything God owns, the psalmist lays claim to exactly one thing in all creation: the God who made it. My God.
This is the answer the whole week has been walking towards.
Three psalms, one word
Psalm 104:33 has a twin. Psalm 146 opens with almost the same words — “I will praise the LORD as long as I live; I will sing praises to my God all my life long” (146:2) — and then, at once, warns: “Do not put your trust in princes, in mortals, in whom there is no help. When their breath departs, they return to the earth; on that very day their plans perish” (146:3–4). Princes, like stewards, are breathing on loan. The same psalm describes the God who “upholds the orphan and the widow” (146:9) — Judith’s God.
And this morning, at Mass, the responsorial psalm is Psalm 63: “Because your steadfast love is better than life, my lips will praise you. So I will bless you as long as I live” (63:3–4). “As long as I live” is בְחַיָּי (bəḥayyāy), the very word of this week’s verse. And “better than life” begins, in Hebrew, with טוֹב (ṭôv), the very word with which Psalm 37:16 began the week. Psalm 37 said that a little is better than much. Psalm 63 says that God’s love is better than life itself. The week that started at the graves with one better ends at the altar with a greater one.
Simply because he is
The Catechism describes praise as the form of prayer that most directly acknowledges God as God, honouring him not only for what he does but “simply because HE IS” (CCC 2639).
Set that beside Thursday’s verse. Before the high priest, the Son said, I am. Here the psalmist says he will sing while I am still. Our still depends entirely on his am. We have being on loan, for a while. He is. And the best use of borrowed being is to sing to the One who simply is.
A word of honesty here, too. The psalmist’s “as long as I live” was probably written before Israel had a developed hope of resurrection; for him, the song may have seemed to end with the breath. Christians read it in the light of Easter and of the vision in the Book of Revelation, where “every creature in heaven and on earth and under the earth and in the sea” sings to God and to the Lamb (Revelation 5:13). The song, it turns out, outlasts the singer’s breath.
For the new inventory:Breath — on loan, and best spent on praise. And one true possession: “my God.”
The Inventory, Rewritten
The tomb at Silwan offered an inventory of one line: no silver, no gold — only bones. This week’s Scriptures have drawn up another. Gather its lines together and they read:
Wealth — made with a strength that was given. Mine to use; not mine to boast of. (Deuteronomy 8:17)
Salvation — never purchased, never carried home. Brought near, as a gift, to the far-off. (Isaiah 46:13)
Office — a robe that can be put on someone else. Never a monument to oneself. (Isaiah 22:15–21)
Authority — a key carried on the shoulder for the sake of the house. (Isaiah 22:22)
Enough — a little, held open, is better than much held tight. (Psalm 37:16)
Power — God’s might does not depend on the strong. It takes hold of the weak. (Judith 9:11)
Identity — the one possession no court can confiscate: who you are before God. (Mark 14:62)
Breath — on loan, and best spent on praise. And one true possession: my God.(Psalm 104:33)
Read as a whole, the week seems to teach three things that are easily missed.
First, Scripture is not against having. It is against claiming. Deuteronomy calls the land good and commands a feast. Psalm 37 promises an inheritance. Judith keeps an estate. Isaiah gives Eliakim real authority. What every one of these texts resists is the sentence in the heart that turns a gift into a title: my hand made this.
Second, the opposite of grasping is not merely giving things away. It is possessing the right Thing. We tend to think the cure for greed is simply to own less. The Bible’s deepest answer is stranger and more generous. The priests of Israel were given no land, because, God said, “I am your share and your possession” (Numbers 18:20). “The LORD is my chosen portion and my cup,” sings Psalm 16:5. And the psalmist of Psalm 104, surveying the whole of God’s property, claims only “my God.” The one thing Scripture lets us call our own, without qualification, is not a thing at all. It is God, who gives himself to be ours.
Third, the God who owns everything chooses to be named by those who own nothing.God of the lowly.Helper of the lesser ones. And in Mark’s courtroom, the Son who could have claimed everything stands with nothing — and, in that poverty, names God the Power and speaks of his throne. Paul’s question to the Corinthians becomes the question of the whole week: “What do you have that you did not receive? And if you received it, why do you boast as if it were not a gift?” (1 Corinthians 4:7).
Where interpreters differ
Honesty about the texts belongs to faithfulness to them, and several questions raised this week remain open. Whether the tomb at Silwan belonged to the Shebna of Isaiah 22 is possible but unproven. Scholars debate whether Isaiah 22:24–25 belongs to the original oracle or reflects a later moment, and whether Eliakim’s key was literal or symbolic. The link between Isaiah 22:22 and Matthew 16:19 is widely held but rests on allusion rather than quotation. The date, setting and genre of Judith are uncertain, and its use of deception raises real moral questions. Interpreters weigh differently how much divine resonance Mark intends in Jesus’ “I am,” and what precisely the council judged to be blasphemy. And the relationship between Psalm 104 and the Egyptian hymn to the Aten — borrowing, shared tradition or independent creation — is still discussed. None of these questions changes what the week’s verses say together.
The Question Beneath the Week
Every one of this week’s verses stands at the meeting point of two ways of holding a life.
One way says mine. It says it quietly, in the heart, in the language of competence and achievement. It buys its gods and then has to carry them. It carves its name into the rock. It hangs its family’s cups on the peg of its office. It is loud — hāmôn, a roar of many things — and it is always slightly anxious, because whatever is truly mine can be truly lost.
The other way says entrusted. It works hard, and blesses God at the table. It carries a key, and uses it to open doors for others. It holds a little, and keeps giving. It calls God by the names of the poor, and finds itself among them. When everything is stripped away, it still knows its name. And it sings, while it has being.
So the tension at the heart of this week is not between wealth and poverty. It is between title and trust:
We claim to own what we were only lent — and we hold at arm’s length the One who has offered himself to be ours.
That is what this week asks each of us to confront. Not how much do I have? but:
Am I living as an owner or as a steward — and whose am I?
Living as Stewards
What does the week’s answer look like on an ordinary Monday?
At the table. Deuteronomy’s antidote to the self-made heart was a blessing at meals: “You shall eat your fill and bless the LORD your God” (8:10). Grace at table is not a pious decoration. It is a small, daily act of handing the title back to its Owner. A family that blesses God for its food is teaching its children, several times a day, that nothing on the table was simply made by anyone’s hand.
In work and achievement. Our age loves the word self-made. Deuteronomy 8:17 is the original self-made speech, and it is forbidden not because effort is wrong but because the story is false. No one is self-made. Behind every degree stand teachers; behind every promotion, colleagues who covered for us; behind every business, roads we did not build, laws we did not draft, and a body and mind we did not design. A Christian may be proud of hard work. A Christian may not forget the credits.
In office and authority. For anyone who holds a key — a public official, a manager, a headteacher, a member of a governing body, a priest, the office-bearer of a residents’ association, a parent — Isaiah 22 is a searching text. The key belongs to the house. Its purpose is to open doors for those who need them, as a father does for his household. Shebna’s temptation was to build a monument; the temptation of Eliakim’s household was to hang their cups on him. Both are with us still. The test is simple and severe: in whose interest am I using this key today?
In families and inheritance. Anyone who has worked near the courts knows how many family relationships founder on property, and how often a lifetime of affection ends in a partition suit. Psalm 37 calls what we pass on an inheritance — something received and handed on. Judith set her affairs in order and distributed her property before she died. Putting one’s own house in order — a clear will, settled papers, honest conversations with those who will come after — can be an act of love, and a quiet confession that we were only ever stewards.
In ageing and retirement. Psalm 37 is the counsel of an old man; Psalm 104 vows to sing as long as I live. Retirement can strip away titles that once seemed part of who we were. That loss can be frightening — or freeing. When the office is gone and the robe has been handed on, what remains is what Jesus kept in the high priest’s house: who we are before God. And praise, unlike employment, has no retirement age.
Among the lowly. Judith’s God is the God of the underdogs. Every household, office and parish has its lesser ones — the domestic worker, the contract labourer, the junior clerk, the elderly relative no one consults, the child with no one to speak for them. If God’s name is helper of the lesser ones, then one way to call on that name is to become, this week, the hand by which he takes hold of one of them.
In what we buy. Isaiah’s goldsmith is not out of business. A great deal of modern advertising is an invitation to purchase a small god — something that promises security, identity, belonging or rescue. Isaiah’s test still works: Can it move towards you? Can it answer when you call? Can it save you from trouble? If not, it is something to use, not something to trust.
A Rise & Inspire Moment
In many older households — in Kerala as in Lisbon or Lagos — there was one person who carried the keys. Often it was the grandmother: a heavy ring of iron and brass at her waist, keys to the storeroom, the rice bin, the cupboard where the good plates and the land documents were kept. Nothing in that house moved without her.
And yet everyone who watched her closely understood something. The keys were never hers. They belonged to the household. She carried them for everyone who ate at that table — for the children who would one day marry, for the workers who needed their rice, for the guest who arrived without warning. And on the day she grew too frail, the keys passed, sometimes with ceremony and sometimes in silence, to another pair of hands. The house remained. The keys moved on.
That is Isaiah 22:22 in a single domestic image. And it is the whole difference between Shebna and Eliakim.
Shebna — or whoever lay behind that door at Silwan — carved: There is no silver and no gold here. He meant, do not bother robbing me. Scripture reads his stone and quietly adds the lines he left out:
The silver and the gold were never yours.The key was only lent.The breath was only borrowed.But the song was yours to give —and you may give it while you have being.
A key kept only for yourself stops being a key and becomes a trophy. Hold everything you have the way a steward holds a key: for opening.
Five Ways to Hold Things Open This Week
1. Bless the table (Deuteronomy 8:10). At one meal every day this week, before or after eating, name aloud one thing on the table and where it came from — the farmer, the cook, the shop, the rain — and then bless God for it. If you live alone, do it anyway. It is the simplest way to say, daily, my hand did not make this.
2. Write the credits (Deuteronomy 8:18). Choose one achievement you are proud of — a degree, a position, a business, a home, a book, a family. On paper, list every person who made it possible, including the ones you never thanked. Then, before Friday, thank two of them by name: a call, a letter, a message they can keep.
3. Use your key to open one door (Isaiah 22:22; Judith 9:11). If you hold any authority — in an office, an institution, a committee, a profession, a family — use it once this week to open a door for someone with no influence: a recommendation written, a pending file cleared, a fair hearing granted, a young person introduced to someone who can help. And decline one small privilege of your position that you have come to take for granted.
4. Put your house in order (Isaiah 22:24; Judith 16:24). Check whether your will, nominations and important papers are clear enough that what you leave will never become your family’s quarrel. If that is already done, choose one thing you intend to give away one day — and consider giving it while you can still see it received.
5. Sing before you ask (Psalm 104:33; CCC 2639). Each morning this week, before you ask God for anything, praise him for one thing about who he is — not for what he has done for you, but simply because he is. Once this week, read Psalm 104 slowly from beginning to end, aloud if you can, and notice every creature in it. And if you are at Mass today, listen for this week’s word in the responsorial psalm: “I will bless you as long as I live.”
Questions to Sit With
In Deuteronomy 8:17–18, what exactly does Moses deny, and what does he deliberately not deny? Why does the difference matter?
If a stranger examined the inventory of my life — my bank statements, my calendar, my phone, the way I speak about my achievements — what would they conclude I believe I own?
Where might I be behaving like Shebna — carving my own name into something entrusted to me for the sake of others? And where have I let others hang their cups on a peg that was never meant to bear them?
Who are “the lesser ones” in my world — at home, at work, in my parish or neighbourhood — and what would it mean for God to take hold of one of them through me this week?
Before this week is over, what is one thing I will hold open, one door I will unlock, and one moment I will set aside simply to praise God because he is?
A Steward’s Prayer
God of the lowly and King of all creation, the earth is full of what is yours, and so am I.
Forgive me the sentence I speak in my heart when no one else is listening: my strength, my skill, my hand. Every strength I have, you gave; every good thing I have made, I made with your gift.
When I am tempted to buy a god I can carry, remind me that you come near on your own, even to the stubborn, even to me.
You have laid some keys on my shoulder. Teach me to carry them for the house and not for myself — to open doors, as a father opens them for his children, and to hand them on gladly when my time is done.
Make me content with a little held open, generous with what I cannot keep, and quick to take hold of the weak, as you take hold of me.
Lord Jesus, who stood with nothing before your judges and did not grasp at what was yours, keep me on the night when everything is taken. Let me know who I am before you, and never deny your name to keep myself warm.
Breath of God, I have my being on loan. While I am still here, let me sing — not only for what you give, but because you are.
You are my God. Let that be the one thing I call my own. Amen.
What to Carry
Everything else you hold in trust; only God gives himself to be called your own.
Lamps, Oil and Entrusted Gold
This morning, across India and far beyond it, our Hindu friends and neighbours are celebrating Deepavali, the festival of lights. Many of our streets will glow tonight with rows of lamps. Rise & Inspire offers them warm greetings, as the Holy See does each year; the Dicastery for Interreligious Dialogue’s message for this year’s festival invites Hindus and Christians to forge pathways of peace together, recalling the fortieth anniversary of Pope Saint John Paul II’s day of prayer for peace at Assisi in 1986. Christians walking past those lamps tonight might remember this morning’s psalm, which pictures God “wrapped in light as with a garment” (Psalm 104:2) — a light no one owns, which falls on every doorstep.
Lamps are in this Sunday’s Gospel too. In the parable of the ten bridesmaids (Matthew 25:1–13), the foolish ones run short of oil and ask to borrow from the wise. The answer sounds harsh: “No! there will not be enough for you and for us” (25:9). But perhaps it says something this week has been teaching all along. Almost everything we have can be shared, lent, given away, handed on. One thing cannot. No one can lend you their readiness, their faith, their yes to God. That oil must be your own.
And next Sunday, the readings will carry this week’s question one step further. The first reading will be the portrait of the ʾēšet ḥayil, the “capable wife” of Proverbs 31 — that same word ḥayil that Moses feared would make Israel proud. Her ḥayil shows itself in this: “She opens her hand to the poor, and reaches out her hands to the needy” (Proverbs 31:20). And the Gospel will be the parable of the talents, in which a man going on a journey “summoned his slaves and entrusted his property to them” (Matthew 25:14). Entrusted. Not given away, not sold — entrusted, to be used well until the master returns.
So this Sunday’s question does not close tonight. It walks with us, like a key on the shoulder, into the week ahead.
What can you truly call your own?
Everything you hold, you hold for a while. The One who holds you is yours for ever.
Which passage of Scripture would you like us to open together in a future Sunday Series? Share it in the comments. The verse you cannot stop thinking about may be the very one another reader needs.
Rise & Inspire — Sunday Bible SeriesDepth over speed. Understanding over volume. Formation over information.
Written by John Britto Kurusumuthu
Each morning, His Excellency, Rt. Rev. Dr. Selvister Ponnumuthan, Bishop of the Diocese of Punalur, shares a verse from the Bible. The seven verses received over the course of each week are brought together and serve as the scriptural foundation for that week’s Sunday Bible Series.
I have forgotten most of the files that crossed my desk in the Government Secretariat. The notes I wrote, the matters I helped process, the deadlines that once seemed so urgent: nearly all of them have faded.
But I have never forgotten one man standing before me with tears in his eyes.
A File That Was More Than Just a File
At the time, I was serving as an Under Secretary to Government. Over the years, many people had approached me with grievances that had remained unresolved for far too long, their files moving slowly or lying unattended in some section.
One day, I came to know of a person with a disability whose pension had been stopped. His case had been pending for a considerable time in another section of the Secretariat. It was not my file. It was not even my section. No one would have faulted me for leaving it alone.
But I knew that he depended on that pension. So I intervened. I made enquiries, followed the matter up and stayed with it until it moved. Eventually, his pension was restored.
The Tears I Never Forgot
After his pension was restored, he came to see me.
He stood before me with tears in his eyes. His expression conveyed a gratitude that no elaborate speech could have communicated.
For the government, it was a pension case.
For him, it was his livelihood, his financial security and perhaps the restoration of a little hope in his life.
I did not feel that I had accomplished something extraordinary. I simply felt grateful that I had been in a position to help.
Why This Moment Stayed
I have often asked myself why this memory outlived so many that seemed far more important at the time. I see three reasons.
First, I saw the other end of the file. Most administrative work is invisible in its effects. A file leaves your desk, and whatever it does to a life happens somewhere you will never see. This time, the consequence walked into my room.
Research suggests this matters more than we realise. In a 2007 study, the organisational psychologist Adam Grant and his colleagues worked with university fundraising callers who raised money for scholarships but had never met anyone who received one. One group was given a brief meeting with a scholarship student. A month later, those callers had more than doubled both their time on the phone and the money they raised.1 Their work had not changed. It had simply acquired a face.
Here lies the inversion. We assume that our largest achievements leave the deepest marks. This memory lasted for the opposite reason: the act was small enough to be seen whole, from the problem to the person.
Second, it was not required of me. Assigned duties tend to blur together precisely because they are assigned. What we choose to do, when we could easily have done nothing, belongs to us in a different way. Perhaps memory keeps our choices more faithfully than our obligations.
Third, the thanks came without ceremony. There was no certificate, no citation, no entry in a service register. Formal recognition passes through procedure; tears do not. Perhaps that is why his gratitude reached me in a way no official recognition could.
Impartial, But Not Indifferent
A caution belongs here. Administration rests on rules, and rightly so. Rules protect citizens from favouritism, and an officer who acts on sympathy alone, outside procedure, can do as much harm as one who never acts at all.
But impartiality is not indifference. Treating every applicant without favour does not mean forgetting that behind every file is a person, often waiting anxiously for a decision that could change his or her life. Within the rules, there is almost always room for initiative: an enquiry made, a reminder sent, a question asked on someone else’s behalf.
When we forget the person behind the file, administration becomes mechanical. When we remember that person, it becomes service. Nor is this true only of government. Teachers, doctors, managers and anyone entrusted with responsibility towards others carry files of their own, whether or not they are called files.
A Face to Recall
In the last months of his life, Mahatma Gandhi left a short note that came to be known as his talisman. Whenever we are in doubt, he advised, we should “recall the face of the poorest and the weakest man” we have seen, and ask whether the step we are about to take will restore to that person control over his own life and destiny.2
For years, I knew that test as a principle. That day gave it a face. A restored pension may be a small administrative act. For the man who received it, it was exactly what Gandhi described: control over his own life, given back.
I no longer need to imagine a face when I apply that test. I remember one.
A Thought to Carry Forward
We seldom know which of our actions will last. The achievements we are proudest of may fade, while a moment we barely noticed may be remembered for a lifetime, by us or by someone else.
So here is one small practice. This week, look for one matter that has been waiting too long on someone else’s behalf: an application, a request, an unanswered message. It may not be your responsibility. Within your role, ask about it anyway, and follow it through.
You may never see the result. But somewhere, someone may remember the day a difficult situation became a little easier because you did not look away.
1. Adam M. Grant, Elizabeth M. Campbell, Grace Chen, Keenan Cottone, David Lapedis and Karen Lee, “Impact and the Art of Motivation Maintenance: The Effects of Contact with Beneficiaries on Persistence Behavior,” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 103, no. 1 (2007): 53–67.
2. Gandhi’s talisman is reproduced in Pyarelal, Mahatma Gandhi: The Last Phase, Vol. II (Ahmedabad: Navajivan, 1958), p. 65. Pyarelal was for many years Gandhi’s private secretary.
John Britto Kurusumuthu
Rise & Inspire · riseandinspire.co.in
In response to the WordPress Daily Writing Prompt, 07 November 2026: What’s a small moment from your past that you still think about years later?
Today’s prompt asks how I define success in life. My first answer: personal growth, meaningful relationships, inner peace and contribution to others. I still believe every word. But nobody could disagree with it, and a definition nobody can disagree with has not yet decided anything.
So here is a harder one. A successful life is measured less by what reached than by what we refused to do to reach it.
1. Both lists avoid the same question
We often measure success by what we possess, the positions we hold, the money we earn and the recognition we receive. Thoughtful people offer a kinder list: character, family, peace, service. Yet both lists describe what we hope to be holding at the end. Neither mentions the price.
More than three thousand years ago, the Egyptian Book of the Dead pictured a person at the end of life, standing before divine judges.1 The words prepared for that moment do not recite offices, estates or honours. They are a long list of refusals. I have not caused pain. I have not caused hunger. I have not taken milk from the mouths of babes.
3. The beggar and the salary
In fourth-century BCE China, Mencius said that if he could not have both life and righteousness he would choose righteousness.2 Even a beggar, he says, will turn away food that has been trampled on, though his life depends on it. Yet a man offered a huge salary will accept it without asking whether it is right.
So refusal is no luxury of the comfortable. Success itself often teaches us to stop refusing.
4. The poet who would not pass the verse
Tamil tradition tells of Nakkeerar, chief poet at the Pandya court in Madurai. A poor man came to claim the king’s gold with a verse composed by the god Shiva himself. Nakkeerar found fault with it. Shiva appeared and opened his burning third eye. The poet would not withdraw: “Netrikkan thirappinum, kutram kutrame.” Even if the third eye opens, a fault is still a fault.3
The story does not even claim he was right. It remembers that he did not bend.
5. The petty bureaucrat
In 1960 the same scene played out in a government office. Frances Kelsey was less than a month into her job at the US Food and Drug Administration when her first file arrived: a sleeping pill popular in Europe, expected to pass routinely. She asked for better evidence. The company visited, phoned her superiors and called her a petty bureaucrat. She held out for nineteen months. Abroad, meanwhile, thousands of children were being born with severe deformities. The drug was thalidomide.4
The greatest achievement of her career was an approval she would not give.
6. The fair objection
Refusal carries two dangers. It can become a boast, like the Pharisee who thanks God that he is not like other people (Luke 18:9–14). And clean hands can simply be empty hands: the servant who buried his talent harmed nobody, and that was exactly his failure (Matthew 25:24–30).
So refusal is only half the definition. Frances Kelsey’s refusal served children she would never meet. The Egyptian text itself moves on: I have given bread to the hungry, beer to the thirsty, clothes to the naked, a boat to the boatless.
I consider it a success when I can look back without being ashamed of the choices I have made, acknowledge my mistakes without losing confidence, and look ahead with curiosity rather than fear. Inner peace does not mean giving up ambition. It means pursuing our ambitions without allowing them to control our happiness.
Try this tonight. Write down three things you would not do, even for the promotion, the sale or the applause. Then ask when each was last tested. A refusal that has never cost you anything is still only an opinion.
A successful life is not necessarily the one that leaves behind the greatest fortune or the loudest reputation. It may be the one that can answer a simpler question: Can I live peacefully with myself?
What about you? When you look back on your life, what would make you say, “Yes, I have lived a successful life”? And what did you refuse, so that you could say it?
Notes for readers
1Book of the Dead, Spell 125, often called the Negative Confession. The earliest known examples date from the reign of Hatshepsut in the fifteenth century BCE. Quotations follow the translation on University College London’s Digital Egypt site. This is a ritual text, prepared for those who could afford a copy, so it records an ideal of a good life and not proof of any owner’s conduct.
2 Mencius (c. 372 to 289 BCE) was the leading Confucian thinker after Confucius. The passage, Mencius 6A10, opens with the famous choice between fish and bear’s paw.
3 The story appears in the Thiruvilaiyadal Puranam of Paranjothi Munivar, a Tamil sacred narrative of about the sixteenth century, and reached a wide audience through the 1965 film Thiruvilaiyadal. The king had offered a thousand gold coins for the verse. The reply is given in the form Tamil speakers quote today. In the fuller story, Nakkeerar is burned and later restored by Shiva. It is legend, not history, though poets named Nakkeerar are known from classical Tamil literature.
4 Frances Oldham Kelsey (1914 to 2015). The company withdrew its application in March 1962. It had already given trial tablets to American doctors, and seventeen children in the United States were documented with thalidomide-related deformities. President Kennedy presented her with the President’s Award for Distinguished Federal Civilian Service on 7 August 1962.
John Britto Kurusumuthu
Rise & Inspire · riseandinspire.co.in
In response to the WordPress Daily Writing Prompt, 06 November 2026: How do you define success in life?
Spell the word Malayalam backwards. You get Malayalam.
That is my answer to today’s prompt. Malayalam is the language of Kerala, where I spent most of my working life, and its name reads the same from either end. This has never solved a problem, won an argument or saved anyone a rupee.
It gets better. The trick fails in the language’s own script. Written മലയാളം, the word is no palindrome; its two l sounds, for one thing, are different letters. So the fact is not really about Malayalam, only about how the word happens to look in someone else’s alphabet. The language itself knows nothing about it.
I can hardly imagine anything more useless, and I intend to defend it on those terms.
1. The usual defence gives the game away.
Lovers of trivia have a comfortable reply to their critics: what we call useless knowledge is simply knowledge whose usefulness we have not yet discovered. In 1939 the American educator Abraham Flexner showed how radio grew out of the work of Maxwell and Hertz, men “without thought of use”.1
He was right about science. But notice the bargain. A useless fact may live only on the promise that it will one day pay. Flexner himself pleaded for “the abolition of the word ‘use’”. Nothing will ever be built on the backward spelling of Malayalam. If I defend it by its future employment, I have won it an adjournment, not an acquittal.
2. People have always spent real genius on such things.
In the seventh century the Tamil poet-saint Thirugnana Sambandar composed verses that read the same from the last letter to the first.2 Unlike Malayalam, they do it in their own script. The Greek line “Wash the sins, not only the face” does the same in Greek letters, and is said to have been carved on a font outside Hagia Sophia.3
A hymn does not praise better for being reversible. Holy water does not wash cleaner. Yet when people wanted to give their best, they gave skill that did no work.
3. A useless fact is the one thing we say that wants nothing.
Nearly everything that reaches us wants something. Advertisements want our money. News wants our attention. Advice, even good advice, wants us to change. This blog wants you to think, I admit.
A useless fact asks for nothing. That is why it crosses so easily between strangers in a waiting room. I hand you something worthless, we both know it, and for a moment neither of us is after anything. Try it today: offer someone a small fact with no moral attached, and stop there.
It may bring a smile, but a smile is a fruit, not a purpose. The moment I tell it to impress you, it has found a job and is no longer worth hearing. That is what is wrong with the guest who corrects every dinner table. His fault is not useless knowledge. He has found a use for it.
4. Some curiosity is only a way of hiding.
Here the critics have a point. In a Buddhist discourse, a man struck by a poisoned arrow refuses the surgeon until he knows the archer’s name and what the bowstring was made of. He would die, says the Buddha, with those things still unknown.4
I can know the history of every word and not know how my neighbour’s operation went. A useless fact is a fine dessert and a poor meal. Once it takes the place of something I owe someone, it has lost its innocence.
5. The harder question waits after retirement.
Retirement, changing responsibilities or the passing of years should never bring our learning to an end. Yet all our working lives we are asked what we are for. Then the asking stops, and we must ask what a thing is worth when it is no longer of use.
I had a glimpse of the answer on the old streets of Alexandria, Virginia, where I was known by no one. For the first time in years, nobody needed me to be anything, and I found I could simply be.
If everything must earn its keep, what shall we say of the aged parent in the next room, the infant who can do nothing yet, the friend whose illness has ended his work, and, in time, ourselves? The instinct that spares a useless fact is, on a smaller scale, the one that keeps a chair at the table for someone who can no longer pay for it.
You will say I have just made this fact work for nearly eight hundred words. I plead guilty. Tomorrow it goes back to doing nothing.
A fact need not earn its keep. Neither, in the end, need we.
What about you? Do you have a curious, unusual or seemingly useless fact that you love sharing? And do you believe any knowledge is truly useless?
Notes
1. Abraham Flexner, “The Usefulness of Useless Knowledge”, Harper’s Magazine, October 1939. Flexner was the founding director of the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton.
2. Sambandar, who is said to have died at sixteen, composed hymns to Shiva that form the first three volumes of the Tirumurai, the Tamil Shaiva canon. His reversible hymn, in the third volume, is in the form called maalai maatru, likened to a garland that runs the same from either end. Its first verse reads: யாமாமாநீ யாமாமா யாழீகாமா காணாகா / காணாகாமா காழீயா மாமாயாநீ மாமாயா
3.Nipson anomemata me monan opsin, attributed to Gregory of Nazianzus, a fourth-century bishop. It is a palindrome only in Greek letters, ΝΙΨΟΝ ΑΝΟΜΗΜΑΤΑ ΜΗ ΜΟΝΑΝ ΟΨΙΝ, in which ps is the single letter psi.
4. The Cula-Malunkyovada Sutta (Majjhima Nikaya 63), from the Pali Canon. The Buddha’s target there is speculation about the cosmos, not trivia. I borrow the picture for a smaller purpose.
Rise & Inspire — Strive to elevate in life.
John Britto Kurusumuthu
Rise & Inspire · riseandinspire.co.in
In response to the WordPress Daily Writing Prompt, 05 November 2026: What’s a completely useless fact you love sharing?